Canadian True Crime is a completely independent production funded mainly through advertising.You can listen to Canadian True Crime ad-free and early on Amazon Music included with Prime, Apple Podcasts, Patreon, and Supercast.
The podcast often has disturbing content and coarse language.It's not for everyone.Please take care when listening.
Hi everyone, and welcome back to a new season of Canadian True Crime.I'm Christy Lee.Thanks for joining me.And if you've just found the podcast because you saw my photo featured on Apple Podcasts Canada, a big welcome to you as well.
And a huge thanks as always to Apple Podcasts.You can find the Creators We Love feature on the browse page right now. Today, we have part one of a two-part series covering a case that many listeners have requested over the years.
It's the bizarre and frankly unbelievable story of Matthew Charles Lamb, the teenager dubbed Canada's first spree killer. On a hot summer night in 1966, Matthew grabbed his uncle's shotgun and took to a residential street in Windsor, Ontario.
He left a trail of victims in his wake.
The crimes he committed were shocking enough, but it's what happened to Matthew Lamb before his shooting spree and after it that really makes his story feel like it's been ripped from the pages of some pulpy psychological thriller.
Matthew found himself right in the middle of the infamous Oak Ridge psychiatric experiment in Penetanguishene, just one of the many strange turns his story takes.
This miniseries has largely been put together from the news archives, notably the Windsor Star and several books, including the definitive investigative book later written about the case called Watching the Devil Dance.
The author, Will Toffin, had a very personal stake in the case, as you'll find out later.He would describe the life of Matthew Charles Lamb as too strange even for fiction.Some might consider that an understatement.
This is the story of a teenage spree killer who slipped through the cracks of the system, coming up in just a moment.
When it comes to weight loss, no two people are the same.That's why Noom builds personalized plans based on your unique psychology and biology.Take Brittany.After years of unsustainable diets, Noom helped her lose 20 pounds and keep it off.
I was definitely in a yo-yo cycle for years of just losing weight, gaining weight, and it was exhausting.
And Stephanie.She's a former D1 athlete who knew she couldn't out-train her diet, and she lost 38 pounds. My relationship to food before Noom was never consistent.And Evan, he can't stand salads, but he still lost 50 pounds with Noom.
I never really was a salad guy.That's just not who I am.Even through the pickiness, Noom taught me that building better habits builds a healthier lifestyle.I'm not doing this to get to a number.I'm doing this to feel better.
Get your personalized plan today at Noom.com.Real Noom users compensated to provide their story.In four weeks, the typical Noom user can expect to lose one to two pounds per week.Individual results may vary.
The holidays are all about sharing with family.Meals, couches, stories, grandma's secret pecan pie recipe.And now you can also share a cart with Instacarts Family Carts.Everyone can add what they want to one group cart from wherever they are.
So you don't have to go from room to room to find out who wants cranberry sauce. or whether you should get mini marshmallows for the yams or collecting votes for sugar cookies versus shortbread.
Just share a cart and then share the meals and the moments.Download the Instacart app and get delivery in as fast as 30 minutes.Plus, enjoy free delivery on your first three orders.Service fees and terms apply.
This story takes place in Windsor, Ontario, on the Canadian side of the Detroit River.The evening of Saturday, June 25th, 1966, was a hot one in the city.The third day of a four-day heatwave where temperatures often hovered above 32 degrees Celsius.
The dark of night offered little relief. That evening, Anne Heaton was watching TV in the living room of a one-story bungalow she shared with her husband in Windsor's East End.
It's a place where cute bungalows are interrupted by blocky two-story wartime houses built in the 40s and 50s for thousands of returning veterans.
No age was listed, but from her photo on the front page of the Windsor Star, Anne Heaton looked to be in her late 40s or early 50s.Her husband was already asleep.
The Heatons were taking a big road trip the next day and had plans to leave Windsor early. Sometime before 10.30pm, Anne heard a knock on the front screen door.She clicked on the porch light and saw a man standing on the stairs.
He was lit from above, casting heavy shadows on his face.Suddenly she realised the man was holding a shotgun and he was pointing it straight at her.He said, I'm going to shoot you.
Anne Heaton would later tell the Windsor Star that by some miracle she stayed calm.She immediately shut off the porch light and backed away from the door, but the stranger followed her into the house.
Anne said he just stopped and eerily looked around the living room.He didn't shoot her.He actually seemed to be looking for something.
She could see now that he was a young, slight man with short, dark brown hair and quote, the youth just stood there looking scared.The gun was still pointing at me and he was about four feet away.I was never so scared in my life.
Despite her abject terror, Anne had the wherewithal to call out to her sleeping husband, yelling for him to go and get his gun and call the police.
This must have jarred the stranger out of his daze, as suddenly as he arrived he fled, heading towards the Heaton's backyard and the overgrown field behind their house.
Perhaps because of shock or maybe because keeping a stiff upper lip was very much the norm back then, Anne Heaton did not call the police that night.And evidently, her husband had been in such a deep sleep that he didn't hear her yelling.
So after having the fright of her own life, Anne decided to go to sleep too.The next morning, she did tell her husband what had happened.
mortified that a man with a gun had entered their home and threatened his wife, he insisted that they postpone their road trip vacation and head to the local police station right away.Detective Frank Chauvin was on desk duty that morning.
Like a lot of officers, he was tired.He'd been up most of the night investigating a wild shooting spree that took place not far from headquarters.
Anne Heaton gave her statement about the strange young man who entered their living room with a gun and then fled.She also provided a description of the gunman.
Detective Chauvin stopped what he was doing and asked the Heatons if they were aware of the deadly shootings just a few blocks away from their house at around the same time.They'd heard nothing, so he filled them in.
Four people had been gunned down for no apparent reason at all.Three of them were just walking down the street.The fourth victim was shot inside her house through her screen door.
The spine-tingling chill the Heaton's must have felt when they heard this would have only been amplified when Detective Chauvin gave them the physical description of that gunman.
Years later, Windsor author Will Toffin interviewed the detective for the investigative book he was writing about the case, called Watching the Devil Dance.Here's what Detective Chauvin recalled about his conversation with Anne Heaton.
Quote, Mrs. Heaton's face went pale when she realized her description of the armed young man at her home matched the physical description of the shooter.
I told her he was likely the shotgun killer that every police agency in southwestern Ontario was actively seeking."
It certainly appeared likely that this rampaging killer might also be the same gunman who made a terrifying stop in the Heaton's living room before slipping away into the night.
Edith Tchaikovsky didn't really want to go out that sticky hot June afternoon.Maybe it was the heat, or maybe she was just tired from working long hours as a nurse's aide.
Edith's mother had to nudge her 20-year-old daughter out the door to visit her brother Kenneth and his wife.
It was Saturday night and she only wanted Edith to go out and do some socialising, but her nudge that day was something she would always live to regret.
22-year-old Kenneth and his very pregnant wife Charmaine lived on Ford Boulevard in a small bungalow just a short bus ride away.Very few homes had air conditioning back then, so the trio spent the hot night chatting outside in the backyard.
At around 10 o'clock, Edith finally rose to catch the bus home.Even though it was late, she was comfortable navigating this neighborhood at night.After all, it was the same street where she'd lived as a child before her parents split up.
Still, at the last minute, Kenneth and Charmaine decided to accompany her to the bus stop. As the three of them walked in the direction of the bus stop, they ran into some old friends hanging out on a nearby lawn.
Andrew Woollock, Vincent Franco, and Don Malusa were the best of friends and around the same age as 20-year-old Edith.In fact, they'd all attended the same grade school and immediately began swapping childhood memories.
Andrew, Vincent and Don had been trying to figure out where to go that Saturday night.Do they hang out at the A&W or grab a drink at the Canada Tavern, a popular local bar?Either way, they'd also have to walk towards Edith's bus stop.
So all six decided to walk together. splitting up into three pairs.These are the kind of vivid details Vincent Franco recalled in a series of interviews he would later give to author Will Toffin.
Vincent was the only survivor Toffin could find who was willing to open up about that tragic night and their important details.
because what happened next was likely determined by the order in which the six of them were now walking, with Don Malusa and Edith Tchaikovsky at the head of the pack, followed by her brother Kenneth and his wife Charmaine, and Vincent Franco and Andrew Woolick.
The group continued in the direction of the bus stop, walking on the darker side of the boulevard, the side without street lights.They heard what sounded like a big party at a house up ahead.
And as they got closer, they could make out the silhouette of partygoers crowded in an open garage at the side of the house.It was later reported that this was a 25th wedding anniversary celebration.
Suddenly, the group was confronted by a dark figure who stepped out from behind a tree in front of the party house.He said, stop, put your hands up.He seemed to be holding what looked like a shotgun, but no one thought it was real.
Here's how Vincent Franco described the moment, quote, Remember those really cool toy guns sold back then?They looked like shotguns or those old-fashioned muskets.
You shoved a piece of cork into the barrel and when you fired, the cork made a really loud popping sound as it flew out of the barrel.That's what I thought it was.Edith Tchaikovsky likely thought the same thing and quickly stepped around the man.
That's when they heard the loud crack of a gunshot.They watched Edith fall flat on the ground in front of them, shot in the back at close range.The rest of the group stood there in complete shock, unable to comprehend what had just happened.
The party goers up the driveway were still oblivious, perhaps thinking someone had set off a firecracker. Again, the strange figure yelled, hands up!Seized by terror, this time, Andrew Woolock complied.
As he shakily lifted his hands, the gunman shot him too, this time in the abdomen.Some of the pellets hit Edith's brother Kenneth in the arm and hip. Mayhem broke out.
Vincent Franco rushed in the direction of the party with a wounded Kenneth and his pregnant wife Charmaine.They frantically warned people that someone was out in front of the house shooting people.
Vincent grabbed a beer bottle and, like out of a western movie, smashed it in order to create a jagged weapon, in case the gunman was in pursuit. Meanwhile, Don Malusa knelt down beside Edith.
He assumed his former classmate was already dead, though he told the Windsor Star she tried to mumble some words but he couldn't understand her.That's when he ran to a nearby house, banging on the door for the occupants to call the police.
By then, the gunman was gone. It was later discovered that he had discarded his spent shells and reloaded while running away from the scene.
Across the street, 19-year-old Grace Dunlop was watching TV in her living room while her fiancé David sat in the kitchen repairing fishing nets. Like the Heaton's, they also had plans to head out the next morning for some fishing.
And while David didn't think much of the loud noises, Grace was startled.She decided to investigate.She turned on the side light and made her way down the short flight of stairs to peer down the driveway.
At that exact moment, the gunman came running past her screen door.He saw Grace's silhouette. Then he shot her too, at close range.The sound of the bullets crashing through the screen door nearly sent David flying off his chair.
He ran towards his fiancée, now slumped forward on the stairs.The gunman was now one street over, making his way to Anne Heaton's house. We know he spooked her on the porch, then followed her into her house.
He stood dazed in her living room, pointing his gun at her.But when Anne called out for her husband, he disappeared into the dark of night, just as all four of his victims were being rushed to the hospital.
To deal with this unprecedented medical emergency, the hospital had to call 15 emergency blood donors in the middle of the night.Windsor police escorted more donated blood from London, Ontario, two hours away.
The doctors spent all night trying to save Edith Tchaikovsky's life, but her head and chest wounds were too serious and she died aged 20.
Her 22-year-old brother, Kenneth Tchaikovsky, had suffered an injured right elbow and hip and would eventually recover from his injuries.But the trauma that his wife, Charmaine Tchaikovsky, suffered put her at risk of losing her baby.
She would remain closely watched for the remainder of her pregnancy.Only one of the three young men who walked with them to the bus stop that night was shot. Andrew Woollock was left in critical condition with serious internal injuries.
At one point, the Windsor Star reported that his condition had improved, but then it worsened, and he died 17 days after the shooting.He was 21 years old.
The Windsor Star described Andrew Woolock as a celebrated local athlete and second-year honour student in chemical engineering at the University of Windsor.
Unfortunately, it was the norm of the day to provide no such description for the women involved.Edith Tchaikovsky was often just referred to as the dead girl in media reports.
And although Andrew's two friends, Vincent Franco and Don Malusa, weren't shot themselves, they would never forget what happened that night.
Neither would 19-year-old Grace Dunlop, who suffered abdominal injuries to her right side from being shot through her screen door.She would spend eight days in the hospital recovering from palate wounds to her hip.She even lost a kidney.
The survivors may have recovered from their injuries, but mentally, none of them would be the same again.The following day, Monday, June 27th of 1966, the front page of the Windsor Star put all the dark facts together.
Above the headline that read, Youth Terrified City Housewife, were four words in bold, blocky letters.Charge Youth.Ambush Slayer. The day after the shootings, police quickly arrested a young man named Matthew Charles Lamb.
He was only 18 years old, but he was already very well known to the police.At the time, Matthew had been living with an uncle not too far from the murder scene.The uncle had tipped off the police after noticing his shotgun was missing.
Police nabbed him the next day while he was visiting with his grandmother. Here's how the arresting officer later described that moment to Will Toffin for his book.
Quote, Lam was sitting quietly on a recliner, shirtless and perspiring from the heat, drinking a beer as he watched television.
He was as calm as could be, quietly listening as I told him he was under arrest on suspicion of murder of Edith Tchaikovsky and wounding three others. Matthew Charles Lamb was charged with capital murder.If found guilty, he'd be hanged.
Matthew Lamb's story begins like too many of these stories do.He was a boy who didn't seem to be wanted by the people around him.His mother was just 15 when she had him, and when he was a baby, she left him with his maternal grandmother in Windsor.
His step-grandfather told the Windsor Star that he believed Matthew suffered from feelings of rejection from early on.Quote, And by occasionally, that meant a short visit every one to three years, according to court reports.
Matthew Lamb's step-grandfather claimed his early years were unremarkable.Quote, when he lived with us, we thought he'd grow up to be like anyone else.He appeared to be a normal boy.There was no evidence of any violence in those years.
It was after he left us that the problems with the police began. But Matthew's oldest friend, Gregory Sweet, gave the Windsor Star a very different account of his early years.
According to Gregory, his friend was sadistically cruel at a very young age.He claimed that Matthew once held a knife to a child's neck and forced him to eat dog feces.He always carried a knife and by the time he was 13,
He regularly had a gun on him too.Gregory also alleged that Matthew once walked down his street in Windsor and shot at the houses of the people he didn't like.
None of these incidents were reported to police, so it's only Gregory Sweet's account that we can rely on.Later, Gregory would tell author Will Toffin that Matthew locked his younger cousins in a closet.
issuing dire threats if they tried to escape, and that he once beat a cousin so badly that he required hospitalisation.
Matthew Lamb himself would later tell his defence lawyer that his step-grandfather used to beat him and often referred to him as that little bastard.
This was an era in which being born to a single mother or being from a broken home held a lot of social stigma. When Matthew's grandparents retired, they moved to a smaller house and sent him to live with one of his uncles.
For a while, he attended a local Catholic high school before dropping out in grade 10.After that, he cycled through a series of odd jobs, including a stint as a golf caddy.
Old friend Gregory Sweet claimed Matthew once caddied for singer Sammy Davis Jr, likely in town performing at the Ellwood Casino, where he was a fixture back in the 60s.
Apparently, Matthew told him that he thought it was wrong for a black man like Davis to have red hair.Gregory also said Matthew tried to join the KKK, but couldn't find a chapter on the Canadian side of the border.
Soon after he turned 16, Matthew Lamb finally faced the consequences of his escalating bad behavior.
In February of 1964, two years before the deadly shooting, he punched a police officer in the face at an arena where a Valentine's Day dance was taking place.It was a completely unprovoked attack.
He was also carrying a knife, a chain, and some brass knuckles. The assault marked the first, but certainly not the last, time Matthew Lamb's name made the Windsor Star.
For that crime, he was sent to a Christian-based juvenile facility for six months.
His friend Gregory told the Windsor Star that it was around this time that Matthew had made a collection of bullets, each inscribed with the name of a police officer he hated.
If there's one thing that my family and friends know me for, it's being an amazing gift giver.I owe it all to Celebrations Passport from 1-800-Flowers.com, my one-stop shopping site that has amazing gifts for every occasion.
With Celebrations Passport, I get free shipping on thousands of amazing gifts.And the more gifts I give, the more perks and rewards I earn.To learn more and take your gift giving to the next level, visit 1-800-Flowers.com slash ACAST.
That's 1-800-Flowers.com slash ACAST.
Ryan Reynolds here for, I guess, my 100th Mint commercial.No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.I mean, honestly, when I started this, I thought I'd only have to do like four of these.I mean, it's unlimited premium wireless for $15 a month.
How are there still people paying two or three times that much?I'm sorry, I shouldn't be victim blaming here.Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch whenever you're ready.
$45 up from payment equivalent to $15 per month.New customers on first three-month plan only.Taxes and fees extra.Speeds lower above 40 gigabytes.See details.
Ready to pop the question?The jewelers at BlueNile.com have got sparkle down to a science with beautiful lab-grown diamonds worthy of your most brilliant moments.
They're lab-grown diamonds are independently graded and guaranteed identical to natural diamonds, and they're ready to ship to your door.Go to BlueNile.com and use promo code LISTEN to get $50 off your purchase of $500 or more.
That's code LISTEN at BlueNile.com for $50 off.BlueNile.com, code LISTEN.
After Matthew got out of juvenile detention, he began a period of couch surfing.Sometimes he stayed with one of his uncles, sometimes a friend, but otherwise had no fixed abode.
It didn't take long for Matthew to get in trouble again, and the violence was escalating. The following account is from another old friend of Matthew Lamb from when he was younger.
This friend became an RCMP officer and after he retired, he agreed to speak with Will Toffin for his book, but requested to use the pseudonym Roger Hammond.
Roger Hammond told the author that he'd met Matthew Lamb at the Lakewood Marine, a store in the village of Tecumseh.It was a regular hangout for a lot of local boys, where you could buy boats and sporting goods, and also guns and ammo.
Buying firearms was easy back then. Lakewood Marine was owned by a couple of brothers named Bernie and Roy Desjardins.They often mentored the teenage boys that hung out at the shop, giving them odd jobs to earn some money.
Matthew Lamb and Roger Hammond were among them. This was the mid-60s, and one of the more popular things to do during any downtime was to go hunting for pheasants in the bush around the store.
The Desjardins brothers would lend the boys a shotgun if they needed one.Roger Hammond recalled that one time, he went hunting with Matthew Lamb, and after they bagged a couple of pheasants, they headed back to the store.
Out of nowhere and entirely unprovoked, Matthew suddenly shot the dirt behind Roger's legs.Roger said he felt the bullets whiz past him.He screamed, what are you crazy?You could have killed me.What was that all about?
Matthew just stood there pointing the gun at him.Finally, he let out a menacing giggle, repeating the words, I could have killed you. Roger Hammond defused the situation by downplaying it and trying to laugh it off.
Anything to get back to the store unscathed.When he told the Desjardins brothers what happened, they stopped allowing Matthew Lamb to have access to their guns.So he stopped coming around the store for the rest of that fall.
Then came December of 1964, Lakeview Marines' annual Christmas Eve party.The Desjardins brothers lit a cozy fire and allowed the boys they'd been mentoring a couple of celebratory beers.Matthew Lamb made a surprise appearance.
But what wasn't surprising was the fact that he was already drunk when he arrived.Most people who knew him back then agreed that he had a problem with alcohol and often drank to excess.For a while, he just hung out, enjoying the festivities.
He even played a little hockey on a makeshift rink.Then everyone left to be with their families on Christmas Eve as the Desjardins brothers locked up the store.
Roger Hammond was staying with his aunt at the time, and that aunt happened to be dating Bernie Desjardins, so Bernie offered Roger a ride home.
As they drove out of the parking lot, they both noticed Matthew Lamb sitting by himself on top of a snowbank. Rumor had it that the uncle Matthew was staying with at the time had just kicked him out, and not for the first time.
The 16-year-old probably had nowhere to be on Christmas Eve.Although Bernie Desjardins was racked with guilt for leaving Matthew there, he had plans to propose to Roger Hammond's aunt that very night, so they pressed on home.
No more than half an hour had passed when Bernie received a call from police telling him his store had been robbed.They wanted him to return to figure out what was stolen.
A police constable picked him up a short time later and the men headed back to Lakewood Marine.The first thing they noticed was the shattered storefront glass. A quick look inside confirmed that the thief had made off with some guns and ammo.
They decided to take a look around the perimeter of the property.Here's what happened next, according to Will Toffin's book Watching the Devil Dance.Quote,
The two men were approaching the dense underbrush when Bernie Desjardins suddenly stopped walking.He intuitively sensed danger and, using the excuse of poor visibility, convinced the constable to abandon the search until the morning.
So the two men had begun walking back towards the police car when gunfire suddenly erupted from the gully, two bullets just missing them. The men dove for cover.The officer immediately returned fire.
Suddenly from the dark, they heard a voice say, don't shoot, I'm coming out.
Bernie Desjardins was shocked that the figure who emerged from the dark with his hands raised in the air was Matthew, the same wayward teenager he and his brother had tried to take under their wing.
The news of Matthew Charles Lamb's arrest made the Windsor Star.He was now charged with possession of a weapon dangerous to public peace, breaking and entering, and theft.
He pleaded guilty in court, and given his prior conviction for assaulting a police officer, he was sentenced as an adult.
The presiding judge told the courtroom, quote, Fortunately, those willing to shoot at another human being in order to prevent apprehension are in the minority.When it occurs, however, it is conduct meriting a penitentiary sentence.
Matthew Lamb was sentenced to two years at Kingston Penitentiary, the mandatory minimum sentence for crimes of this nature.He was still only 16 years old.
Matthew Lamb's brief stay at one of Canada's most notorious maximum security prisons was reportedly marked by violence and a bout of suicidal depression. He was also punished with long stays in solitary confinement at Kingston Pen.
Then there was the night that guards found him in his cell, kneeling by his bed with a broomstick lodged in his anus.This was something prison officials deemed as deeply aberrant behaviour.
Will Toffin wrote that Matthew was sedated after that incident and diagnosed with hypomania, a milder form of the manic episodes we might now associate with bipolar disorder.
But not long after, he did it again, with a handle from a mop he was using while on janitor duty. Matthew claimed this time he was only joking, that he did it just to bother the guards.Nonetheless, he was sent for further psychiatric evaluation.
Along with his hypomania, he told the doctor that he was still having violent fantasies involving guns.Matthew was found to be quote, in a marginal state of mental pathology and a schizoid element in his behavior had developed.
Despite this poor prognosis and the fact that prison doctors deemed him a high risk for re-offending, he was released from Kingston Penitentiary after serving 14 months of his 24-month sentence.
By this time, he was 18 years old and returned to Windsor to live with one of his uncles, Stanley Haskith. who had a wife and two small children.
They only agreed to it on the condition that Matthew get a job, which he did, as a woodworker's apprentice making $80 a week. But it was only two and a half weeks later that Matthew Lamb took his uncle's shotgun and headed out into the night.
He shot four innocent people, sending Windsor police on a wild chase for a spree killer on the loose.He was last heard yelling, there are still more I have to get.
By the time Matthew Lamb made his first court appearance, the weapon had been found behind the Heaton's house. It was indeed his uncle Stanley Haskith's shotgun.Several witnesses also picked him up out of a lineup.
Plus, he already had a record of gun violence.Matthew was charged with capital murder, which carried an automatic death penalty in Canada at the time. What led Matthew Charles Lamb to commit such a crazed act?
Was he truly insane or was he really just a calculating killer?These are some of the questions that psychiatric professionals of the time were trying to get answered.
In the months leading up to the trial, Matthew was subjected to a barrage of psychiatric tests, all designed to determine what happened that night and whether he was fit to stand trial at all.
The first psychiatric test was conducted at the county jail in Windsor. During the one-hour interview with the doctor, Matthew claimed he couldn't remember shooting anyone.
And when informed that Edith Tchaikovsky had died, he reportedly giggled and said, poor broad. Here's how author Will Toffin describes the rest of that session in his book.
Quote, Lam dominated the interview, purposely avoiding specific questions about the night of the shootings.
Lam frequently changed the subject while strutting around the county jail's holding room, complaining how he just wanted a normal life like other kids his age.
then quickly changing tack by bragging of the money he'd saved for a new car, while cautioning the doctor that he had the kind of friends you don't mess with.
Lamb displayed all the classic traits of the violent psychopath, the self-centered sense of entitlement, grandiosity, and attempts to establish control over the interview process."
The Windsor Doctor came to the conclusion that Matthew Lamb had suffered from a temporary psychotic break and couldn't appreciate the full consequences of his actions. The doctor declared him legally insane or mentally unfit to stand for trial.
But the Windsor judge wasn't buying it.He sent Matthew to another psychiatric hospital, this time in St.Thomas, Ontario.There, the 18-year-old decided to tell a doctor what happened that night.
He recalled coming home from work to his uncle Stanley's house and drinking about eight beers. He watched a violent Western on TV, then fell asleep at about 9 o'clock.When he woke up about an hour later, He said he grabbed his uncle's gun.
Matthew told the doctor he found himself walking down Ford Boulevard in a kind of a trance.He came upon the group of young people walking on the sidewalk on the darker side of the street and started shooting.
He said it was as though, quote, another person committed the crimes. By the time he reached Anne Heaton's house, he said he had come to his senses, shocked to be holding a gun in his hand.
This doctor also reached the conclusion that Matthew was mentally ill, quote, coming out of an acute psychotic episode and was returning to sanity as he stood inside the doorway of the Heaton home, end quote.
Still, the judge sent him for a third series of tests, this time to the notorious Oak Ridge Facility for the Criminally Insane in Penetanguishene, Ontario.Built during the Great Depression in 1933,
It was Ontario's only maximum security forensic mental health care facility for more than 80 years.
There, Matthew Charles Lamb was examined by no fewer than five psychiatrists, including Dr. Elliot Barker, a name that will figure prominently later on.
All five doctors at Oak Ridge were unanimous in their belief that Matthew knew what he was doing that night and that he remembered it all as well.But they were split on whether he actually understood the gravity of his crimes.
Three doctors felt that he was incapable of understanding the consequences.The other two disagreed.They believed he was fully aware of how wrong it was to shoot those people.
During the tests, in the months leading up to the trial, Matthew Lamb remained behind bars, and his behavior was reportedly unremarkable.
But three weeks before the trial, he went on a bizarre three-hour rampage in the jailhouse, setting fires, breaking dozens of windows and damaging the plumbing.
This violent outburst seemed to come out of nowhere, a gift for the defence no doubt, who could use it to argue that he had a propensity to suddenly break with reality and lose control of himself.
Matthew's defense lawyer was a keen young lawyer from legal aid named Saul Nosanchuk.
If the name sounds familiar to listeners, that's because 14 years later, he would become the presiding judge in the Raymond LaRoche trial, a story we covered earlier this year.
LaRoche was the 19-year-old found guilty of manslaughter in the death of his seven-month-old son, baby Raymond.
As Matthew Charles Lamb's defense lawyer, Saul Nozenchuk's job was to gather all of the information and reports and begin to piece together his argument, that Matthew was insane, that he was not of sound mind when he committed these crimes, and therefore he couldn't be found guilty of murder.
This would mean that Matthew would have to forego any plea deals to lesser offenses, like say manslaughter or second-degree murder.This was a risky prospect and the stakes were high.
If Saul Nozomchuk's defense failed, his client would likely be found guilty and hanged.But if he succeeded, would that increase the chances of a psychopathic killer being back on the streets yet again?
Matthew Lamb's capital murder trial began in Windsor on January 16th of 1967, just over six months after the shootings.He had just turned 19 years old and he spoke only once on day one when he pleaded not guilty.
One of the first people to testify against Matthew Lamb was his own uncle Stanley, the one he was staying with when he took to the streets holding the shotgun that night.
Stanley Haskith told the jury that his nephew had only been released from Kingston Pen a little over two weeks before the shootings and described him as being well-behaved since, maybe too well-behaved.
Matthew reportedly asked permission for everything, from having a cigarette to taking a bath, a habit likely formed during his months behind bars.
On the night of the shooting, Stanley said he and his wife left their children with Matthew so they could enjoy an evening out, a date night.When they returned home after midnight, the neighborhood was blockaded by police.
The radio blared reports about a deadly shooting nearby.Inside the house, the kids were asleep.So was Matthew.Stanley said he had a bad feeling his nephew was involved.
That feeling was confirmed when he saw shotgun shells scattered across the kitchen table.He then realised his gun was also missing.
Stanley Haskith testified that he woke up his nephew to ask about his missing shotgun, quote, he said he didn't know what happened, but that he must have done it, end quote.
Matthew grew agitated with his uncle's questioning and eventually broke down sobbing before he fell back asleep.
Stanley told the jury that given his nephew's odd behavior that night and his propensity for violence, he decided to sit vigil at his kitchen table until sunrise.Then he went to the police. The survivors of the shooting had their day in court too.
There was Edith Tchaikovsky's brother, Kenneth, and his wife, Charmaine, and Vincent Franco and Don Malusa, Edith's grade school classmates who were walking to the bus stop along with Andrew Woollock, who lost his life.
Each provided similar descriptions of Matthew Charles Lamb from that night.A figure in the dark, devoid of emotion, behaving almost robotically.
Charmaine described him as, quote, small and thin-faced, adding that he looked dirty and unkempt, like someone just coming off work.She was able to clearly pick Matthew Lamb out of a police lineup, boldly placing her hand on his shoulder.
Grace Dunlop chillingly described how she could hear the gunman loading his gun seconds before he shot her through the side screen door of her house.She added, quote, it appeared to me as if he was weary.It was sort of a hunched walk.
Anne Heaton described how he stood in her living room looking around, seemingly confused and scared, before fleeing the house with his gun.Like Charmaine, Anne easily picked Matthew Lamb out of a police lineup.
Then, the court heard the heartbreaking details of Edith Tchaikovsky's death.Both ambulance attendants said she was in great pain as they tried to save her.She'd been shot in the back at close range.The bullets didn't even have time to disperse.
She took the full blast of the casings, which left a gaping exit wound below her navel. During the autopsy, they removed 31 pallets from her abdomen.
Bada, bada boom, sold.Huh?Just sold my car on Carvana.Dropping it off and getting paid today.
What, you still haven't sold yours?You told me about it months ago.I just... Is the offer good?
Don't have another car yet?
I could trade it in for this car I love.
Come on, what are we waiting for?
Let's go!Whether you're looking to sell your car right now or just whenever feels right, go to carvana.com and sell your car the convenient way.Terms and conditions apply.
Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile.With the price of just about everything going up during inflation, we thought we'd bring our prices down.So to help us, we brought in a reverse auctioneer, which is apparently a thing.
Mint Mobile Unlimited Premium Wireless!I bet you get 30, 30, I bet you get 30, I bet you get 20, 20, 20, I bet you get 20, 20, I bet you get 15, 15, 15, 15, just 15 bucks a month.Sold!
Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch.
$45 up front payment equivalent to $15 per month.New customers on first three month plan only.Taxes and fees extra.Speeds lower above 40 gigabytes.See detail.
Ready to pop the question?The jewelers at bluenile.com have got sparkle down to a science with beautiful lab-grown diamonds worthy of your most brilliant moments.
They're lab-grown diamonds are independently graded and guaranteed identical to natural diamonds, and they're ready to ship to your door.Go to BlueNile.com and use promo code LISTEN to get $50 off your purchase of $500 or more.
That's code LISTEN at BlueNile.com for $50 off.BlueNile.com, code LISTEN.
On day three of the trial, the first of seven psychiatrists who had examined Matthew Lamb testified, including the doctor from Kingston Penitentiary, the same doctor who signed off on Matthew's early release two weeks before he went on his shooting spree.
On the stand, the doctor reiterated that Lamb was in a fragile state when they released him from prison, likely bordering on psychotic.
At that point in the trial, survivor Vincent Franco reportedly disrupted the proceedings and yelled, then why did you let him out early?
The doctor never answered this question, but he did stress that the reason they didn't keep him in any longer was because he was showing signs of improvement.In the doctor's opinion, Matthew Lamb was not quote, certifiably insane.
The chief investigator would later tell author Will Toffin about this doctor's testimony and the impact it had on the defense's case.Quote, That psychiatrist who came down from Kingston Penitentiary was the most impressive witness in my opinion.
He said that the combination of factors such as Lamb's emotional state, the violent gunfights on a John Wayne television show he watched on the night of the killings, coupled with Lamb's drinking about eight beers in that unbearable humid weather, all came together in such a way that it set Lamb off on his shooting spree."
This same investigator said that he and Matthew Lem had become friendly over the months, having spent a lot of time together.
During a brief recess in court, Matthew reportedly told that investigator, quote, Those guys arguing in court are the crazy ones, not me. I'm fine.I know exactly what I'm doing.They should be getting treatment instead of me.
It's just that killing a stranger means nothing to me.It feels just like stepping on a bug."End quote.
Matthew had apparently made a similar comment to Dr. Elliot Barker, who drove down with three colleagues from Oak Ridge Mental Hospital for the Criminally Insane in Penetanguishene to testify for the defense.
They were among the doctors who believed the now 19-year-old was criminally insane and should be found not guilty. When the judge asked Dr. Barker if he thought Matthew could comprehend the true nature of his crimes that day, he replied, quote,
Another doctor from Oak Ridge who testified for the defense agreed, telling the court that Matthew once said, quote, I hate everybody on the street and I will probably kill someone else before I die.It doesn't bother me at all.
It's like stepping on a bug.This doctor added that Lamb was uniquely afflicted, quote, to me, he's no ordinary criminal.He's a sick man.
Violent, unpredictable, obsessed with guns and brimming over with resentment, these are familiar characteristics the average modern mass shooter might possess.But in the mid-60s, this crime, and this kind of criminal, was rare.
Matthews' defense lawyer Saul Nosanchuk was hoping the bizarre novelty of this senseless crime could only mean the shooter was not of sound mind, that a person had to be genuinely insane to commit such a widely random act of such brutality.
When Nosenchuk wrapped his defense, he was confident that he'd made the case that Matthew Charles Lamb was insane.
Whether it was stress, the hot weather, the alcohol, the violent movie, or a combination of those factors, something triggered in him a sudden and deadly break with reality.
Matthew was in some kind of psychotic trance with no sense of right or wrong when he shot those four innocent people, killing two.
Nosenchuk also reassured jurors that even if Matthew was found not guilty by reason of insanity, he'd still spend the rest of his life in custody at some kind of facility for the criminally insane.
The defense lawyer described the shootings as, quote, about as remarkable and grotesque a piece of conduct by a human being as anyone could imagine.
He ended his closing arguments by telling the jurors, quote, even without the evidence of any experts, your own common sense would tell you he was very seriously ill and had no capacity to appreciate what he was doing or perceive the consequences.
The position of the Crown Prosecution was that Matthew Charles Lamb knew exactly what he was doing when he left his uncle's house with a shotgun that hot summer night.That he was, indeed, a cold-blooded killer.
One of the first witnesses for the prosecution was a doctor that Matthew never saw in person.Still, it was his opinion that the 19-year-old acted out of hatred and bitterness.
He believed from what he read about Matthew that he set out to deliberately hurt someone that night, describing it as, quote, a disability or disorder of the mind, but not a mental illness.
This doctor added that Matthew was capable of, quote, the gamut of emotion, except guilt or conscience.He told the jury it's comparable to being a perfectly healthy person with amputated fingers.
The Crown painted a dark picture of a deeply disturbed young man who was manipulating the courts to stay out of prison.Quote, Would slick con artists have a field day in striving to be classified as insane and not criminally responsible?
Would the shrewd, psychopathic criminal have a much easier time in the hospital for the mentally ill than in a federal penitentiary?End quote.
Of the nine medical experts who testified at the trial, seven said Matthew Charles Lamb was insane and shouldn't be held criminally responsible for his actions.
The other two said that though he might have experienced bouts of insanity, Matthew knew full well what he was doing that night.Therefore, he should be hanged for his crimes.On January 20th of 1967,
The last day of the trial, the all-male jury was dismissed at 4.30 p.m.They deliberated for only two hours before returning with a verdict that same evening.They found 19-year-old Matthew Charles Lamb not guilty by reason of insanity.
In the days that followed, the Windsor Star ran competing editorials, including this angry one by columnist W. L. Clarke, who wrote, quote, The jury finding that Matthew Charles Lamb was not guilty by reason of insanity should cause plenty of mind and heart searching.
Two people are dead and no one has contended that they were not killed by Lam.A person who is insane is no less a killer.The result for the victim is equally fatal.What to do about these loonies?
How should they be placed in some sort of protective care? How can they be kept from breaking loose?On the flip side, another columnist, John Lindblad, agreed with the verdict, writing that Lam was,
Quote, The day of June 26, 1966 was a day of mad dog violence when Matthew Charles Lamb ran into the streets with a shotgun and shot a girl he never knew and fatally wounded a 21-year-old student, also a stranger to him.
It was just one of those mad things in a mad world, and for that reason, Correctly, a jury returned a not guilty verdict by reason of insanity.No other verdict was possible.Lam, a terribly mentally sick person, will be confined to a mental hospital."
The so-called mental hospital where Matthew Lamb was sent was the notorious maximum security Oak Ridge facility for the criminally insane in Penetanguishene, Ontario.And that's where his story takes yet another turn.
Matthew arrived just as the infamous Oak Ridge psychiatric experiment was getting started.And he found himself right in the middle of it.
Well, really, I don't feel any guilt about people I kill.I don't know them.They mean nothing to me.I can't even remember what they look like or anything.
I mean, here's two innocent people that I'd never met, never bothered me, never caused me any problem.We're good people as far as I know, you know, and I just shot them.
Thanks for listening.That, and a lot more, is coming up in part two, available in a week.
If you're listening ad-free on one of our premium feeds, look out for early release on Amazon Music, included with Prime, Apple Podcasts, Patreon, and Supercast.
As always, we'll be posting news clippings and photos mentioned in this episode on the Canadian True Crime Facebook and Instagram pages. The podcast donates monthly to those facing injustice.
This month, we have donated to the Canadian Resource Centre for Victims of Crime, who offer support, research and education to survivors, victims and their families.Learn more at crcvc.ca. This case was researched and written by Lisa Gabriel.
Audio editing was by Eric Crosby, who also voiced the Disclaimer.Our senior producer is Lindsay Eldridge, and Carol Weinberg is our script consultant.
Narration, additional research and sound design was by me, and the theme songs were composed by We Talk of Dreams.I'll be back soon with the final part of this series.See you then.
You've been waiting all year, and the moment is finally here.Bowlin Branch is the betting brand for better sleep, and their best sale of the year is happening now.
Right now, you can get 25% off the organic cotton sheets loved by millions of sleepers.They feel breathable, luxuriously soft, and get softer with every wash.Shop Bowlin Branch's cyber event with extended returns for the holiday season.
Hurry to bowlinbranch.com and use code BUTTERY for 25% off everything. Limited time only.Exclusions apply.See site for details.
If there's one thing that my family and friends know me for, it's being an amazing gift giver.I owe it all to Celebrations Passport from 1-800-Flowers.com, my one-stop shopping site that has amazing gifts for every occasion.
With Celebrations Passport, I get free shipping on thousands of amazing gifts.And the more gifts I give, the more perks and rewards I earn.To learn more and take your gift giving to the next level, visit 1-800-Flowers.com slash ACAST.
That's 1-800-Flowers.com slash ACAST.
Sign in
