Sign in
Arts
Society & Culture
Dylan John
Nature and the Nation explores politics, philosophy, psychology, sociology and economics from a naturalistic, paleoconservative perspective, using the format of a book review. I examine books published in a wide array of time periods, with a special emphasis on the early to middle 20th century, the ancient Greeks, and of course the present.
Review: William James' Essays on Faith and Morals edited by Ralph Barton Perry
In this episode I dive deeper into William James' lecture series Talks to Students with the essays On a 'Certain Blindness in Human Beings' and 'What Makes a Life Significant' as presented in Ralph Barton Perry's collection of James' essays, Essays on Faith and Morals. I look particularly at the practicality of this blindness and the balance between ideals and practicality.
01:21:2123/11/2024
Review: Ideas Have Consequences by Richard Weaver
In this episode I arrive at Richard Weaver's classic statement of post-war Conservatism, Ideas Have Consequences, in particular the the traditionalist, hierarchical, formal aspects of enduring culture.
01:05:3510/11/2024
Review: The Heart of William James edited by Robert Richardson
In this episode, I discuss William James' consequential essay Philosophical Conceptions and Practical Results and his lecture to students, The Gospel of Relaxation, as collected in The Heart of William James, edited by Robert Richardson.
01:04:4209/11/2024
Review: Darwinism and Human Affairs (Part 2) by Richard D. Alexander
In this episode I continue my examination of Darwinism and Human Affairs, this time exploring the connections between cultural evolution and genetic evolution. I focus on ways that cultural evolution both aligns with and betrays our genetic drive to reproduction.
01:28:4723/10/2024
Review: Darwinism and Human Affairs (Part 1) by Richard D. Alexander
In this episode I return to evolutionary theory, discussing the controversy surrounding group selection and its relationship with kin selection and inclusive fitness as described by Richard Alexander in his book Darwinism and Human Affairs.
01:04:2719/10/2024
Review: Talks to Teachers by William James
In this episode I look at William James' further discussions of psychology in Talks to Teachers, in which he draws on prior psychological writings to address the needs of teachers. I pay particular attention to the practical and pragmatic aspect of his discussion of competing drives and ideas, and his limited domain of the activity of the will.
01:05:0110/10/2024
Review: Pragmatism: The Classic Writings (Part 2) edited by H. S. Thayer
In this episode I return to John Dewey for a look at his essay The Practical Character of Reality, included in the compilation Pragmatism: The Classic Writings edited by H. S. Thayer. I focus on Dewey's examination of the nature of knowledge and awareness.
01:25:2701/10/2024
Review: Pragmatism: The Classic Writings (Part 1) edited by H. S. Thayer
In this episode I look at John Dewey's overview of the early history of pragmatism as described in Pragmatism: The Classic Writings edited by H. S. Thayer. I examine the major themes of pragmatism, including the importance of consequences, human conduct, the vaguery of ends, and the approximateness of knowledge.
01:21:5727/09/2024
Review: History of Political Philosophy (Plato) edited by Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey
In this episode I revisit History of Political Philosophy to look at Leo Strauss' examination of the political theory of Plato. I look at the attempts to define Justice, the viability of absolute communism, and make my first foray into Plato's theory of ideas.
01:24:0023/09/2024
Review: Plato by Constance Meinwald
In this episode I look at the classic text of Western philosophy, Plato's Republic, as detailed by Constance Meinwald in her wide-ranging book Plato. I focus on the early portions of The Republic dealing with the quest for a definition of Justice, including the arguments of Glaucon and Thrasymachus.
58:5516/09/2024
Review: The Trial of Socrates by I. F. Stone
In this episode I analyze I. F. Stone's critique of Socrates and his followers, as described in his book The Trial of Socrates. I focus on Socrates' hostility to democracy, the inadequecy of universalist philosophy, and the classical understanding of the gods.
01:24:5414/09/2024
Review: History of Political Philosophy (Thucydides) edited by Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey
In this episode I revisit Thucydides as discussed by David Bolotin in the classic History of Political Philosophy edited by Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey. I focus on Alcibiades, Nicias, and the Sicilian Expedition.
46:3101/09/2024
Review: Thucydides on Justice, Power, and Human Nature edited by Paul Woodruff
In this episode I look at the conflict between Democracy and Oligarchy in the Peloponnesian War as described by Thucydides and translated and abridged by Paul Woodruff.
59:0625/08/2024
Review: Social Darwinism in American Thought by Richard Hofstadter
In this episode I look at the late 19th Century Darwinian Conservatism of Herbert Spencer, William Graham Sumner, and reactions by William James and others as described in Richard Hofstadter's Social Darwinism in American Thought.
01:08:3523/08/2024
Review: The Social Contract Theorists (Hobbes's War of All Against All) edited by Chris Morris
In this episode I look at Gregory Kavka's 'Hobbes's War of All Against All' in The Social Contract Theorists edited by Christopher W. Morris, with a special focus on the prisoner's dilemma and nation size.
46:4010/08/2024
Review: History of Political Philosophy (Rousseau) edited by Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey
In this episode I return to Strauss and Cropsey collection, History of Political Philosophy, to focus on Alan Bloom's examination of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the general will, and the potential conflict between nature and custom.
59:0104/08/2024
Review: The Reveries of the Solitary Walker by Jean-Jacques Rousseau
In this episode I wander through Rousseau's final book, published posthumously, The Reveries of the Solitary Walker. I look at the difference between youth and old age, trusting yourself and others, and the nature of reverie itself.
01:07:4027/07/2024
Review: The Rise and Fall of Scottish Common Sense Realism by Douglas McDermid
In this episode I take a first look at Scottish Common Sense Philosophy as described by Douglas McDermid in The Rise and Fall of Scottish Common Sense Realism, with the aim of providing an overview of the major themes of Thomas Reid and his contemporaries.
01:23:0322/07/2024
Review: A Republic, Not an Empire by Patrick Buchanan
In this episode I examine Buchanan's case for non-interventionism, or isolationism, as made in A Republic, Not an Empire. I take a look a the League of Nations and US policy after the Cold War.
39:5802/06/2024
Review: Liberal Fascism by Jonah Goldberg
In this episode I look at Jonah Goldberg's examination of the fascist tendencies of President Woodrow Wilson in his classic book, Liberal Fascism.
01:09:3526/05/2024
Review: To Make Men Free by Heather Cox Richardson
In this episode I look at two Republican Presidents, Taft and Harding, as detailed in Heather Cox Richardson's history of the Republican Party, To Make Men Free.
56:0119/05/2024
The Pursuit of Certainty by Shirley Robin Letwin
In this episode I look at Letwin's collection of philosophical biographies, The Pursuit of Certainty, with a special focus on David Hume and his thoughts on virtue, prudence, and politics.
39:4211/05/2024
Review: The True Believer by Eric Hoffer
In this episode, I explore Eric Hoffer's description of the various types of people that constitute the leaders and followers of mass movements, as described in his classic 1951 book, The True Believer.
51:2121/04/2024
Review: The Sophists by W. K. C. Guthrie
In this episode I examine the competing forces of Physis (Nature) and Nomos (Custom) as detailed in the erudite examination The Sophists by W. K. C. Guthrie.
01:15:1014/04/2024
Review: From Religion to Philosophy by F. M. Cornford
In this episode I examine the connections between Nomos, Physis, and Moira in early Greek philosophy as detailed by Cornford in From Religion to Philosophy.
01:01:1307/04/2024
Review: The Iliad by Homer
In this episode I look at the violent glory of war in Homer's Iliad, as detailed in Bernard Knox's introduction to the Robert Fagles translation of this classic epic poem of war, and several choice readings of the battle for the Argive ships.
43:5831/03/2024
Review: Sailing the Wine Dark Sea by Thomas Cahill
In this episode I look at Thomas Cahill's examination of Ancient Greece in Sailing the Wine Dark Sea: Why the Greeks Matter. I pay special attention to the first three chapter where Cahill discusses Homer and his great works, The Iliad and the Odessey.
50:3523/03/2024
Review: History of Political Philosophy (Hume) edited by Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey
In this episode I explore another essay in Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey's massive History of Political Philosophy 3rd Edition. This time it's David Hume and his so-called skepticism, which I call into question on account of his deference to habit and custom. This episode is the fourth of a series.
35:0923/03/2024
Review: History of Political Philosophy (Montesquieu) edited by Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey
In this episode I explore another essays in Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey's massive History of Political Philosophy 3rd Edition, this time looking at an essay by David Lowenthal that discusses Montesquieu and the various types of regimes, and the English synthesis of them. This episode is the third of a series.
01:02:3509/03/2024
Review: History of Political Philosophy (Locke) edited by Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey
In this episode I explore another essays in Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey's massive History of Political Philosophy 3rd Edition, this time looking at an essay by Robert A. Goldwin discussing John Locke and his theories of the state of nature vs the state of war, and his thoughts on the right of rebellion. This episode is the second of a series.
01:15:5705/03/2024
Review: History of Political Philosophy (Hobbes) edited by Joseph Cropsey and Leo Strauss
In this episode I examine one of the many essays in Leo Strauss and Joseph Cropsey's massive History of Political Philosophy 3rd Edition, detailing the thoughts of Thomas Hobbes. This essay by Laurence Berns discusses the weaknesses of Hobbes' conception of sovereignty. This episode is the first of a series.
59:3426/02/2024
Review: Trade Wars Against America by WIlliam Gill
In this episode I revisit the history of trade policy in America, with Gill's book Trade Wars Against America. I look especially at the 2nd half of the 19th Century and Woodrow Wilson.
53:1507/02/2024
Review: Pragmatism: A Reader (Part 2) edited by Louis Menand
In this episode I revisit Louis Menand's collection of Pragmatist writings, Pragmatism: A Reader, with an eye toward the more recent writers. I discuss Richard Rorty's Postmodernist Bourgeois Liberalism and Richard Bernstein's Pragmatism, Pluralism, and the Healing of Wounds.
50:2527/01/2024
Review: Pragmatism: A Reader (Part 1) edited by Louis Menand
In this episode I look at some of the early pragmatist writings, in particular The Will to Believe by William James, and The Ethics of Democracy by John Dewey. This episode is the first of a two part series on this book.
01:33:5824/01/2024
Review: The Blind Watchmaker by Richard Dawkins
In this episode I look at the evolutionary exposition of Richard Dawkins in his classic The Blind Watchmaker, with a closer look at how DNA replicates and evolves.
33:5420/01/2024
Review: The Essential William James edited by John R. Shook
In this episode I look at a few of William James' early essays What Is an Emotion? and The Function of Cognition, and I make a particular examination of his essay The Dilemma of Determinism.
01:16:1412/01/2024
Review: The Creation by P. W. Atkins
In this episode I examine the deterministic vision of the nature of the universe as described by P. W. Atkins in The Creation.
53:0707/01/2024
Review: Essays on a Science of Mythology by C. G. Jung and C. Kerenyi
In this episode I explore the myth of the divine child, viewed through both historical myths and the archetypes of the collective unconscious, in the collaborative book by both Carl Jung and Carl Kerenyi, Essays on a Science of Mythology.
01:07:3127/12/2023
Review: Patriarchs of Time by Samuel L. Macey
In this episode I look at the ancient Roman god of Saturn and the festival of Saturnalia, as described in Samuel Macey's Patriarchs of Time.
01:02:2323/12/2023
Review: The Cry for Myth by Rollo May
In this episode I explore the lack of myth in our modern world, as described by Rollo May in The Cry for Myth.
49:2021/12/2023
Review: The Power of Myth by Joseph Campbell
In this episode I look at The Power of Myth by Joseph Campbell, with a particular emphasis on his definitions of myth, archetype, metaphor, and transcendence.
58:1711/12/2023
Review: Free Trade Doesn't Work by Ian Fletcher
In this episode I look at the phenomenal book Free Trade Doesn't Work by Ian Fletcher. I focus on Fletcher's overview of trade deficits and his explanation of the theory of comparative advantage.
01:04:3209/12/2023
Review: The National System of Political Economy by Friedrich List
In this episode I look at one of the most important of protectionist treatises, The National System of Political Economy by Friedrich List, with a particular focus on Book 2: The Theory.
54:1829/11/2023
Review: The Nature of Economies by Jane Jacobs
In this episode, I look at the connections between ecosystems and economies, as described by Jane Jacobs in The Nature of Economies.
48:5218/11/2023
Review: Henry Clay and the American System by Maurice Baxter
In this episode I look at Henry Clay's attempts to get tariff legislation passed in the early 19th Century, in Maurice Baxter's Henry Clay and they American System.
40:5114/11/2023
Review: Economics in One Lesson by Henry Hazlitt
In this episode I look at the basic premise of economic theory as presented by Henry Hazlitt in his classic Economics in One Lesson. I look closely at his discussion of tariffs, and provide a counter-argument that examines the tax burden of tariffs and the elasticity of supply and demand.
01:15:5211/11/2023
Review: The Great Betrayal by Pat Buchanan
In this episode I examine the case for protectionism and against free trade, as described by Pat Buchanan in his book The Great Betrayal.
57:0631/10/2023
Review: The Republican Workers Party by F. H. Buckley
In this episode I look at several types of American Nationalism as described by F. H. Buckley in his book The Republican Workers Party. I argue against his position on Liberal Nationalism.
43:1622/10/2023
Review: The Will to Believe by William James
In this episode I examine the essay 'The Sentiment of Rationality' from William James' collection of essays, The Will to Believe. This essay shows the early signs of James' Pragmatism.
01:04:3414/09/2023
Review: Pragmatism: From Peirce to Davidson by John P. Murphy
In this episode I look at the origins of philosophical Pragmatism in John Muphy's Pragmatism. I look especially at Charles Peirce and his ideas about doubt and truth.
01:05:2209/09/2023