In this episode, the hosts explore the upcoming popcorn-making competition dubbed the Pop Off, with Greg expressing doubts about his skills against Dan, who is favored to win. Chris shares a humorous update about an encounter at Oktoberfest involving a mysterious toe, creating a comedic backdrop. As both hosts prepare their popcorn recipes under various challenges, the segment humorously chronicles their banter and the unique dynamics of their cooking styles. The tasting segment culminates in playful critiques of each other's popcorn, leading to a light-hearted showdown as they each vie for supremacy in flavor and presentation.