In this episode, Tegan and Sara recount the traumatic experience of being catfished, where a hacker posing as Tegan misled fans and manipulated relationships over three years. This incident occurred during their rise to fame, profoundly impacting their safety and trust, and altering how they interacted with their dedicated queer fanbase. Through discussions of identity theft, the emotional toll on fans, and the psychological motivations behind catfishing, the episode explores the complexities of celebrity and fan relationships, particularly in the context of LGBTQ+ representation and community.