In episode #546 of Small Town Murder, titled "Stairway To Heaven - Newfane, Vermont," hosts James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman recount a chaotic house party that leads to the tragic murder of the host, Glenn A. Michelson, found with a ski pole in his neck. The hosts explore Newfane's picturesque charm and community dynamics while weaving humor with horror, ultimately highlighting the absurdity of the events prompted by an unruly guest, Robert Plant, whose disruptive behavior spirals into violence. The episode juxtaposes in-depth research with comedic commentary on the grim subject of small-town murder.