Sharon McMahon (law and government teacher) AI transcript and summary - episode of podcast Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard
Go to PodExtra AI's episode page (Sharon McMahon (law and government teacher)) to play and view complete AI-processed content: summary, mindmap, topics, takeaways, transcript, keywords and highlights.
Go to PodExtra AI's podcast page (Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard) to view the AI-processed content of all episodes of this podcast.
Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard episodes list: view full AI transcripts and summaries of this podcast on the blog
Episode: Sharon McMahon (law and government teacher)
Author: Armchair Umbrella
Duration: 02:17:05
Episode Shownotes
Sharon McMahon (The Small and the Mighty) is a NYT bestselling author, podcast host, and known as America’s History Teacher. Sharon joins the Armchair Expert to discuss her favorite historical writers, how the government has been structurally set up, and what types of modern challenges the U.S. Supreme Court faces.
Sharon and Dax talk about the different types of democracies, the importance of constructively challenging other’s ideas, and how dangerous it can be to have blind allegiance to a party. Sharon explains why some people may feel burned out by politics, the problems with proportional representation, and the value of having multiple political parties.Follow Armchair Expert on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Watch new content on YouTube or listen to Armchair Expert early and ad-free by joining Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting wondery.com/links/armchair-expert-with-dax-shepard/ now.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Summary
In this episode, Sharon McMahon, an acclaimed author and educator, discusses the importance of civic engagement and understanding governmental structures. She highlights the dangers of blind loyalty to political parties, the impact of historical perspectives on current discourse, and the necessity of diverse political representation. McMahon delves into the roles of the branches of government and the implications of recent Supreme Court cases, advocating for informed political participation and the value of questioning one's own beliefs in a polarized society.
Go to PodExtra AI's episode page (Sharon McMahon (law and government teacher)) to play and view complete AI-processed content: summary, mindmap, topics, takeaways, transcript, keywords and highlights.
Full Transcript
00:00:00 Speaker_08
Wondery Plus subscribers can listen to Armchair Expert early and ad free right now. Join Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts, or you can listen for free wherever you get your podcasts.
00:00:13 Speaker_08
Welcome, welcome, welcome to Armchair Expert, experts on expert. I'm Dan Shepard and I'm joined by Lily Padman. Hi. Hi. We have, um, one of the most likable experts imaginable today.
00:00:24 Speaker_02
So fun.
00:00:25 Speaker_08
Sharon McMahon. I don't know. I'm going to be honest. It's make, I would say McMahon, but there is an H in the middle and I'm very scared.
00:00:32 Speaker_02
Yeah.
00:00:33 Speaker_08
Yeah. McMahon.
00:00:34 Speaker_02
McMahon. Yeah. McMahon.
00:00:36 Speaker_08
That's how Vince McMahon spells his last name. Vince McMahon. Yeah. They have, I noticed that when we were interviewing, cause I just watched the Mr. McMahon. I wonder if that's, I think they're related. Her dad. Yeah, her dad. It's not her dad.
00:00:50 Speaker_08
I know his daughter, she was in the doc. But anyways, Sharon is a podcast host, a bestselling author, and a law and government teacher. She's known as America's history teacher. And this was great. And we could have done six more hours.
00:01:05 Speaker_08
We didn't get enough. Get a really like fundamental understanding of how the government works. And she's just great. She has a very, very nonpartisan approach to trying to educate people on how all this works.
00:01:17 Speaker_08
She has a new book out now called The Small and the Mighty, where she profiles 12 ordinary Americans who really changed the course of history. It's a very hopeful and encouraging book. And she has a great podcast. Here's where it gets interesting.
00:01:31 Speaker_08
So if you want more of her, go. She covers every topic you might be curious about as pertains to the U.S. government.
00:01:37 Speaker_02
Someone posted something about her the other day, and I was like,
00:01:41 Speaker_08
She's huge.
00:01:41 Speaker_02
Yeah.
00:01:42 Speaker_08
Kristen was like, did you have Sharon today? Like Kristen follows her and is a devotee.
00:01:47 Speaker_02
Also, we should say we asked the arm cherries who they wanted as experts on, and she was the most requested.
00:01:53 Speaker_08
Yeah. Yeah. That's really relevant.
00:01:55 Speaker_02
Yeah.
00:01:55 Speaker_08
I almost forgot that.
00:01:56 Speaker_02
Congrats to you guys.
00:01:58 Speaker_08
You were right.
00:01:59 Speaker_02
And you were right. Not shot. Thank you.
00:02:01 Speaker_08
Thank you. And we'll do that again. Cause you guys are a great source. Last thing I want to say, and we get into it a lot. She and I have a very similar objective of hoping to bridge this insurmountable gap between everyone.
00:02:12 Speaker_08
She has a great movement in this direction and you can go to www.startswith.us. Not starts with us dot something starts with dot us.
00:02:25 Speaker_02
Oh, I like that.
00:02:26 Speaker_08
Yeah. Sneaky and wonderful sneaks. So go to www dot starts with dot us. Please enjoy Sharon McMahon. We are supported by Audible. Audible's best of 2024 picks are here.
00:02:42 Speaker_08
Audible's curated list in every category is the best way to hear 2024's best in audio entertainment. Like a stunning new full cast production of George Orwell's 1984. This is the one I am most excited to indulge myself with.
00:02:58 Speaker_02
I'm so excited to listen to James, which is a new title by Percival Efret that is very, very hot right now.
00:03:07 Speaker_08
Well, there's so many good ones on the list.
00:03:09 Speaker_02
We love Audible. This is how you go to bed.
00:03:11 Speaker_08
I love Audible, I swear by Audible. I can't wait to listen to the Orwell 1984 off this list. I'm also doing Flea's autobiography right now, which I'm obsessed with. I can't get enough Audible in my life, every night.
00:03:23 Speaker_08
Go to audible.com slash dax and discover all the year's best waiting for you. That's audible.com slash dax. We are supported by Audible. Audible's best of 2024 picks are here.
00:03:39 Speaker_08
Audible's curated list in every category is the best way to hear 2024's best in audio entertainment. Like a stunning new full cast production of George Orwell's 1984. This is the one I am most excited to indulge myself with.
00:03:55 Speaker_02
I'm so excited to listen to James, which is a new title by Percival Efret that is very, very hot right now.
00:04:04 Speaker_08
Well, there's so many good ones on the list.
00:04:06 Speaker_02
We love Audible. This is how you go to bed.
00:04:08 Speaker_08
I love Audible. I swear by Audible. I can't wait to listen to the Orwell 1984 off this list. I'm also doing Flea's autobiography right now, which I'm obsessed with. I can't get enough Audible in my life. Every night.
00:04:20 Speaker_08
Go to audible.com slash dax and discover all the year's best waiting for you. That's audible.com slash dax.
00:04:46 Speaker_05
Did you guys hire a designer to like do all your shelves?
00:04:48 Speaker_08
Rob.
00:04:49 Speaker_05
Rob, you're a designer too?
00:04:51 Speaker_08
He has such an aesthetic. Isn't that impressive?
00:04:54 Speaker_05
Styling shelves is actually a pain in the ass. It's hard to do. It's hard to do well. It just looks like cluttery junk.
00:05:00 Speaker_08
Tell me more, because you do video for your podcast.
00:05:03 Speaker_05
Yeah, I do. And I have shelves and I'm aware of what a pain in the ass it is. I like your sorting hat and your like- Little mice. A nice mix of tchotchkes and books. Yeah.
00:05:14 Speaker_08
So he did a perfect job. So blown away. And it's all Rob. He very thoughtfully thought of all these things behind us. She has more than I do. Let's not get hung up on that.
00:05:21 Speaker_09
Well.
00:05:23 Speaker_08
But some of the books we haven't read. Now, I would have insisted that only the books that we've read have made it up onto the shelf.
00:05:28 Speaker_05
But they have to be color coordinated. That's the thing. Yeah, it's a color thing. Yeah. You have to have the blues together, the reds together. Yeah, and those are obviously antiques.
00:05:37 Speaker_08
And I should just look at it as an opportunity to rise to the occasion.
00:05:40 Speaker_05
That's right. It's an opportunity to better yourself.
00:05:43 Speaker_08
If you, I'm sure you have, cause you're a history nerd. You have a fun term for yourselves, Governerds?
00:05:47 Speaker_05
Governerds.
00:05:48 Speaker_08
That's really cute.
00:05:49 Speaker_02
Oh my God, that's so cute.
00:05:50 Speaker_08
But have you read The Rise and the Fall of the Third Reich? Of course. Of course. Yeah. I think for people who don't love history, the notion of reading that book is preposterous. I can recognize how silly it is, but what a book.
00:06:03 Speaker_05
It's not a book to read because you think it's going to have good ideas. Right. But it's a book to read if you want to understand your enemies. Yeah.
00:06:10 Speaker_05
And that's actually an important part of being a good historian or an important part of understanding what's happening in the world. You have to understand what you're working with.
00:06:18 Speaker_08
What is your all-time favorite history book?
00:06:20 Speaker_05
Oh my gosh, that's like asking me to choose a favorite child. There's so many, there's so many.
00:06:26 Speaker_08
Give me top three.
00:06:26 Speaker_05
Okay, I have so many friends who are history writers.
00:06:29 Speaker_08
Oh, it's getting personal.
00:06:31 Speaker_05
Okay, if any of your friends are listening, pause it or plug your ears.
00:06:34 Speaker_08
We commit to wrapping this up in 30 seconds, so you want to hang out for 30 seconds.
00:06:38 Speaker_05
Okay, so David Graham is one of my favorite history writers. He wrote The Wager and he also wrote Killers of Flower Moon. Fantastic history writer.
00:06:46 Speaker_08
I'm embarrassed I've not read any.
00:06:48 Speaker_05
He's one of those people who when one of his books comes out, it stays on the bestseller list for like, oh, 17 weeks, 39 weeks. Okay, great. It sounds like he deserves it if he's your favorite. He does deserve it.
00:06:57 Speaker_05
And he also wrote a blurb for the front cover of my book, which I feel extremely honored. That's awesome.
00:07:03 Speaker_08
Yes, if your favorite historical writer.
00:07:05 Speaker_05
That's right, that's right. Yes, I also love Timothy Egan, who wrote a book called Fever in the Heartland. Did he write a blurb too? Yes. Yes.
00:07:14 Speaker_08
You got that pattern quick. You only needed one.
00:07:16 Speaker_05
That's right. I know. You're good at pattern recognition.
00:07:18 Speaker_02
I play connections. That's why.
00:07:20 Speaker_05
Yeah.
00:07:21 Speaker_08
Have you dabbled in Chernow? Is that too pedestrian for you?
00:07:24 Speaker_05
Chernow's great. He's a very serious historian. He doesn't write popular history. And there's a difference.
00:07:30 Speaker_08
Tell me.
00:07:31 Speaker_05
Academic history has a different audience than popular history. So if you think about the book Hidden Figures, that is a popular history book. It is meant for a broad general audience.
00:07:40 Speaker_05
It's meant for somebody to be able to pick up and read with their middle schooler or make a movie about. That's sort of the genre that David Graham and Timothy Egan work in. I do love academic history, though.
00:07:50 Speaker_05
And that's kind of where the Ron Chernows and the David McCulloughs and people in that genre, the John Meachams, they write in of different style and for a different audience.
00:07:59 Speaker_05
And it's really important work, but it's a little less accessible for the average person. You have to really be into it to pick up a book this thick about the life of one dude. You gotta be real into it.
00:08:12 Speaker_08
Or the building of a single bridge.
00:08:14 Speaker_05
Do you like reading books about people that you can sort of emulate or idolize?
00:08:18 Speaker_08
Almost the opposite. I really like reading books about people who are opposite of me. So George Washington, the fact that he never spoke. All I do is speak. I'm trying to impress upon everyone at all times that I'm smart.
00:08:31 Speaker_08
He became viewed as really smart by not talking in a group of men who talk too much.
00:08:36 Speaker_02
But in some ways, you do want to emulate that. It's different from you, but you found that admirable.
00:08:41 Speaker_08
And super aspirational.
00:08:43 Speaker_02
Yeah.
00:08:43 Speaker_08
Yeah. So it's almost like I want to dive into something that's the opposite of me and maybe find purchase or a toehold. Maybe I could strive to be like that.
00:08:49 Speaker_05
I'll tell you one thing about George Washington. Maybe you didn't know this. Maybe you did.
00:08:53 Speaker_08
I bet I didn't.
00:08:54 Speaker_05
George Washington, this is something that fascinates me about him, is that when he was appointed to be sort of the head of the army in the war against the British, he had never commanded a large army before.
00:09:04 Speaker_05
He'd worked in the Virginia militia, but he didn't have any like big general nationwide experience, not even at like a lower level where you often sort of work your way up. And so on his way to fight in the Revolutionary War,
00:09:18 Speaker_05
He had to stop by a bookstore and buy a book on how to be a general. And I was like, hmm, there's a lot to unpack there. George Washington had to buy a how-to book on how to be a general. That was such a thing back then. Yes.
00:09:35 Speaker_05
I mean, it wasn't like how to be a general for dummies, black and yellow. But if you think about it, he would have had to go into a small shop where all of the goods are kept behind the counter.
00:09:45 Speaker_05
He would have had to ask for a specific book on how to become a general. I think it's a great lesson for today in that how many of us feel like I'm not ready to get started because I don't know how to do that thing yet. Yeah.
00:09:59 Speaker_08
I'll wait till I'm ready.
00:10:01 Speaker_05
That's right. I'll wait till I finish the degree or have worked at that company for five years. When in fact, history smiles the most kindly on people who just went for it. People who just tried stuff, who just did something no one else had done.
00:10:14 Speaker_05
Sometimes they fail at it. George Washington had failures. In fact, he was almost fired from being the head of the Revolutionary Army. History does not smile kindly on the timid or the critics.
00:10:24 Speaker_08
Yes, which your book deals with exclusively, or that's the paradigm we're looking at. Yeah. All right, I'll add one. I like that he accepted that job and immediately bought a super fancy outfit.
00:10:35 Speaker_06
Yes.
00:10:36 Speaker_08
All out of his own pocket.
00:10:37 Speaker_05
I like that.
00:10:37 Speaker_08
He looked absurdly well-dressed compared to everyone else.
00:10:41 Speaker_05
He loved fancy outfits.
00:10:42 Speaker_08
He was like you, Monica. He had a total shopping addiction with this place in England. Half of his correspondence he wrote were ordering this bolt of linen or something.
00:10:51 Speaker_05
Velvets? Yes. He loved fancy wine, like Madeira wine. Is he me? Plus 250 slaves, but yes. Oh yeah, that part's not me. He had expensive taste.
00:11:05 Speaker_04
Unlike Abraham Lincoln, who's like, I grew up in a little log cabin and I had nothing and my clothes are too small. You know, like he has this vibe. I taught myself how to read. Oh my God, Dad says that all the time.
00:11:16 Speaker_08
We both might've had, oh, what's the disease? Marfan's.
00:11:19 Speaker_05
Marfan's syndrome.
00:11:20 Speaker_08
Yes, that's true. I have the phenotype of someone with Marfan's.
00:11:23 Speaker_05
Do you? No, you don't have Marfan's. I don't think you do.
00:11:26 Speaker_08
I don't think I do, but I am the phenotype of that. Really tall and lanky and gangly.
00:11:31 Speaker_05
Yeah, but you're not like excessively tall.
00:11:33 Speaker_08
That's only because I've packed on some muscle. I think if you saw me in 11th grade, you'd be like, that boy's too tall and skinny.
00:11:37 Speaker_05
No, see, I wouldn't. I'm six feet tall. That's true.
00:11:39 Speaker_08
You would have had a lucky night eye.
00:11:41 Speaker_05
I would have been like, finally, there's one person taller than me in this entire school. Oh, man. At what age did you become six feet? The best stage for any girl to be six feet tall. That's early, early, early, early.
00:11:56 Speaker_05
Oh, Shannon, that's really... It's real rough, you guys. Even in Minnesota, where people are above average,
00:12:03 Speaker_08
As Garrison would say.
00:12:05 Speaker_05
It's so rough. But of course George Washington was famously tall, too.
00:12:08 Speaker_08
He was in a physical specimen. It wasn't just that he was tall. It was the way he handled his horse. People would talk around the country of what a good horseman he was, like how athletic he was on a horse.
00:12:18 Speaker_02
That's you as well. That's also me.
00:12:20 Speaker_08
You're a great horsewoman.
00:12:22 Speaker_02
I can't really ride a bike, but that's fine.
00:12:23 Speaker_08
Well, what's great is you are going to educate us on a lot of things. We're going to talk about the small and the mighty.
00:12:28 Speaker_08
But before we do that, we're going to have some fun with all of the many lessons you're regularly giving out and are known to give out.
00:12:35 Speaker_05
I love it.
00:12:36 Speaker_08
I think the timing is pretty perfect as we enter an election. I think there's a lot of things people know and they're not quite certain really how it works.
00:12:44 Speaker_08
Like everyone knows there's an electoral college, but do they really know what that means and how it came about and what it means to democracy and whatnot? So you are our number one.
00:12:53 Speaker_08
We turned over to the armchairs who, what expert they wanted to hear the most. And you are number one.
00:12:58 Speaker_05
That's incredible.
00:12:59 Speaker_08
You won a poll.
00:13:00 Speaker_05
I won a poll.
00:13:00 Speaker_08
That is huge. Your nickname is America's government teacher, which is very endearing. I love that. Okay, so let's just get into your background a little bit. You're from Minnesota.
00:13:08 Speaker_05
I'm from Minnesota. I live on a dirt road.
00:13:11 Speaker_08
You still do?
00:13:11 Speaker_05
Yes, outside of a town of 80,000 people and 150 miles from the nearest Whole Foods. Oh, my God. Wow.
00:13:19 Speaker_08
So that means that at least the vaccine level is probably high where you're at.
00:13:23 Speaker_05
That's true. Yeah. But you know, I grew up in a lower middle class family. My dad was a blue collar worker.
00:13:29 Speaker_08
What was his trade?
00:13:30 Speaker_05
He was a carpenter. He was a disabled Vietnam vet who later died of his war related injuries. Oh wow. He didn't have enough food to eat and things like that. But there were times where each person got a $10 Christmas gift.
00:13:41 Speaker_05
So neither of my parents went to college. I certainly was not well positioned for this trajectory from my childhood. But what I did have was a library card and I did live one block from the library. And that was very instrumental in who I have become.
00:13:56 Speaker_05
The unfettered access to books has been super instrumental in what I do now.
00:14:00 Speaker_08
And then you ultimately became a teacher.
00:14:03 Speaker_05
I did.
00:14:03 Speaker_08
Where did you teach and for how long?
00:14:05 Speaker_05
I taught for 12 years in California. I taught up in the Bay Area. Oh, you did? I did.
00:14:09 Speaker_08
How'd that happen?
00:14:10 Speaker_05
My husband's job. And that was great. I've taught in Minnesota, but I taught for the majority of my career out in the D.C. suburbs. which is very different animal than teaching in the Bay Area. When I was in the Bay Area, it was middle class high school.
00:14:23 Speaker_05
It was like a performing arts magnet. Great people. I loved teaching there. But we had no hot water. We had no toilet paper or soap in the bathroom. Children carried around toilet paper in their backpacks. Wow.
00:14:34 Speaker_05
We had rolling blackouts all the time where the power would just go out. We did not have TVs in every classroom. The media center was closed because there was nobody to work at it. We did not have even like whiteboards and overhead projectors.
00:14:47 Speaker_05
I wrote a grant proposal to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation seeing if I could get whiteboard screens like the projector screens and the overhead projectors that people use.
00:14:58 Speaker_08
You mean the wax pen?
00:14:59 Speaker_05
I loved them. Like the transparency.
00:15:01 Speaker_08
I'm so jealous of the teacher getting it right with the wax.
00:15:06 Speaker_05
I discovered that 32 of the classrooms in my school did not have overhead projectors or the transparencies or the screens, nor did we have any of the other options to go along with it.
00:15:16 Speaker_05
Additionally, all of our textbooks had been destroyed in a water main break.
00:15:21 Speaker_08
And then it swelled to like 10 times their normal size.
00:15:23 Speaker_05
Yes, and then it exploded into the hallway. There was no budget to buy new books. The icing on the cake, every teacher had a $15 a month copy budget. You could make $15 a month worth of copies.
00:15:36 Speaker_05
And if you wanted more than that, it literally came out of your paycheck.
00:15:39 Speaker_08
Oh, geez, Louise.
00:15:40 Speaker_05
So we have no materials. Nice middle class area. Those were the conditions on the ground in the schools. Oh, moving to the suburbs of Washington, D.C., where people are absolutely rabid about public education was very eye opening.
00:15:53 Speaker_05
They have two billion dollar a year operating budgets.
00:15:55 Speaker_08
Wow. Are you in Maryland or Virginia?
00:15:57 Speaker_05
Maryland. Every supply you could ever want. And of course, the Maryland suburbs are very competitive with Virginia suburbs. Everyone wants to see who has the better public schools. So there's this sort of competition between the two.
00:16:09 Speaker_05
The one school that I worked in had five computer labs. It was just such a different environment than DIY toilet paper. Yeah.
00:16:19 Speaker_08
By the way, already you don't want to go number two at school. You want to hold it till you get home. But the notion that you're carrying your own toilet, I just imagine even if I knew that was necessary, I'd be like, I can't blow up my spot.
00:16:32 Speaker_08
If I've got toilet paper, obviously I'm up to one business.
00:16:35 Speaker_02
Well, for boys, it's different. Girls can get away.
00:16:37 Speaker_08
Yeah, you have a justified reason for toilet paper.
00:16:40 Speaker_02
But you could have said like, oh, it's for my girlfriends in case they forgot.
00:16:43 Speaker_08
All my girlfriends, I can't carry a lot.
00:16:45 Speaker_05
All my girlfriends. Wow, wow, wow. Here in California, they make you take this class about bloodborne pathogens. so that you don't contaminate the children when the kid's bleeding on the floor at the school.
00:16:55 Speaker_05
So you have to get this like certification in order to get a license to teach in California. And so I remember going to the Bloodborne Pathogens Workshop.
00:17:03 Speaker_05
They're giving you this whole spiel about like, and then you run your hands under more hot water and soap 20 seconds and blah, blah, blah.
00:17:10 Speaker_04
And I raised my hand and I was like, what if we don't have hot water and soap?
00:17:14 Speaker_05
Yes! Because we literally did not. All that to say, I've taught in a few different places and every spot in the country has their own educational vibe.
00:17:21 Speaker_08
Yeah, everything's got a culture. Okay, so in high school, you were teaching what? Government?
00:17:28 Speaker_05
History.
00:17:29 Speaker_08
History. And is one of those interests you more than the other?
00:17:32 Speaker_05
They're very related. You can't learn government without learning the history of government. So in terms of like a class that I preferred to teach, government was always my preferred class. I also taught upper class electives in law.
00:17:42 Speaker_05
Those are also a big favorite of mine.
00:17:44 Speaker_08
Let's quickly talk about how the government has been set up structurally.
00:17:48 Speaker_05
What's your understanding of it?
00:17:50 Speaker_08
Oh, God. So I think we have three branches of government. We have the executive. That's the president, the judiciary. That's our judges and the legislative. They're writing the laws. No way it's supposed to work is this group writes laws.
00:18:05 Speaker_08
This person enforces laws. And this group determines whether those laws are constitutional. So far, so good.
00:18:12 Speaker_05
That's roughly right. The judicial branch does more than just constitutional challenges, but that is part of what they're doing. Yes.
00:18:18 Speaker_08
OK, great. They're interpreting the law.
00:18:20 Speaker_05
That's right.
00:18:20 Speaker_08
I mean, they're still ultimately going this is unconstitutional. Do they have another knockout punch than saying that?
00:18:24 Speaker_05
Well, yeah, they can determine whether or not a certain governmental action, for example, is in the confines of the way the law was written.
00:18:31 Speaker_08
Oh, OK.
00:18:31 Speaker_05
So it's not just is this law constitutional? It is the way the Voting Rights Act was implemented in Alabama in keeping with the original intent of the Voting Rights Act or things along those lines, too.
00:18:41 Speaker_08
Interesting. So what percentage do you think is one of those two things?
00:18:45 Speaker_05
They hear far fewer constitutional challenges. Because a lot of the constitutional challenges have been adjudicated. We're still hearing new constitutional challenges.
00:18:53 Speaker_05
Like right now, the Supreme Court is just coming back into session and they are hearing a case this term. They work in these terms.
00:19:00 Speaker_08
Really quick. Yeah. The terms, are they quarterly or are they semi-annually?
00:19:03 Speaker_05
They start in October and they end in June and then they're done from July to September. I didn't know that. I already didn't know.
00:19:09 Speaker_05
They are still hearing emergencies during the summer, but they're not hearing their regularly scheduled or what they call oral arguments. They get about 7,000 requests a year for oral arguments, like, please take my case.
00:19:22 Speaker_05
And of those 7,000 requests, they take about 80 of them. So it's a tiny percentage of the cases that make it to the Supreme Court. One of the big cases they're going to be hearing this term is about transgender medical care for minors.
00:19:34 Speaker_05
and whether a state banning transgender medical care for minors violates their constitutional right to be free from gender discrimination.
00:19:42 Speaker_05
So, for example, if you are a teenage girl who wants to get breast reduction surgery because your back hurts and you have medical issues with the size, why is that permissible?
00:19:53 Speaker_05
But it's not permissible if you are a trans boy who wants to have surgery to be in alignment with your perceived gender. right, is one of those discriminating against somebody because of their gender.
00:20:07 Speaker_05
Of course, these are issues that the Supreme Court did not take up in 1792, right? So these are sort of like the new generation of constitutional challenges that are coming down the pike.
00:20:17 Speaker_05
Another case that they're hearing, the founders never would have seen this one coming, is whether or not a state law in Texas that requires the operator of a porn site to verify the identity and age of the
00:20:33 Speaker_05
in the state of Texas, whether that violates their First Amendment rights or not.
00:20:38 Speaker_08
Can I tell you the most crazy? This is such a Sim moment. I was in Texas three days ago. I was with my best friend, Aaron Weakley. He would not mind me telling the story. We slept somewhere.
00:20:49 Speaker_08
The next day we're chatting and he tells me he went to go on a pornographic website to do his nightly exercising. No. So then it had this really lengthy verification of age thing. And then he just decided I'll just watch TV.
00:21:02 Speaker_02
What?
00:21:03 Speaker_08
First of all, maybe that rule.
00:21:04 Speaker_02
And he's definitely of age.
00:21:06 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah, he's nearing 50. But I just found out that was a thing literally days ago because a friend tried to use a pornographic website in Texas. So that's already happening in Texas, Monica.
00:21:15 Speaker_05
Yes, it's already been implemented. And some people have sued. The porn site operators, of course, are not into this because people watch TV instead. But also your friend might not want his name to be recorded.
00:21:31 Speaker_08
you shouldn't necessarily have to give all of your documents to a website.
00:21:35 Speaker_05
But I understand the age component. Right. The other things like if you're going to purchase alcohol or you're going to purchase tobacco products, they have to verify your age. They can't just be like, oh, First Amendment. Right.
00:21:48 Speaker_05
So it's a unique question about how do we enforce the law to keep certain materials out of the hands of minors, but yet not infringe on the rights of adults. That's a legit question.
00:21:59 Speaker_05
These are things that people have not thought of before that are finally getting to be decided by the Supreme Court this season.
00:22:04 Speaker_08
And would you say because that right now you've already brought up one that's really great and complicated and has merits on both sides.
00:22:10 Speaker_08
Do you think people's general stereotypical view of how the Supreme Court is being used is that it's solely political? And in general, anything coming before is really going to align with either the left or the right.
00:22:23 Speaker_08
And that we know how they'll line up. Do you think there's a perception that's maybe not entirely accurate? So many of the cases that make the headlines are these kind of very politicized issues. Some of them are like, yeah, new thing has arisen.
00:22:37 Speaker_08
Very complicated arguments on both sides. Let's figure this out.
00:22:41 Speaker_05
There is absolutely a perception that the Supreme Court has been overtly politicized. The number of people who think that they're doing a good job, that everything's above board, non-biased, it's very low. This is one of the lowest points in U.S.
00:22:53 Speaker_05
history in terms of perceived legitimacy of the Supreme Court. And some of that has to do with abortion. The majority of Americans are pro-choice in at least some circumstances.
00:23:03 Speaker_05
I think some people don't realize that if you believe that there should be exceptions for things like rape and incest, that that actually falls under the purview of being pro-choice, that there are some circumstances in which abortion should be legal.
00:23:15 Speaker_05
Overwhelming majority of Americans think that. And so some people, they really, really view the Supreme Court's recent actions on abortion as delegitimizing the court.
00:23:25 Speaker_05
And then the other aspect of it is the ethics concerns related to a couple of the justices on the court now where they're taking all these trips with billionaires and they're not disclosing them and they're supposed to be disclosing them.
00:23:37 Speaker_05
And then they're like, oh, my bad, I didn't realize the form was supposed to be filled out that way. And it's a little bit like, but you're in charge of determining if people fill out the forms right.
00:23:46 Speaker_08
Well, also, one of the main things a court would point out is ignorance of the law is not a defense.
00:23:52 Speaker_05
Exactly.
00:23:53 Speaker_08
Yes. So that's kind of your job is pointing out that everyone's supposed to know.
00:23:56 Speaker_05
Right. And so one of the challenges there is people feel like I would never get away with that at my job. Yes.
00:24:02 Speaker_05
If you were just a normal federal government employee, let's say you just work in a Social Security office helping people get Social Security cards. There are very strict ethics rules that do not allow you to accept gifts greater than $20.
00:24:14 Speaker_05
I cannot send you a copy of my book because it costs more than $20. Right. And so there are very strict codes of ethics for federal employees.
00:24:23 Speaker_05
It's meant to make sure that things are transparent and above board and you can't just send gifts to grease the wheels and make things happen. happen and that it's treating citizens fairly.
00:24:32 Speaker_05
And so when you see that some Supreme Court members are taking trips with billionaires on private yachts and going to their private hunting, fishing retreats and the private jet trips, and it seems like the rules are for thee, but not for me.
00:24:50 Speaker_05
It makes people feel salty about it. Like, I would get fired if I let you take me out to lunch. It's easy for Chipotle to even cost more than $20. Yeah, exactly. If you just add on enough queso.
00:24:59 Speaker_05
Some Supreme Court justices have even talked openly about that, that when they go out to lunch with friends, they insist on paying for themselves. They do not even allow themselves to be treated by a friend to lunch to keep things above board.
00:25:11 Speaker_05
But that has not been the case with a couple of justices on the court. So all that to say that there is a perceived imbalance in terms of how political they have become to where they're supposed to be.
00:25:24 Speaker_05
The number of cases they hear that are unanimous, if you look at the number of cases they hear where at least one of the liberal justices is in the majority with the conservative justices, if you look at the number of cases where one of the conservative justices finds with the liberals, you would find a different pattern, however.
00:25:42 Speaker_05
you would find a pattern in which their behavior overall is not as politicized as the news would have us believe.
00:25:49 Speaker_08
Oh, that's really a shocking and be comforting.
00:25:52 Speaker_05
It's the big name cases. It's the heavy hitters. But it's the political cases that is the ones that get the attention. Exactly. And this is the other thing that's true about the court is that they take the cases they want to hear.
00:26:04 Speaker_05
They get to choose which cases they want to hear.
00:26:06 Speaker_08
What consensus has to exist?
00:26:08 Speaker_05
Four people have to want to hear the case.
00:26:10 Speaker_08
Out of seven.
00:26:11 Speaker_05
Out of nine.
00:26:12 Speaker_08
Just forgot my first big.
00:26:14 Speaker_05
No, keep it in. Well, that was nice of you.
00:26:17 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:26:17 Speaker_05
Got my first. Four people out of nine have to want to hear it. But here's the other thing is that there's not a law. There's no law that says four people have to want to hear it. They just decided that for themselves. They could change that at any point.
00:26:28 Speaker_05
They make all of their own rules. So yes, the tradition of four out of nine have to want to hear the case is just a tradition. There's no external governing body that dictates these things to them. So four people have to want to hear it.
00:26:40 Speaker_05
And the fact that they have a six person ideological consensus means that they are more likely to take up political cases.
00:26:49 Speaker_05
And so even though the majority of the cases are not highly political, the majority of the cases are kind of boring, they're administrative, they're pertaining to one specific criminal, doesn't extrapolate to the country at large necessarily.
00:27:03 Speaker_05
Even though that is true, the willingness of the court to take on these highly politicized cases like affirmative action, like abortion, like transgender medical care, because they now have a crucial majority who wants to hear a certain type of case.
00:27:16 Speaker_08
Meaning there's six of the nine are conservative.
00:27:18 Speaker_05
Yes, that's right. Two varying degrees. Even within the six, there's a spectrum.
00:27:23 Speaker_08
They'll shock you all the time. That's what's kind of fun.
00:27:25 Speaker_05
They feel empowered to take up cases that they maybe would not have felt empowered to take up before because they have a level of consensus amongst themselves that the case is going to be decided in a way that they feel is favorable.
00:27:38 Speaker_05
When it was 5-4 or when it was a more liberal swing to the court, the conservative members would not have advocated for taking up these cases because they know they're not going to be decided in their favor. And so now the opposite is true.
00:27:50 Speaker_05
The pendulum has swung to the right on the court.
00:27:52 Speaker_08
And am I right? I listen to more perfect. Did you ever listen to that podcast? So good. The Supreme Court's role has evolved over time.
00:28:00 Speaker_08
And as I understand it, they have gotten more overtly political, more about steering the direction we're going in as opposed to course correcting.
00:28:09 Speaker_05
I think that's absolutely true. The role of the court has evolved over time significantly. Members of the Supreme Court used to literally ride around on horseback to hear cases. They didn't even have a building.
00:28:19 Speaker_08
They were in the basement.
00:28:20 Speaker_05
They were in the basement of the Capitol. They didn't even have a building until the 1930s. And so if you think about the visibility of or the optics of we meet in the basement of the legislative branch.
00:28:31 Speaker_05
The optics are very different than the building they have now, which is like on the top of the steps with the big marble pillars.
00:28:38 Speaker_04
It seems very grandiose and official. Yeah.
00:28:41 Speaker_05
The way the court views its role is on a pendulum spectrum.
00:28:46 Speaker_05
If you think back to the 1950s, during the time when we were making rulings about things like Brown v. Board of Education, school integration, the person who was in charge of the Supreme Court at the time was a chief justice named Earl Warren, who was actually formerly the governor of California.
00:29:00 Speaker_05
He was also the only governor of California to ever have won both the Democratic and the Republican primary elections to be the governor. He won them both. Oh my God. So Earl Warren, very popular figure in California history at the time.
00:29:15 Speaker_05
He's a former prosecutor.
00:29:16 Speaker_08
Is the Warren Commission his name?
00:29:18 Speaker_05
Yes, same guy. Earl Warren was not a judge when he got appointed to the Supreme Court. He was the governor of California. Ah. Yeah.
00:29:27 Speaker_08
Was he a lawyer at least? Do you have to be a lawyer?
00:29:29 Speaker_05
Yes, yes. You actually don't have to be a lawyer. I could be on the Supreme Court. You could be on the Supreme Court.
00:29:32 Speaker_08
I like the time off. I like that there's a summer break still.
00:29:35 Speaker_05
All three of us can be on the Supreme Court. There are literally no constitutional requirements to be on the court.
00:29:39 Speaker_08
Even foreign born?
00:29:41 Speaker_05
No.
00:29:41 Speaker_08
Wow.
00:29:42 Speaker_05
The constitutional requirement is you have to be able to get approved by the Senate. That's it. And so if the Senate says you're good, then you're golden.
00:29:49 Speaker_08
Okay. God. I got to retract some statements, I think.
00:29:52 Speaker_05
It's too late for you.
00:29:57 Speaker_08
Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert, if you dare. We are supported by Amazon Prime. You might think of Prime as your gateway to incredibly fast free shipping on all your Amazon orders, which it definitely is, but Prime is so much more than that.
00:30:16 Speaker_08
Being a Prime member gives you access to Prime Video, Amazon Music, Prime Gaming, ultra-fast grocery delivery, and tons of other benefits.
00:30:26 Speaker_02
It's a game changer, especially during the holiday season. Want to get in the holiday spirit while relaxing at home? Press play on a holiday playlist on Amazon Music or stream a festive movie on Prime Video.
00:30:38 Speaker_02
You've got an instant ticket to holiday cheer.
00:30:41 Speaker_08
Sounds like a great night. Another way Prime saves the holidays, let's say a coworker got you a holiday present and you somehow forgot to get them something.
00:30:49 Speaker_08
Seamlessly shop for their gift on Amazon.com and then use Prime to get free one day or same day delivery. So it's like they were on your gift list all along. So what are you waiting for?
00:31:01 Speaker_08
Become a Prime member today and get more out of whatever passions you're pursuing. Whatever you're into, it's on Prime. We are supported by Expedia. Having an adventure on the books gives you somewhere to look forward to.
00:31:15 Speaker_02
The excitement, the anticipation.
00:31:17 Speaker_08
Just living in the fantasy of it. And that's why Expedia, Hotels.com, and Verbo have launched Unpacked 2025, an annual report on the trends and travel for the upcoming year. It's a great way to figure out where you want to go on your next adventure.
00:31:33 Speaker_08
We checked out the unpacked 25 site and it's really, really cool. They have a section called detour destinations that highlights lesser known cities near major travel spots. So let's say you're thinking of traveling to Cancun.
00:31:45 Speaker_08
Why not venture off the beaten path for a couple of days to check out Expedia's detour destination, Cozumel. Now, Cozumel, Mexico is fantastic. I've been. That's a great detour. Hey, maybe you could even make Cozumel your vacation's main destination.
00:31:59 Speaker_08
Because there's nothing better than traveling. But having a trip to look forward to is a close second. Book your somewhere to look forward to at Expedia.com slash unpack 25. We are supported by Sonos.
00:32:15 Speaker_08
Sonos is the world's leading sound experience company. They invented the smart sound system that makes it easy to play anything in any room, which we love. Sonos was the star of our Halloween party. I had it playing outside by the guest house.
00:32:28 Speaker_08
I had it playing in the garden. I had it playing in the kitchen. Kept the party rocking no matter where you moved.
00:32:34 Speaker_02
It makes a big difference.
00:32:36 Speaker_08
Yeah, the sound is so good. You really got to take your favorite holiday movies and holiday songs to the next level and experience them with Sonos.
00:32:45 Speaker_08
And with holiday gift season upon us, Sonos products are a perfect solution for that hard-to-buy-for person on your gift list.
00:32:52 Speaker_02
They've got amazing Ace headphones, and since, you know, we are podcasters, if you know any arm cherries in your life... Really smart. It's a great gift for them so that they can really get us in their ears properly.
00:33:05 Speaker_08
Whether you gift a sleek soundbar, a sturdy portable speaker, or our favorite headphones, your lucky gift recipient is sure to be impressed. Sonos has great gifts for everyone on your list.
00:33:15 Speaker_08
Visit sonos.com forward slash dax to wrap up your holiday shopping. That's sonos.com slash dax. We are supported by Addy.
00:33:27 Speaker_02
I know about Addy, the little pink pill, right?
00:33:29 Speaker_08
Yes, that's right. Addy is the FDA-approved pink pill clinically proven to boost desire in certain premenopausal women who are bothered by a low libido.
00:33:40 Speaker_02
I love this. It's really nice that there's an option out there for women who are dealing with low desire. And I like that Addy's non-hormonal and created by a woman for women.
00:33:50 Speaker_02
Addy is helping women feel like themselves again, and that's really important.
00:33:54 Speaker_08
It really is. So Armcherries, if your libido could use a little jumpstart, Addie's got you covered.
00:34:00 Speaker_02
Learn more at addie.com.
00:34:02 Speaker_08
That's A-D-D-Y-I dot com.
00:34:05 Speaker_03
Addi, or flavancerin, is for premenopausal women with acquired generalized hypoactive sexual desire disorder, HSDD, who have not had problems with low sexual desire in the past, who have low sexual desire no matter the type of sexual activity, the situation, or the sexual partner.
00:34:18 Speaker_03
The low sexual desire is troubling to them and is not due to a medical or mental health problem, problems in the relationship, or a medicine or other drug use. Addi is not for use in men or to enhance sexual performance.
00:34:27 Speaker_03
Your risk of severe low blood pressure and fainting is increased if you drink one to two standard alcoholic drinks close in time to your Addi dose. Wait at least two hours after drinking before taking Addi at bedtime.
00:34:36 Speaker_03
Your risk of severe low blood pressure and fainting is also increased if you take certain prescriptions, over-the-counter herbal medications, or have liver problems.
00:34:43 Speaker_03
Low blood pressure and fainting can happen when you take Addi, even if you don't drink alcohol or take other medicines. Do not take if you are allergic to any of the ingredients in Addi.
00:34:50 Speaker_03
Allergic reactions may include hives, itching, or trouble breathing. Sleepiness, sometimes serious, can occur. Common side effects include dizziness, nausea, tiredness, difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep, and dry mouth.
00:35:00 Speaker_03
See full PI and medication guide, including boxed warning, Addie.com slash PI or call 844-PINK-PILL. Addie.
00:35:06 Speaker_08
That's A-D-D-Y-I dot com.
00:35:17 Speaker_05
Anyway, Earl Warren gets on the Supreme Court, gets appointed by Dwight Eisenhower. Dwight Eisenhower kind of later regretted appointing Earl Warren because Earl Warren went about changing some stuff.
00:35:28 Speaker_05
He had been in charge of the state of California during the time period that the United States was actively incarcerating Japanese Americans during World War II.
00:35:36 Speaker_05
where we rounded up more than 100,000 people of Japanese ancestry and moved them into incarceration camps away from the Pacific coast because of the attack on Pearl Harbor. And those people were, by and large, U.S.
00:35:48 Speaker_05
citizens who had been accused of absolutely no crime. Many of them were children. They received no due process whatsoever.
00:35:54 Speaker_05
And Earl Warren cooperated with the Department of Justice and cooperated with FDR in the removal orders to move Japanese Americans to these camps. Later, he wrote about in his autobiography how deeply he regretted those actions.
00:36:09 Speaker_05
And then he spent the rest of his life on the Supreme Court trying to make up for the fact that he had deprived hundreds of thousands of people of their due process.
00:36:22 Speaker_05
And so he is the Supreme Court Justice who comes into position during Brown v. Board of Education. He's the person who steers the court to making sure it's a unanimous decision. He's the person who oversees Miranda v. Arizona.
00:36:34 Speaker_05
We've all heard of your Miranda rights. The right to remain silent. Everything you say can and will be used against you. That was a Supreme Court case under the Warren court.
00:36:42 Speaker_05
He was also in charge of Gideon v. Wainwright, which says that people have the right to a court appointed attorney if they cannot forward one.
00:36:49 Speaker_05
So the court saw a hard pendulum swing to the left under Earl Warren, in part because of his guilt over what he had done during World War II.
00:36:59 Speaker_08
Wow. Talk about making the best of a terrible thing.
00:37:02 Speaker_05
Yeah.
00:37:03 Speaker_08
That's admirable.
00:37:04 Speaker_05
Earl Warren's father was also murdered. He was a prosecutor at the time up in the Bay Area and he knows people that are investigating his own father's murder.
00:37:15 Speaker_05
His dad was literally sitting in his house one night and somebody broke into his house and hit him in the head with like a pipe and he was dead. And they get this line on like, we think we might be this guy. And it's a guy who's already in prison.
00:37:27 Speaker_05
If you wanted, we could like put a wiretap in his cell and see if he's talking about it to anybody and gain evidence against this guy that way. And Earl Warren was like, no, we're going to play things above board.
00:37:39 Speaker_05
We're not going to secretly wiretap anybody. That's violating people's rights. So he, even as a prosecutor, was somebody who wanted to play by the rules, so to speak, even if it meant not solving his own father's murder.
00:37:54 Speaker_08
That's a level of integrity not seen often.
00:37:58 Speaker_05
His father's murder is still technically unsolved all of these years later, although people now feel like it's very likely this one guy. There's a good amount of evidence.
00:38:07 Speaker_08
Like Hodel and the Black Dahlia murders.
00:38:10 Speaker_05
Yes. And it was the guy who was in prison who he could have wiretapped and didn't. He's the most likely suspect in having killed Earl Warren's dad.
00:38:19 Speaker_08
But again, if you believe in the principle that it would be better to have a guilty man free than an innocent man in prison, which I do and our system's built on, you've got to play by that.
00:38:29 Speaker_05
I think you're right that first of all, it is better to have a guilty man free than an innocent man imprisoned. You might think to yourself, yeah, I agree with that. But I think in times like today, that's a big ask for some people.
00:38:43 Speaker_05
People would rather be safe. And if that means putting in some innocent people in prison, then that's the choice they're going to make. Do you agree? Do you see what I'm saying there?
00:38:52 Speaker_08
I 100% agree with you. And in fact, look, I'm a liberal, but I try to do my best to make a really strong case for the right as often as I can.
00:39:00 Speaker_08
And we had a guest on saying that for people who think that the canceling is gone too far, he said, ultimately it's all worth it. Look how things have changed. And I'm like, That's fine. And I agree they've changed for good.
00:39:12 Speaker_08
But if you can anchor the opposition's belief in this premise of our judicial system, which I bet you can, can you yourself agree it's better to have an innocent man out of incarceration than a guilty? Yes.
00:39:25 Speaker_08
So do you see that that premise applies to trying people in public and then they lose their thing? And sometimes we get it wrong. Can you at least see that that's a defendable point of view, whether you ultimately agree with it or not?
00:39:36 Speaker_08
You see, it's a substantive pushback. And yeah, I think people are having a really hard time making a good faith argument for the other side or at least spending 10 minutes trying to figure out what point they're making and if it's on solid footing.
00:39:49 Speaker_05
Yeah, I agree with you. And I think it's really easy when you are operating from a position of fear. In some cases, a fear for their own safety, a fear for their own livelihood, their way of life or their religious whatever.
00:40:01 Speaker_05
They feel like, well, you know, sometimes that's the way it works. They don't
00:40:05 Speaker_05
extend that idea to its logical conclusion that sometimes in a system run by fallible humans, it does mean that guilty people will walk free, but that we have to err on the side of not incarcerating or putting to death somebody who there's even a small chance of being innocent.
00:40:23 Speaker_05
When push comes to shove and it's your own family and it's your own community, people have a really hard time.
00:40:29 Speaker_08
Both ways.
00:40:30 Speaker_05
Yeah. Yeah.
00:40:30 Speaker_08
My mom's murdered, but I can own that. Right. People go, I'm not in favor of the death penalty. What if your children were raped and murdered? I'm like, yeah, I would want those people killed. But I shouldn't be a justice in that case. That's right.
00:40:42 Speaker_08
And I shouldn't be the police officer that arrests the people. I should have some distance. They think that's a gotcha. And it's like, no, no. Yes, I would want that, which is why I shouldn't be deciding it.
00:40:51 Speaker_05
It's your normal human instinct to be like, you should no longer walk the earth if you did that to my children. And that is why we can't have laws based on our base instincts. Yeah, exactly.
00:41:01 Speaker_05
That is why we need to have laws that are principled and not based on the emotional anger that somebody feels in a given moment.
00:41:10 Speaker_02
Also, those people don't think it's a possibility that they would be wrongly incarcerated.
00:41:16 Speaker_08
They want to walk into court being presumed innocent.
00:41:19 Speaker_02
Yeah. And they also think a group of people who is being incarcerated is much different from them. And maybe they did do something bad. Maybe it wasn't this, but they probably I mean, I've heard all this, right?
00:41:28 Speaker_08
Until they look down and they heard something in their front seat go on the floor and they look down at that and then they look up and they kill a pedestrian.
00:41:35 Speaker_05
You know, like it's a lot of arrogance. I think you're right.
00:41:37 Speaker_08
But that point we were just on is a great kind of segue into term limits or lack of term limits. Another job that the court has, as I understand it, is to be removed from the swell of emotions of pop culture, that we see things.
00:41:53 Speaker_08
Pearl Harbor would be a great example. In the wake of Pearl Harbor, we're going to make some really rash decisions. We're human, we're reactive, we're hurt. And so the cord is supposed to be semi removed from the swell of popular outrage.
00:42:08 Speaker_08
It's purposely slow. It's supposed to build in a little gap between. And so A, is that true? And B, is that where we get into life appointment so that there's no political pressure or daytime pressure to react in a certain way?
00:42:21 Speaker_05
Yeah, I mean, it is true that they are not supposed to be making decisions based on what is popular, which is what politicians often do. They make decisions that will help them get reelected as opposed to principled decisions.
00:42:35 Speaker_05
So, yes, that's the idea. behind it that we are removed from public opinion. That's why the members of the Supreme Court have lifetime appointments.
00:42:44 Speaker_05
And so there's almost always a gap between what happens theoretically and what happens on the ground, right? Theoretically, it insulates you from popular opinion so that you only make principal decisions.
00:42:55 Speaker_05
What it can also mean is that it allows people who potentially are corrupt or people who potentially are not playing by the rules, it allows them to stay in power excessively because it's too difficult to get rid of them.
00:43:04 Speaker_05
So there's always a give and take when it comes to these issues. Yes, it's a good idea in theory, but in reality, it means the following things.
00:43:11 Speaker_05
But you're right that there's meant to be a lack of reactivity to public opinion on the part of the court system. And sometimes a court gets it wrong.
00:43:22 Speaker_10
Yeah.
00:43:23 Speaker_05
Sometimes the court has gotten it wrong. They got it real wrong when it came to Plessy v. Ferguson saying that African-Americans were not citizens of the United States, even if they were born here.
00:43:34 Speaker_05
They got it real wrong in the Korematsu case, which is what found it constitutionally permissible to incarcerate Japanese-Americans. The Supreme Court actually said it was fine that they did that.
00:43:45 Speaker_05
So you can look back and point to a variety of cases where you're like, oh, hell no, that is messed up.
00:43:50 Speaker_08
Yeah. And again, I don't know, like years ago when the premise was explained to me, it made sense. And now that I find myself on the wrong side of the politics of the supermajority or whatever we'd call what is existing now.
00:44:04 Speaker_08
I, of course, am seeing the fallibility of this. And then I wonder, well, is it if it's good for the goose, is it good for the gander? Why didn't I? You know, you're always trying to self-correct.
00:44:13 Speaker_08
Like, am I just caught in my own silo of opinion or do we think that these lifetime appointments are problematic? I also think, again, as the writers of the Second Amendment couldn't anticipate AR-15s, we can't anticipate justices living to 94.
00:44:28 Speaker_08
Like that wasn't in the realm of what was going to happen.
00:44:31 Speaker_05
That's so true.
00:44:32 Speaker_05
You are absolutely right that if you are taking a principled look at this, if you dislike the conservative bent of the court today and you feel like, oh, it's just become so political, oh my gosh, and making so many decisions that impact some people's lives, then you are feeling exactly how conservatives felt during the 1950s and 60s, where they're like, what the
00:44:53 Speaker_05
F is this cart. And they felt like the court was radically reshaping American society during the 1950s. And they were. We just today feel like they were reshaping it in the right way. Yeah.
00:45:05 Speaker_08
To be fair, they were reshaping it in the right way.
00:45:09 Speaker_05
way. You know, like segregation was not acceptable. It's not okay.
00:45:13 Speaker_05
So it's easy for us to look back on that today and be like, yeah, sometimes the court should radically reshape society because lawmakers who are concerned with consolidating and maintaining their own power care more about that than about doing the right thing.
00:45:28 Speaker_05
Or lawmakers are themselves bigots. But then we feel really uncomfortable if the same principle is extended to its logical conclusion. And it means that sometimes the court swings to the right.
00:45:40 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah, yeah. There's so many tasty things. And I feel like we're semi-aligned, which is really fun. I feel quite alone in screaming like, A, democracy's first. Forget whatever your issue is.
00:45:51 Speaker_08
You have an issue and it's legit, but it has to come second to democracy.
00:45:55 Speaker_05
I totally agree with you. Principle over party. That's how I say it. The principles of democracy are more important than any party allegiance to somebody.
00:46:02 Speaker_08
Or any or single issue. It's like we cannot have a minority of people running a majority of the country. And so with that said, I get in this argument. Sometimes I sounded off the other day about it.
00:46:11 Speaker_08
And now I'm a little worried I might be actually wrong. So I'm going to ask you. And this does seem to be a favorite comment from people on the far right, which is it's not a democracy. It's a republic.
00:46:21 Speaker_08
My issue is like, yeah, motherfucker, that's a version of democracy. You could have direct democracy, you could have representative. So please just start with, are we a democracy?
00:46:31 Speaker_05
Dax, you're right. You are correct. It is both a democracy and a republic. A republic is a structure of government. A democracy is a government of the people. That's literally what the word means in Greek.
00:46:45 Speaker_05
And there are different ways to structure democracies, direct democracies, constitutional republics, a variety of different kinds. You can have a figurehead like a monarch in like they do in England. We don't have that here.
00:46:56 Speaker_05
But yet the UK is still a democracy. So there's more than one way to structure a democratic government. but democracy just means government of the people. And this far right talking point about like, it's not a democracy, it's a republic.
00:47:10 Speaker_05
My question to you is like, and what is your point? Their point is that they're repeating a far right talking point from the 1950s.
00:47:16 Speaker_08
Oh, that starts in the 50s?
00:47:17 Speaker_05
Yes, in the 1950s.
00:47:19 Speaker_08
Oh, this is so fun to learn.
00:47:20 Speaker_05
It started with a far-right group called the John Birch Society, who wanted to put forward this idea that it's not a democracy, because if you were going to have a democracy, that would mean that everyone, including people of color in the South, would have to have equal rights.
00:47:38 Speaker_02
And so this idea of like, it's a republic. So they're not defending democracy. They're saying it's not a democracy. It's not a democracy. Don't try to say it is.
00:47:45 Speaker_05
They don't like it when you say it's a democracy. They will try to correct you and say it's not a democracy, it's a republic. Which is why we can have like electoral college and things like that.
00:47:56 Speaker_02
It's not just like popular vote.
00:47:57 Speaker_08
Those terms aren't mutually exclusive.
00:47:59 Speaker_02
That's exactly right.
00:48:00 Speaker_08
It's like saying it's not a democracy because it's a communist. And it's like, no, that's an economic system.
00:48:05 Speaker_05
So all constitutional republics are democracies, but not all democracies are constitutional republics. America is both of those things. It's both a republican and democracy. And this is one of those things that like gets under my skin.
00:48:20 Speaker_05
I'm always so curious what the point somebody is trying to make when they say that.
00:48:23 Speaker_08
Well, I have found that that comes as the last ditch I'm out. Generally, for me, it's their point didn't hold up all that much. And then that comes in at the end is like hopefully unravel everything we just covered.
00:48:35 Speaker_05
Well, you don't even understand it because it's not a democracy.
00:48:37 Speaker_08
It's not a democracy. OK, so none of this stuff we just argued about is relevant now.
00:48:41 Speaker_05
Democracy is mob rule. This is another thing people will say. Democracy is like two wolves and a sheep trying to decide what to have for dinner. This is another thing that people will say. Oh, my God.
00:48:53 Speaker_08
First of all, I like that. That's pretty funny. Two wolves and a sheep trying to decide what to have for dinner.
00:48:58 Speaker_05
I mean, it's pretty good. I don't get it.
00:48:59 Speaker_08
Well, the two wolves are going to vote to eat the sheep.
00:49:01 Speaker_05
The majority are going to vote to eat the sheep. So it's mom's rule.
00:49:04 Speaker_08
So it's almost like implicit in a democracy is that the majority will victimize the minority.
00:49:08 Speaker_05
That's right.
00:49:09 Speaker_08
This would be a great time to introduce baked intentions that are from our conceit. We have liberty, inequality, and these often are in opposition to one another.
00:49:18 Speaker_08
Yet there are two ideals we're going to try to juggle and get as close to both as we can without infringing on the other. The other is this union in this republic, the state's rights versus federal rights.
00:49:28 Speaker_08
And these are long standing tensions that the political parties tend to gravitate towards.
00:49:34 Speaker_05
That's absolutely true.
00:49:34 Speaker_05
Literally from the very beginning, before the modern Republican and Democratic parties, which have not existed in the format that they exist today for very long, you have the Federalists and the Anti-Federalists, which were very much this idea of how much do the federal government do versus how much do the
00:49:50 Speaker_05
state governments do? And obviously, leading up to the Civil War, we have this continual tension between what states have the right to do and the federal government has the right to do. You see it with abortion today, another state's rights issue.
00:50:01 Speaker_05
What should the states have the right to do? Of course, you understand Los Angeles needs different environmental rules than northern Minnesota, where I live, where we have too much water.
00:50:11 Speaker_05
as opposed to not enough water, you know, where we have almost nobody that lives there. Of course, it makes sense that there are certain things that fall under the purview of states.
00:50:20 Speaker_05
But to what extent, to what end, is it fair that women in one state should be able to receive a certain type of medical care while somebody in another state should not be able to receive that kind of medical care?
00:50:31 Speaker_05
And so you're right that this is a continual balancing act that the federal government is trying to find the right happy medium.
00:50:39 Speaker_05
And right now, with the more conservative leaning Supreme Court, they're tipping backs towards this sort of states' rights issues.
00:50:45 Speaker_08
And in general, we could probably say the modern left and right, the right is about the individual and the left is about
00:50:51 Speaker_05
More about the collective. Yes.
00:50:53 Speaker_08
Both are really valid. I also want to scream that often. Yes. You know who was the minority who was getting shit on by the majority were gay folks. Jews. We've had a lot of minority groups that were getting fucked by the majority.
00:51:05 Speaker_08
So it is a very good principle to be defending of the individual's right to pursue their happiness here.
00:51:11 Speaker_05
I bring this point up all the time, too, that we actually cannot have one political party. We need multiple political parties. One political party is a dictatorship, right?
00:51:23 Speaker_04
So we can't just be like, well, I hope the people I like get into power and screw the rest of y'all.
00:51:28 Speaker_05
And that's actually not a healthy democracy. We're better off by having our ideas challenged and by having the best ideas rise to the top.
00:51:36 Speaker_05
We should have enough allegiance to the country and to the Constitution to be willing to acknowledge when somebody who belongs to a party that we do not vote for, when they have a good idea. Like we should have enough humility.
00:51:50 Speaker_05
to be able to be like, you know what, I didn't vote for you, but I think that's a good idea. And integrity. Yes. Some of the best leaders from history have done that exact thing. I know you have team of rivals on your shelf right above your head.
00:52:02 Speaker_08
Just learning that.
00:52:06 Speaker_05
The Doris Kearns Goodwin book, it's a great book about how some of the best leaders from history have brought people into their cabinets who some of them did not agree with them.
00:52:16 Speaker_05
They did not just hire a bunch of yes men who were like, whatever you think, great idea, of course.
00:52:20 Speaker_08
Wasn't Lincoln famous for this?
00:52:22 Speaker_05
Yes, that's what this is about. Team of Rivals shows George Washington. George Washington hires both Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson who hate each other.
00:52:29 Speaker_05
The thinking behind that is, I don't want you to just pat me on the head and tell me I'm pretty and I come up with all the good ideas. Yeah, this is important stuff. Right.
00:52:38 Speaker_08
And back to what you said 10 minutes ago about theory versus practice, each side has a scorecard just riddled with failures and successes.
00:52:47 Speaker_05
Nobody has the lock on we've historically had all the good ideas. That's ridiculous.
00:52:51 Speaker_08
My site's had a lot of well-intentioned stuff that in practice split up families in the inner city that incarcerated people. You know, we've done a lot of well-intentioned things that in practice turned out terribly that we got a course correct.
00:53:04 Speaker_05
That's right. And the right thing to do is to admit when you got it wrong and to do what you can to make it right.
00:53:11 Speaker_05
And I think too often our leaders today view admitting any kind of change in thinking or any kind of, you know, like, I thought it was a good idea and then ultimately it ended up not working out the way I thought.
00:53:22 Speaker_05
They're so penalized for admitting those kinds of things. When personally, if we're having an interaction together and you call me on the phone, you're like, you know what? I really screwed that up. I am so sorry.
00:53:33 Speaker_05
I did not realize how it would impact you. I'm going to make changes. You would have respect for that person.
00:53:39 Speaker_08
Oh, so much.
00:53:40 Speaker_05
Who did that to you personally, but yet on a broader political scale, we're like, oh my God, they're a flip-flopper.
00:53:47 Speaker_02
Yeah, it's the public's fault for doing this, for villainizing that type of behavior from a powerful person. Why can't they change their mind? They should change their mind when presented with better information.
00:53:57 Speaker_02
That's what a person with intellectual integrity does. It was like with COVID, a bunch of people were very upset that the initial stuff that was coming out, they ended up being like, oh, actually, now you don't need to probably lice all your fruit.
00:54:10 Speaker_02
They're like, oh, you were wrong. And so now we don't trust you at all. It's like, well, they're just figuring it out.
00:54:15 Speaker_05
We probably don't need to put every book in an autoclave, right? But yet the initial responses to a global pandemic were not perfect.
00:54:26 Speaker_08
What's even more depressing is like, I'm not even sure how I feel about all this. Let me check in with my tribe and see how they feel about it. And now I know.
00:54:34 Speaker_08
That to me was the much more scary, and I think we have a similar concern, you and I. The notion that something like a global pandemic got funneled into one of two camps politically. Let's look at the fucking aliens come up with the laser beams.
00:54:46 Speaker_08
Are we going to actually decide? Is that going to be political? Like, what would be the threat where we would stop?
00:54:52 Speaker_05
Where we would come together?
00:54:53 Speaker_08
Also, I just want to say, too, I think both sides were wrong about a bunch of stuff.
00:54:56 Speaker_05
Totally. Of course, everyone was wrong.
00:54:57 Speaker_02
It was a brand new thing.
00:55:00 Speaker_08
But just the notion that anyone could come out of it and go like, my side was vindicated. I also think it's a total fantasy. It's like they were right about some stuff. We were right about some stuff. We were wrong about some stuff.
00:55:10 Speaker_08
They were wrong about some stuff.
00:55:11 Speaker_05
I totally agree. And now we should be willing to do a postmortem on that.
00:55:14 Speaker_08
Kids should probably go to school if they're going to survive. That's something the left got completely wrong.
00:55:18 Speaker_05
Now we know the learning loss from not being in school was too great a burden to bear. But yet you can also understand how children are not the only people in the schools. right?
00:55:29 Speaker_05
That the adults that work in the schools also deserve a safe working environment.
00:55:34 Speaker_05
And that that's very tricky when you have small children who don't understand basic hygiene, who don't know how to cover their cough, who don't know how to wash their hands appropriately. What about the adults in the schools?
00:55:44 Speaker_05
Don't they deserve to not die from COVID?
00:55:46 Speaker_02
And also the kids that go home to environments where there's a lot of people in a small environment. a lot of adults, grandmothers, grandparents, like again, we don't live in that type of environment.
00:55:58 Speaker_02
So it's easy for us to forget that that exists, but that's a lot of people.
00:56:01 Speaker_05
A lot of people. The black and white thinking, I don't think is particularly helpful here because yes, the children should be in school and also yes, the teachers should not die from COVID. Both of those things are true, right?
00:56:13 Speaker_05
And the idea that only my side is the correct side and if you don't agree with it, then you're a Satan worshiper or whatever it is.
00:56:19 Speaker_08
Again, though, I don't think it's helpful to call it the other side's failures in some way. Like, they're not listening to me.
00:56:24 Speaker_02
That's true. It's not fair. Yes, because it's not fair because you actively say, I'm a centrist. You've stopped saying you're a liberal. So if you're a centrist, then you do need to call out both sides. It doesn't feel fair to me.
00:56:37 Speaker_08
Yeah, well, OK, so on the right, it was insane. They're hosting covid parties. They're intentionally endangering themselves to prove a point. And there was no period where they could even wear a mask for five minutes to see where this goes.
00:56:49 Speaker_08
Like there was a lot of belligerence and insolence on that side, for sure. But there was a bit of hypocrisy on our side, which was like service. What was the term we use? Essential workers. If I'm on the right, that's a total elitist bullshit thing.
00:57:03 Speaker_08
So all the professionals with college degrees just didn't work and everyone else had to work. Somehow it was not unsafe for this whole section of our economy to be working every day. They never stopped.
00:57:14 Speaker_08
Everyone that I know stopped working and was in quarantine.
00:57:17 Speaker_05
Worked from Zoom.
00:57:18 Speaker_08
Yeah. Relocate. If you work at Chipotle, there's no fucking work from home. So it was also very elitist in the way that it was executed. If I'm on the right, it's not hard to see that. And that's legit.
00:57:28 Speaker_05
Yes. And both of those things can be true at the same time. Yeah. And people's weddedness to their political party of choice blinds them in some ways to the things that their own party is getting wrong. And this blind allegiance
00:57:42 Speaker_05
has never led any civilization somewhere worth going.
00:57:46 Speaker_05
Blind allegiance to a party or blind allegiance to a leader, that has always led to dehumanization, that has always led to dictatorships, that has always led to further marginalization of vulnerable groups.
00:57:58 Speaker_08
Incarcerated opponents.
00:57:59 Speaker_05
Yes, exactly. The idea of blind allegiance. No one deserves, not me, not any of y'all, nobody deserves your unexamined loyalty. Right?
00:58:11 Speaker_05
And I think we're seeing the effects today of some people who have unexamined loyalty to a party or a person, and it's a dangerous direction to be headed in.
00:58:22 Speaker_05
If you want to paint yourself as a critical thinker and as an intellectually honest person, and I think most people would want to be labeled a critical thinker, right? If I'm like, well, you don't know how to critically think, you'd be offended.
00:58:34 Speaker_05
We all want to feel like we're good at critical thinking. If you want to be a critical thinker and you want to be intellectually mature and honest, you have to be willing to admit when your preferred ideology gets it wrong. You really do.
00:58:48 Speaker_05
And I think it's a failure, regardless of what your preferred ideology is. And if you cannot listen to a single criticism of your preferred ideology, then you don't have the intellectual maturity enough to be able to say, yeah, you know what?
00:58:59 Speaker_05
We screwed that up. We should not do that again in the future.
00:59:01 Speaker_08
Yeah. And you're right. We admire people who do it so much.
00:59:03 Speaker_05
They've been showing clips of old debates.
00:59:05 Speaker_02
Yes. Old John Kerry. Yeah. Mitt Romney and Obama. And everyone's laughing and there's agreement. It's just normal. You have your ideas about how you want the country to go, but you just don't have to hate the opponent or it doesn't have to be so extreme.
00:59:20 Speaker_02
No, you're totally right.
00:59:22 Speaker_05
It doesn't have to be this way. It's this way because we're permitting it to be this way and we're participating in it. People don't realize how much money there is in producing outrage content on the internet.
00:59:32 Speaker_05
They do not realize how lucrative it is to create this kind of division. And I'm not somebody who's out here like, oh, the media is ruining the world. The media has an important job. Press is an important role in society.
00:59:43 Speaker_05
But you don't have any idea how some of these people who have very popular YouTube channels are making $20 million a year pumping out hate content.
00:59:50 Speaker_05
The idea that it's somehow the media, and what they mean by that is legacy media, ABC News or whatever, that it's somehow their fault, when in reality, they are very willing to ignore the people who are getting paid $20 million a year to make fun of ABC News.
01:00:07 Speaker_05
This is somehow corrupt over here, but what you're doing is completely legit? Sure.
01:00:14 Speaker_05
Also the idea that some people are getting paid $20 million a year to roll clip and then they watch President Biden stumble on the steps of Air Force One and then they spend 15 minutes making fun of what an old guy he is.
01:00:26 Speaker_05
Those clips that go uber viral, that is a tremendously lucrative line of work if you have enough eyeballs on your content. And when you understand the business model behind the hate content that is online, it's very, very eye-opening.
01:00:43 Speaker_05
It pays far more to be a hyper-partisan pundit. I could make so much more money than I make right now getting a gig on some news network and talking about how shitty XYZ person is, why this person's an idiot, et cetera.
01:00:56 Speaker_05
The amount of money that exists in that hyper-partisan space is so much more than somebody who exists where common sense There's not cash in common sense.
01:01:08 Speaker_05
And so if I have a choice between a giant check and having common sense, listen, it's very enticing to be like, I'll take the cash and I'll buy the sweaters.
01:01:17 Speaker_08
Well, again, it doesn't even have to be personal to anyone. It's you're observing what the system creates and the incentive structure, and it's a system and it produces a result.
01:01:27 Speaker_05
The incentive structure.
01:01:27 Speaker_08
And it's producing the exact result that's designed, you know.
01:01:29 Speaker_05
Precisely. It's producing the exact result that is designed to produce, and everybody is willingly participating in it without even realizing what the incentive structure is there. Yeah, exactly. And that's the problem.
01:01:43 Speaker_08
OK, well, I have done a bad job because you're so interesting of mowing through a lot of these things I wanted to explain. I feel like we could do 20 hours together.
01:01:51 Speaker_05
I would love to.
01:01:51 Speaker_08
But I think people would like to know, too, the difference between the Senate and the House of Representatives. Right. That's a little confusing.
01:01:58 Speaker_05
Yeah, it is. So the legislative branch of the federal government is Congress. Congress has two houses in it, the Senate and the House of Representatives. The Senate has a six year term and they're meant to be slow and deliberate.
01:02:10 Speaker_05
Every state gets two senators. And so consequently, small states like Wyoming get exactly as much representation as giant states like California. And a lot of people feel like, how is that fair?
01:02:22 Speaker_05
Wyoming has less than 1 million people in it, and they get two senators just like California does. This is something they argued about when they were writing the Constitution. They fought like cats and dogs about this.
01:02:31 Speaker_05
And the House of Representatives has allegedly proportional representation, where a state gets a certain number of representatives based on their population. and all of those representatives serve two-year terms.
01:02:42 Speaker_05
So there's 100 senators and 435 representatives, and together, those 535 members make up the entirety of Congress.
01:02:50 Speaker_05
There are a few people, they have kind of more advisory jobs to Congress, they're delegates to Congress, and they represent places that are United States territories, places like Guam or Puerto Rico, Washington, DC, places that are not states.
01:03:04 Speaker_05
They're allowed to go to committee meetings and make their voice known, but they can't vote on legislation. So the problem with proportional representation is still that there is a finite pie that has to be divvied up.
01:03:17 Speaker_05
Every 10 years, they go through and re-divvy up the pie again, these 435 seats. After the 2020 census, California actually lost a seat in the House of Representatives, even though California is bigger than it's ever been, of course. Right.
01:03:32 Speaker_05
And that's because other places grew faster than California did.
01:03:37 Speaker_05
So the number of people that are being represented by one representative in Wyoming or North Dakota is much, much, much smaller than the number of people that are being represented by one representative in the state of California, for example.
01:03:50 Speaker_05
That's one of the big criticisms of Congress is that the way people are represented is not equal across the entire country.
01:03:57 Speaker_08
Yeah. It's OK if we have a representative democracy, assuming that each person is representative.
01:04:03 Speaker_05
Yes. Or at least relatively equally. And nobody's saying it has to be perfect, but get us in the ballpark here of one representative for every 500,000 people or, you know, whatever it is.
01:04:15 Speaker_05
So the way that it works, there's an actual commission that goes through and divvies up this pie of 435 people every 10 years. Inevitably, some states are going to lose some people and some states are going to gain some people.
01:04:26 Speaker_05
Together, those two houses of Congress, the Senate and the House of Representatives, some of the roles they have are very similar, but they each have some specific roles. Like the Senate has to confirm the president's appointments.
01:04:36 Speaker_05
They have to confirm people to the Supreme Court. They're meant to act differently because the House of Representatives is being reelected every even year. Congress is on recess right now until after the election. For six weeks, they're off of work.
01:04:50 Speaker_08
Oh my God, maybe I'll be a congressperson as well.
01:04:54 Speaker_05
Do that on my break from being a judge. No, so you can't be in two branches of government at the same time.
01:04:59 Speaker_08
All right, that'd be a conflict.
01:04:59 Speaker_05
Okay, that's enough. They're all off because they're campaigning for re-election. Imagine having to campaign for re-election every other year.
01:05:07 Speaker_02
But also that you don't have to do your job because you're campaigning, I don't like.
01:05:11 Speaker_08
Their term is only every two years.
01:05:12 Speaker_05
Two years. It's meant to be more immediately responsive, thinking people have short memories. And if you screwed up last year, I'm going to remember it this year. I'm going to vote you out. That's the thinking behind it.
01:05:26 Speaker_08
And for legislation to become law that will be enforced by the president, the executive branch, it has to pass both.
01:05:33 Speaker_05
Yep, it has to pass both.
01:05:34 Speaker_08
And then be signed off by the president.
01:05:36 Speaker_05
You know, I won't go into the whole, like, how do committees work, the whole structure of how every aspect of Congress works.
01:05:43 Speaker_05
But the bottom line is, yes, both the Senate and the House of Representatives has to pass identical versions of the same law to land on the president's desk for him or her.
01:05:55 Speaker_10
Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert, if you dare.
01:06:02 Speaker_08
We are supported by Quince. Tis the season of holiday gifting, but finding the perfect gift can be pretty overwhelming. For timeless gifts made from premium materials at an affordable price, Quince has your back.
01:06:16 Speaker_08
Quince lets you treat your loved ones and yourself to quality essentials like their Mongolian cashmere sweaters, which start at just $50. That's an elevated gift at a price that won't break the bank.
01:06:29 Speaker_08
or for more winter coziness, try their Super Soft Fleece Sweatpants or their Packable Puffer Jackets, both perfect for anyone who's traveling for the holidays.
01:06:39 Speaker_02
Yes, okay, they also have, they're called Ultra Stretch Point, P-O-N-T-E, Straight Leg Pants, and they are really, really great. They're great for travel, they're very cozy.
01:06:52 Speaker_08
Gift luxury this holiday season without the luxury price tag. Go to quince.com slash DAX for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's Q-U-I-N-C-E dot com slash DAX to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quince.com slash DAX.
01:07:14 Speaker_08
We are supported by the thrilling Apple TV Plus legal drama, Presumed Innocent, from the masters of brilliant character-driven storytelling, David E. Kelly and J.J. Abrams. Have you seen this series yet?
01:07:27 Speaker_08
It's about a horrific murder investigation that upends the Chicago prosecuting attorney's office when one of its own, Chief Deputy Prosecutor Rusty Savage, played by Jake Gyllenhaal, ding, ding, ding.
01:07:38 Speaker_02
Friend of the pod.
01:07:39 Speaker_08
is suspected of the crime. There are so many twists and turns that will keep you on the edge of your seat right until the very end, which is probably why Variety raved that it was one of the best legal thrillers in years.
01:07:51 Speaker_08
If I were you, I'd stream it on Apple TV Plus the second this podcast finishes. We are supported by BetterHelp. There are so many things to love about December. It's holiday season.
01:08:02 Speaker_08
There are breaks from work and school on the calendar to spend time with loved ones, not to mention delicious seasonal treats.
01:08:09 Speaker_08
Staying cozy in the winter months is essential, and therapy can be a great way to bring yourself some comfort that never goes away, even when the seasons change.
01:08:18 Speaker_02
Therapy is essential to me during the holidays especially because I generally am going home.
01:08:26 Speaker_08
Right, yes.
01:08:27 Speaker_02
And I need sort of some stability. And guidance. And guidance to stay nice.
01:08:34 Speaker_08
Well, if you've ever been considering starting therapy, give BetterHelp a try. It's completely online, so it's easy to integrate into your schedule. BetterHelp is flexible, too. It's easy to book or move appointments on their platform.
01:08:47 Speaker_08
And if the therapist you're matched with isn't the right fit, you can switch therapists at any time for no additional charge. Find comfort this December with BetterHelp. Visit betterhelp.com slash dax today to get 10% off your first month.
01:09:01 Speaker_08
That's betterhelp, H-E-L-P dot com slash dax. And if we want to change the Constitution, it requires a two thirds vote. In both houses. In both houses.
01:09:20 Speaker_05
Yes. But then it also has to be ratified by three quarters of the states. Oh, my God.
01:09:26 Speaker_08
When's the last time this has happened?
01:09:28 Speaker_05
The Constitution has been amended 27 times.
01:09:30 Speaker_08
OK, when was the last?
01:09:32 Speaker_05
In the 90s. Oh, what was the last amendment? The last amendment, it had to do with the way, like if Congress is going to adjust its own pay, it said that the change in pay would not go into effect until after the next election.
01:09:46 Speaker_08
OK, that's a pretty good. So it can't be self-serving.
01:09:49 Speaker_05
So they can't be like, everyone gets 20 million dollars and then they get a check tomorrow. They have to wait till after the next election. So it has not been amended since the 90s, but we have amended it 27 times. And the framers of the Constitution,
01:10:02 Speaker_05
wrote two different ways to amend the Constitution into the document itself. This is not holy scripture. This is not forever and ever. Amen. Thus saith the Lord. These are two different ways.
01:10:14 Speaker_05
Like, listen, if we got something wrong, here's two ways you might go about fixing it, but please do fix it in the future. They were at least smart enough to understand that they didn't know what was coming down the pike.
01:10:24 Speaker_05
They had no way of knowing that there's going to be the internet and porn websites and transgender medical care for minors.
01:10:30 Speaker_08
60 rounds a second guns.
01:10:32 Speaker_05
Yeah, exactly. Semi-automatic weapons that kill children in their classrooms in Texas. They had no way of anticipating these things.
01:10:38 Speaker_05
And so consequently, even though they did get a lot of things wrong by today's standards, namely the rights of women, the rights of people of color, they got a lot wrong. They at least knew that they were fallible people.
01:10:50 Speaker_05
They did not view themselves as gods. And I think some people today hold up the framers of the Constitution as like Thomas Jefferson. Like he's some kind of deity. Right.
01:10:59 Speaker_08
Yeah, it is. It's biblical, the document. What's the second way to amend it?
01:11:04 Speaker_05
You can have a convention of states in which the states can decide to circumvent Congress and be like, forget you, we're going to do it ourselves.
01:11:13 Speaker_05
And there actually is a movement on the political right right now to have a convention of states to amend the Constitution and to sort of refashion portions of the Constitution in the way that they view as preferable.
01:11:24 Speaker_08
Interesting.
01:11:25 Speaker_05
And how many states would that require? Three quarters. Oh, still three quarters. OK. What's interesting, too, is how would states decide who gets to go to the Convention of States? That's the million dollar question. Is it me? My friends?
01:11:40 Speaker_05
Is it the governor? Yeah. Do they have to be elected? Who gets to choose? Because who shows up at that Convention of States would be real, real important. Yeah.
01:11:49 Speaker_08
So it's never happened.
01:11:50 Speaker_05
We've never used it, but it's there for the using.
01:11:53 Speaker_08
Oh, wow. Well, that kind of gets to one of my other questions is this gap between there's a few examples of it. You've already brought up one of the most glaring at the moment.
01:12:02 Speaker_08
There's these times where the representatives do not reflect at all what the national consensus is that we find out in polling. Of course, Roe v. Wade is the most salient of those examples right now. It's in the 70s or some crazy majority.
01:12:17 Speaker_05
Guns are another one.
01:12:18 Speaker_08
Not like abolishment of guns, but gun control.
01:12:21 Speaker_02
No one, even Kamala is like, I have a gun. I'm not trying to take anyone's guns away. No one's saying that. I mean, maybe like there might be a tiny percentage, but most.
01:12:31 Speaker_08
But again, just like we respond to the ding baddiest on the right, they're responding to the ding baddiest on the left. So, yeah, there are socialist Democrats. There are no guns.
01:12:41 Speaker_05
But the one who is representing this side. She's like, no guns than people in the United States. Yeah. You can say we need to get rid of all of the guns all day long, but practically, how does one do that? Right? I know.
01:12:54 Speaker_05
It's like saying we're going to deport 80 million immigrants. How does one do that? Practically, what does that even look like? Are the cops going door to door? No. Are the cops even going to cooperate with that? No.
01:13:05 Speaker_05
The idea that that's somebody's concept is like, come and take my guns. That's just silly. It's not even a real idea. There's no practical way to carry that out. But what
01:13:13 Speaker_05
the overwhelming majority of Americans want, 80 plus percent, are just really common sense laws. How about we just do universal background checks to make sure you are not a domestic abuser?
01:13:23 Speaker_05
How about we make sure that you haven't been flagged for being a potential school shooter? How about we just have safe storage laws that require you to lock up your weapon and lock up your ammunition?
01:13:33 Speaker_05
If you are a law-abiding citizen, you should want other people to be law-abiding citizens. Just like when I am driving safely on the road, I don't want it to be permissible for drunk drivers. I want you to follow the rules of the road as well. Right.
01:13:45 Speaker_05
Just like I want to follow the rules of the road. Normal firearms owners want other people to be law-abiding firearms owners.
01:13:53 Speaker_10
Yes.
01:13:54 Speaker_05
What about the rights of children to not be shot in their schools? It's not in the Constitution. I mean, most people agree with that. That's the thing. Exactly.
01:14:00 Speaker_02
So it shouldn't be an issue.
01:14:01 Speaker_08
But that's why you can imagine maybe one of these state conventions rallying around one of these issues that is like a ubiquitous supermajority that everyone agrees with.
01:14:12 Speaker_02
But also that should be able to just get passed through Congress, but then we can't because there are lobbies and things.
01:14:17 Speaker_05
To your point, if Congress is supposed to reflect, generally speaking, the will of the people and they are absolutely shirking that duty, it makes people feel like the government is not legitimate.
01:14:30 Speaker_05
It makes people feel like, I'm not going to listen to what they have to say. I'm just going to violate whatever rules they come up with because they're not a legitimate lawmaking group.
01:14:38 Speaker_05
This has been the least productive Congress in United States history. That's not my opinion. I mean, like the number of laws that have been passed, the least productive Congress in U.S. history. Again, that doesn't play well in Peoria.
01:14:50 Speaker_05
If you were from a blue collar area like I am where people literally work on ore ships or they mine iron ore or they work in health care, like they are working hard for their money. It seems really frustrating.
01:15:03 Speaker_05
that I should pay you $170,000 plus a year plus great benefits to sit around and just do press conferences about how stupid your opponents are.
01:15:14 Speaker_05
That really sticks in people's craw where they're like, I'm working two jobs to put food on the table and y'all are sitting around being shitty on television. That's not how it's supposed to work.
01:15:24 Speaker_05
Meanwhile, it's fine that the kids keep getting shot in the schools and we're not going to do anything about it. We're going to go on TV and say, well, it's just an unfortunate reality is how it is. We're not going to do anything to fix it.
01:15:33 Speaker_05
It doesn't fly in any other line of work. If you just straight up refuse to do the job that you were hired to do, you would soon find yourself out of a job. Yeah.
01:15:44 Speaker_08
Unless you had a lifetime appointment.
01:15:45 Speaker_05
Unless you have a lifetime appointment.
01:15:46 Speaker_08
Okay, last thing, and then we're going to talk about the book, which is so worthy of talking about on its own for two hours. But maybe another pet peeve of mine is, do you think people in general exaggerate the role of the president?
01:15:56 Speaker_07
Oh my God, yes. This is also a pet peeve of mine, Jax. Okay.
01:16:00 Speaker_08
We're crediting them with the economy. We're crediting them with supply chains. We're crediting them with a pandemic. We're crediting them. I mean, it'd be great if one person could whip everyone into shape.
01:16:08 Speaker_05
The problem with it'd be great if everybody could do it is that they can also wield that power to do bad things, right? If that person has too much power, that's how we get dictatorships.
01:16:17 Speaker_05
They intentionally restrain the power of the president significantly on purpose because the framers of the Constitution were all coming from monarchies where the governments were saying, here's the religion you have to belong to.
01:16:30 Speaker_05
The idea that whatever I say, whatever whim that's at the top of my head, we're just going to go with that thing. They intentionally created a system that constrained the power of the president.
01:16:39 Speaker_05
This is one of my pet peeves when a president is like, I've created 82 million jobs.
01:16:44 Speaker_04
Exactly. No, you didn't.
01:16:46 Speaker_08
Oh, yeah.
01:16:47 Speaker_04
You sure did not.
01:16:48 Speaker_08
You were sitting there when the tech boom happened. That was convenient. You were sitting there when this bad thing happened. That was inconvenient.
01:16:55 Speaker_05
Yes. You might have some ideas that can help promote job growth. Maybe you have some ideas. And you can call up some of the people in Congress and be like, listen, we should pass the CHIPS Act.
01:17:04 Speaker_05
We should start getting more microchips made in the United States. We should start passing some tax incentives so that people bring manufacturing back to the United States. Yes, you can do things like that.
01:17:13 Speaker_05
But the idea that you could like, ooh, attaboy, pat on the back, you made all those jobs.
01:17:17 Speaker_04
That's really annoying to me.
01:17:19 Speaker_05
Also, the same is true of the economy. The president gets a lot of blame or a lot of credit for how the economy overall is doing.
01:17:27 Speaker_05
When the economy is so multifactorial and so complicated, the factors that go into creating low unemployment reach so far beyond what a president has the power to do with his little pen.
01:17:41 Speaker_08
It's so simplistic in that there would be a lever in this incredibly dynamic, multinational breeding organism.
01:17:49 Speaker_05
Pull it down and move it to the low position. We want low unemployment.
01:17:54 Speaker_08
And it undermines what the Fed is doing and the amount of power that they're wielding and how much they're in charge of all that. And we spent all this energy and all of our cultural capital fighting over this one role.
01:18:05 Speaker_08
And I think you point out your life is far more impacted by your state government.
01:18:09 Speaker_05
to your state and local government has a lot more to do with your day-to-day.
01:18:13 Speaker_05
Because on a day-to-day basis, with the exception of a few big hot-button issues, if you are in the military, sure, I'm willing to grant you that the federal government has more impact on your life if you're in the military.
01:18:24 Speaker_05
Or if you're a federal employee, the things that they're doing impact you more. But if you just live here in a normal neighborhood, you have a job, and you're not the recipient of government benefits by and large, you're just working for a living,
01:18:37 Speaker_05
The things that are impacting your life are like, what kind of schools do my kids have to go to? How well are my streets cleaned? Does somebody pick up my trash? Do I have clean drinking water?
01:18:46 Speaker_08
Are we sending addicts in my community to rehab or are we just putting them in prison?
01:18:51 Speaker_05
Yeah. Do people have the ability to pursue an education, you know, if they can't pay for it? By and large, these are state schools, their state and local programs, their local school boards that are impacting our daily lives. And we get so hung up.
01:19:07 Speaker_05
on who the president is. This is not to say they're not important because they are. That's not to say they don't set the tone because they do. And that's not to say you shouldn't vote for president because it does matter.
01:19:16 Speaker_08
It's just about right sizing it. It's a very important role, arguably the most important role in the world, perhaps. I'd stand behind that. But also, they can't do as much as you think they can.
01:19:26 Speaker_04
Now, if they could just like, oh, they lowered gas prices. Right. Oh, my God. Oh, my God.
01:19:31 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:19:32 Speaker_05
You obviously don't know how gas is priced.
01:19:35 Speaker_08
Yeah, what affects gas prices is where you fucking live. Because in California, they're $6 and I was just in Tennessee and they're $2.80. It has nothing to do with the president. It's like 2X and that's a state issue.
01:19:47 Speaker_05
I live near an oil refinery that gets its crude oil from a pipeline from Canada and they refine it and then put it on trains and trucks put all over the world. And gas is like $2.85 near my house.
01:19:58 Speaker_05
And we don't have $4 in state taxes, but neither do we have 35 million people trying to occupy a very small area of environmentally fragile land. It's complicated. It's very complicated.
01:20:10 Speaker_05
Anybody who tries to reduce the economy into the words a president speaks into a microphone or a telephone either does not have an understanding of how the economy actually works, and thus we shouldn't be listening to you, or they do understand how it works and they're lying, in which case we shouldn't listen to you.
01:20:31 Speaker_05
So that person should be regarded with suspicion if they're like, well, such and such had low gas prices. Why? Explain the mechanism by which gas prices were low under their presidency then.
01:20:42 Speaker_08
OK, let's talk about the small and the mighty, because we kind of just spoke about the big and who all gets the attention. But yeah, the book is about you single out 12 unsung Americans who changed American history.
01:20:53 Speaker_08
And as you said earlier, these are doers and not the critics. Why is that a distinction that we make?
01:20:59 Speaker_05
I think it's really easy to feel like on the internet, criticizing people, it creates this heightened emotional state. A great example of this is Hurricane Helene.
01:21:09 Speaker_05
Absolutely devastating to people in North Carolina in particular, Florida, Georgia, six states that have been affected by this hurricane. So many people have lost everything.
01:21:16 Speaker_05
And people look around and they see what they view as an inadequate female response, federal government emergency response to this natural disaster. And they feel like, if I am mad about it,
01:21:28 Speaker_05
and I'm posting about how mad I am about it, or I'm posting about how they're not doing enough, that that is in some way activism. That being mad on the internet is activism. They feel like it is because they feel a heightened emotional response.
01:21:42 Speaker_05
They feel like by criticizing the federal government or criticizing the governor of such and such, blah, blah, blah, that they're doing something.
01:21:49 Speaker_05
I think it's worth remembering that there's nobody in our history book who went down as somebody who really changed the world.
01:21:56 Speaker_05
And that person was somebody who just wrote mean tweets or somebody who just wrote letters being like, your response is terrible. I don't approve of anything you've done. The people who history smiles kindly upon are the people who actually did stuff.
01:22:12 Speaker_05
They're the doers. I think it's important for us to realize that, like, did anybody get clean drinking water because of my post on X today? Does anybody go to bed with food tonight because I've left some mean comments on Facebook? Probably not.
01:22:26 Speaker_05
Nothing has changed.
01:22:27 Speaker_08
The only bad thing I will just say one thing because I'm with you.
01:22:30 Speaker_05
Yeah.
01:22:30 Speaker_08
The only problem where it is effective is it can influence the news cycle back to what's fucked up about the media is unfortunately those dumb groundswells of outrage. You see it on your mainstream media. They read these inane tweets.
01:22:47 Speaker_08
And then it starts to feel like it's consensus or its majority. It does get really misleading. If I just look at the news cycle, feels very led by the tail end of these reactions.
01:22:58 Speaker_05
I can see what you're saying, that there's enough social media outrage about something that can influence what's covered by the news.
01:23:03 Speaker_08
I still don't think that person is an activist.
01:23:05 Speaker_05
That doesn't change anything, even though they're talking about it.
01:23:08 Speaker_08
Yeah, they would have to land on something that really everyone just felt by accident.
01:23:12 Speaker_05
Right now, just using the Helene response is another example. The news is spending an inordinate amount of time debunking lies on social media about how FEMA works and about what the actual response is.
01:23:25 Speaker_05
And that actually makes it so that resources are diverted. away from people who actually need help.
01:23:32 Speaker_05
If these organizations, instead of publicizing ways to get help, ways that FEMA can help you, where to go to apply for assistance, how to contact your homeowner's insurance, etc.
01:23:43 Speaker_05
If they are spending all of their time being like, no, the hurricane wasn't man-made to try to win the election for Kamala Harris. That's literally what the New York Times is spending its time doing. That's a waste of resources.
01:23:57 Speaker_02
Yeah, exactly.
01:23:58 Speaker_05
That's a waste of effing time. Let's focus on helping people who actually need it. There's a difference between raising awareness of something like these people really need our help.
01:24:08 Speaker_05
Over the last few days, I have personally raised a half a million dollars for people who are impacted by Hurricane Helene. I can simultaneously talk about, yeah, Congress doesn't fund FEMA well enough to actually help all these people.
01:24:19 Speaker_05
I can say that thing as a true thing. It's my belief that Congress needs to get their rear in gear and stop spending time arguing on TV cameras and actually do something on behalf of the American people.
01:24:31 Speaker_05
I can simultaneously hold that as true while also actually not just spending all my time running my mouth. and actually move my hands and feet to do something to help. Can I do everything? No. Can I do something?
01:24:42 Speaker_05
Yes, I can leverage my platform to do something instead of just criticizing. I think we just feel like if we're angry, that will change things. And ultimately, running your mouth doesn't produce the kind of change that you think it should.
01:24:59 Speaker_02
Do those people even want change? Like, I don't think they care. I think they just want to be loud and feel like they contributed their voice. It's like selfish and arrogant.
01:25:10 Speaker_08
It's the sweet, sweet hit of self-righteous indignation. It's talked about in AA a lot. We love self-righteous.
01:25:18 Speaker_05
Yeah, the dopamine hate of as soon as I'm like, you know who is the worst? FEMA. And you're like, yeah, I hate them too. Like you get this like validation of like we both hate the same thing. And then we feel like we're on the same team.
01:25:29 Speaker_05
And it produced this feedback loop in our brains. You feel like you're making a difference because other people agree with you.
01:25:35 Speaker_08
Yes. How did you even begin to pick your 12?
01:25:37 Speaker_05
Well, you know, I've been teaching for a while. I teach on the internet now and I used to teach in a classroom, obviously. And it's very apparent to me that people in this moment, they feel really hopeless. They feel like nothing they do matters.
01:25:49 Speaker_05
They feel like nothing they will ever do matters. They don't have billions of dollars. They don't have a weirdly shaped rocket ship. to blast off into space with. They don't have millions of followers. They're not in movies.
01:26:01 Speaker_05
They don't have any kind of capital on which they can access the levers of power. They know those levers exist, but they feel like there's nothing they can ever do to be able to move them themselves.
01:26:12 Speaker_05
And they feel like, I've written letters, I've voted, nothing has changed. And it feels really hopeless to people. And I hear that, you know, I get more than 10,000 DMs every day.
01:26:22 Speaker_05
And a huge amount of them are people who are like, I just feel like nothing will ever change for the better.
01:26:27 Speaker_05
And so I know from experience how meaningful it is to hear about people who have changed things without having access to the levers of power that we traditionally think you need to be able to make a difference.
01:26:44 Speaker_05
And history is actually full of people who did such consequential things, not because they woke up in the morning and felt hope, but who chose to have hope.
01:26:56 Speaker_05
And I think that's a distinction that we really, really need today, that hope is a choice that we can make. It is not a feeling that we wait to feel.
01:27:03 Speaker_05
Our ancestors, who did incredible things in this country, who built schools for children who had no access to them, who reformed prisons, people who wrote incredibly consequential words, people who were incredible philanthropists,
01:27:16 Speaker_05
People who changed the course of history without access to the levers of power did not wake up in the morning and feel hope because the totality of their life circumstances in many cases were such that none of us would ever want to trade places with them.
01:27:31 Speaker_05
We would never be like, yes, let me get her life instead. People who were falsely arrested or incarcerated, people who were fired from their jobs, who grew up in the segregated South, people whose parents were enslaved, people whose children died,
01:27:43 Speaker_05
people whose husbands were liars, who had second lives or married to another woman, had kids with those people. We would never look at the totality of their life circumstances and say, I would love your life.
01:27:53 Speaker_08
Yeah, they were super well positioned to change the world around them.
01:27:55 Speaker_05
Right. No, we would never say that.
01:27:57 Speaker_08
Yeah. Tell me about Anez.
01:27:58 Speaker_05
Inez was a suffrage worker whose story is really remarkable. But one of the things that I find really amusing about her is that she used what she had and what she had was her beauty. And she also was very smart.
01:28:12 Speaker_05
She went to law school at a time when women did not go to law school. What year is it? 19-teens. Have you seen Suffs? I've not, but I want to. The producer reached out to me and was like, please come see it. We'll get you tickets. I'm going to. Yes.
01:28:25 Speaker_08
It's a film or a show?
01:28:26 Speaker_07
It's a Broadway show.
01:28:28 Speaker_05
Broadway show. And Inez is a character in the Broadway show. Milholland. Milholland, yes. She's very beautiful and also very smart. And she is somebody who really changed what suffrage meant in this country.
01:28:40 Speaker_05
Suddenly, suffrage grew up with temperance movement.
01:28:43 Speaker_08
Let's just say suffrage is a movement to get women the right to vote.
01:28:46 Speaker_05
Yes, to enfranchise women. And the Temperance Movement was the movement that led towards the fact that we made it illegal to sell alcohol in the United States for a period of time.
01:28:55 Speaker_05
And we quickly also amended the Constitution to get rid of that amendment. These are two branches of the same vine, temperance and suffrage. It was women who were working on this for decades, 30, 40 years.
01:29:06 Speaker_05
And so by the time we get to the 19-teens, many of these women are in their 40s and 50s. And here comes Inez, who newspaper reporters said things like, her white satin dress clings to her with the tenacity with which she clings to the suffrage cause.
01:29:23 Speaker_08
Oh, very flowery.
01:29:26 Speaker_05
Suddenly, suffrage became sexy.
01:29:29 Speaker_08
Now I'm paying attention.
01:29:30 Speaker_05
Yeah. She was a very, very attractive woman who was willing to be at the front of every parade, who was willing to carry all the banners. She had a car and the idea that like women could drive. That is noteworthy. She had Inez in her car.
01:29:47 Speaker_05
She was willing to use what she had. And I know that there are a lot of feminists, myself included, who feel like women shouldn't have to trade on their looks in an effort to make change in society. But let's also be real.
01:29:57 Speaker_05
That is one of the levers of power that women have always had access to, right, is their ability to make themselves attractive in conventional sense. But Inez ultimately is a martyr for the cause of suffrage.
01:30:10 Speaker_05
And I won't give away how she goes about becoming a martyr for the cause of suffrage, but her efforts are a precursor to the passage of the 19th Amendment.
01:30:20 Speaker_05
And I think one of the things that's worth remembering about Inez, of course, she martyrs herself. And so her sacrifice is noteworthy. But ultimately, she dies before the 19th Amendment is passed.
01:30:30 Speaker_05
And one of the things that people say about her after she's gone is that no work for liberty can be lost because it becomes part of the fabric of the nation.
01:30:41 Speaker_05
And I think that's really worth remembering that even if we don't see the ball make it into the end zone, whatever we're working for, even if we don't see the ultimate like, and the bill was passed and they all lived happily ever after, ultimately the fabric of the country is changed because of your efforts.
01:30:58 Speaker_05
We are made incrementally better because of your efforts. And these are the kinds of messages that I think people need in this moment when it seems like the rich and powerful have usurped the reins of power for themselves.
01:31:12 Speaker_05
This is a phrase from George Washington in his farewell address. Beware excess partisanship and factionalism, lest unscrupulous men usurp for themselves the reins of government. And I think Americans, maybe they wouldn't say it in those words.
01:31:26 Speaker_05
Unscrupulous men usurp for themselves the reins of government, but they feel that sentiment. That unscrupulous men and women have stolen the reins of power from the American people.
01:31:38 Speaker_05
And the people in this book show what it means to be able to make change because you make the choice to have hope.
01:31:46 Speaker_08
What about Claudette Colvin? Why don't I know her name, but I know Rosa Parks' name?
01:31:51 Speaker_05
That's a great question. Claudette Colvin refused to give up her seat on the bus before Rosa Parks ever gave her seat up on the bus. And Claudette Colvin was a 15-year-old girl when she refused to give up her seat on the bus.
01:32:02 Speaker_05
And in the moment these white law enforcement officers get on the bus and are telling her to give up her seat, there's a white woman who wants
01:32:09 Speaker_05
Not just her seat, but she wants all of the African-Americans in that row to get up and exit the row because she refuses to sit even in the same row. That would mean they were equal if they could sit in the same row.
01:32:20 Speaker_05
And Claudette Colvin is like, I paid for this seat. I am sitting in the black section of the bus. I have every right to sit here.
01:32:26 Speaker_08
The white woman was trying to commandeer the, oh wow.
01:32:28 Speaker_05
Yes, because the white section had filled up.
01:32:31 Speaker_08
Sure, sure, sure.
01:32:32 Speaker_05
The bus driver is yelling at everybody, you know, move back, move back.
01:32:35 Speaker_08
We got more whites, everyone back.
01:32:37 Speaker_05
Precisely, precisely. Yeah, yeah. Exactly right. And Claudette says in that moment, she feels the hand of Harriet Tubman on one shoulder and the hand of Sojourner Truth on the other. And she feels them sort of like pin her down in her seat.
01:32:50 Speaker_05
You know, if she had been alive today and she had seen Hamilton, she would know the phrase history has its eyes on you, that she refuses in that moment to get up. They actually pick her up and carry her off the bus and bring her to jail.
01:33:01 Speaker_05
They bring her to an adult jail. Again, she's 15 years old. She's sitting in the backseat of the police car while the two officers who are driving her, one wedges himself in the backseat next to her.
01:33:11 Speaker_05
They're having a conversation about her bra size amongst themselves while she said she's riding in the backseat of the car, like pinning her knees together, repeating scripture to herself that she will not be sexually assaulted by these police officers.
01:33:25 Speaker_05
because for hundreds of years, black women were sexually assaulted by white men and nothing ever happened as a result of it. In fact, Rosa Parks was a rape investigator before she ever became the face of the civil rights movement.
01:33:39 Speaker_05
She worked for the NAACP investigating rapes. Wow. So eventually Claudette Colvin gets pregnant. And so she is a pregnant 16 year old during the Montgomery bus boycott.
01:33:52 Speaker_05
And she is essentially excluded from being the face of the civil rights movement because she's a pregnant teenager and she's not the right one. And one of the reasons, right, the optics of it were important.
01:34:07 Speaker_05
They needed somebody who was regarded as quote unquote Respectable.
01:34:11 Speaker_08
And sympathetic.
01:34:12 Speaker_05
Yes. And pregnant teenagers of any race were not viewed as respectable people.
01:34:17 Speaker_08
We got to kick them to the curb.
01:34:18 Speaker_05
That's right. We had to kick Claudette out of school, which is what they did. You weren't allowed to stay at school. And Rosa Parks was viewed as, again, quote unquote, respectable.
01:34:27 Speaker_05
She was a seamstress, a quiet, mild-mannered, pleasant-looking mom figure who was not viewed as, quote unquote, problematic, like perhaps a pregnant teenager would have been.
01:34:39 Speaker_05
Claudette Colvin ultimately feels abandoned by the civil rights movement, like they just cast her to the side. When she gives birth, nobody contacts her and tries to help her with her baby. Nobody sends her a welcome baby gift.
01:34:51 Speaker_08
Do we know the father, a much older person?
01:34:54 Speaker_05
No, she has never publicized who the father of her baby was, but some people presumed that he was a white man with whom she had a consensual relationship. But yet Claudette talked openly about how she had absolutely no idea where babies came from.
01:35:09 Speaker_05
She was taken advantage of by an older man who was married. But we don't know his identity. We don't know for sure if he was white. But she talked about how they had a consensual relationship with each other. But again, she's a teenager. Yeah.
01:35:20 Speaker_05
How consensual can it be?
01:35:21 Speaker_08
So I'm saying if you're a black girl in that era, in that place, it's not like she's safe when she got away from the police. Oh, my God. You're just not safe.
01:35:30 Speaker_05
That's right. She gives birth and she raises her child and all of these things. And ultimately, Claudette Colvin was the party to an important civil rights lawsuit regarding the bus boycott.
01:35:40 Speaker_05
Browder v. Gayle, the Supreme Court ultimately declared segregation on Montgomery buses unconstitutional.
01:35:47 Speaker_05
And she has the courage, even though she's been abandoned by the civil rights movement, on the morning that this trial is starting, she's one of the witnesses on this trial, she has to like pump her breast milk because she has a new baby.
01:36:00 Speaker_08
with a 60s pump.
01:36:01 Speaker_05
Nothing fancy. So that she's not a breastfeeding teenager leaking milk everywhere in a courtroom where she knows that the opposing counsel is going to try to destroy her character.
01:36:12 Speaker_05
And she was smart enough to anticipate what it was that they were trying to do to her. They kept trying to trip her up. They kept trying to get her to admit that Martin Luther King put her up to it.
01:36:24 Speaker_05
Kept trying to get her to admit that she was a pawn in this bigger party.
01:36:27 Speaker_08
A big conspiracy.
01:36:28 Speaker_05
Yes. And she's smart enough to know that she shouldn't take the bait. And ultimately, the lawsuit was successful. And she had an incredibly important role in the first domino that falls in segregation in the United States.
01:36:44 Speaker_05
But because she was a pregnant teenager, She was relegated to the sidebars of history. She's actually convicted of multiple crimes as a result of refusing to get off of the bus. Claudette Colvin's still alive.
01:36:58 Speaker_05
It wasn't until recently that her criminal record was expunged, that she filed a request with the state of Alabama. She's like, I did nothing wrong. Your laws were unconstitutional.
01:37:09 Speaker_05
And so within the last couple of years, she has had that conviction removed from her criminal record. Yes.
01:37:18 Speaker_09
Wow.
01:37:19 Speaker_08
Oh, my gosh. OK. I guess the thing that I would maybe like to go out on, it's a very hopeful book. And I think it's good that you point out you got to kind of choose it. I wrestle with that all the time.
01:37:30 Speaker_05
Yeah, do you find yourself struggling with choosing to be hopeful? Do you find yourself struggling with cynicism?
01:37:34 Speaker_08
Yeah, I have these two voices in my head. One is I'm just a pessimist by default, or who knows, by nurture. But then also I have Steven Pinker's long arc of history in my mind. So I know that the ideals of the Enlightenment are coming true.
01:37:47 Speaker_08
I know life's getting better. I know society's getting better. I know that we have less infant mortality. I know we have less starving people. I know all the metrics are good. So I must always keep that in the back of my mind, that it is getting better.
01:38:01 Speaker_08
But I get a little pessimistic about where everyone's at, and I get pessimistic about the road out.
01:38:08 Speaker_05
Are you naturally cynical? That's a good question. No shade if you are. No, I know. I think it's a very common way to be.
01:38:15 Speaker_02
I think I'm skeptical. Skeptical is healthy. I don't know if I'm cynical. What do you think? Do you think I am?
01:38:23 Speaker_08
No.
01:38:24 Speaker_02
I don't think I am.
01:38:25 Speaker_08
You're not cynical.
01:38:26 Speaker_02
Actually, I do think that I am hopeful, even in the face of a lot of things that don't seem it.
01:38:33 Speaker_08
My pessimism stems from the fact that both sides have a winner takes all mentality. If you're on the left, the solution is for the left to win and dominate. And if you're on the right, the solution is for the right to win and dominate.
01:38:45 Speaker_08
And it scares me that you have a marriage. This is what no one wants to admit. We are in a marriage in this country and we're not getting out. There's no way to end the marriage. We're not dividing up the country into the coast. That's not happening.
01:38:57 Speaker_08
So we look at it in a Gottman Institute way. It's like, OK, well, we're married. How do we make the best out of this marriage? And when I hear that both sides' opinion is how to make it better is winner takes all.
01:39:06 Speaker_05
Annihilation.
01:39:07 Speaker_08
Yeah. I get really hopeless. I'm like, the marriage will never get better if both people are still stuck on who's right. That's the truth.
01:39:14 Speaker_08
And so it's really hard for me when I look through that lens to see who's going first, who's going to have the first huge act of generous leap of faith, who's going to treat the other side with some respect.
01:39:24 Speaker_08
I just get scared because as you see in marriages back to Gottman, they can watch a one hour conversation between a couple and predict 96% if they'll get divorced, they can watch five minutes and still be in the high 80s. And it's contempt.
01:39:38 Speaker_08
If you have contempt for your partner, the marriage is going to fail. And the level of just ubiquitous contempt for each other is so disheartening to me.
01:39:45 Speaker_05
Yeah, you're not wrong that the level of contempt is very high. I think where it might be helpful to you to think about this is we cannot wait for a person on a white horse to ride in and be the plan.
01:40:01 Speaker_05
The plan is not a dude with a scroll that arrives with a trumpet and is like, I have arrived and here is the plan.
01:40:10 Speaker_08
I've just spoken with God.
01:40:12 Speaker_05
Yeah, that's right. By the way, if a dude does arrive with a scroll that says the plan, they want to be a dictator. Yeah, exactly.
01:40:17 Speaker_04
Like the dude with the plan is the dictator. He's scared of that person.
01:40:20 Speaker_05
Be scared of the dude with the plan. We cannot sit around waiting for someone to go first, for someone to come save us, for a political figure to be the voice of reason, because we're the plan. The political party is not the plan.
01:40:35 Speaker_05
And if you are wedded to a political party being the plan, you are going to be disappointed and you are going to be cynical because that political party is going to fail over and over. They're going to fail if they compromise in your eyes.
01:40:49 Speaker_05
We didn't get everything we wanted. When in reality, compromise is the only way anything gets done. Anybody who's ever been married will tell you that it can't be all your way and it can't be all their way. Sometimes we have to eat food we don't like.
01:40:59 Speaker_05
The compromise cannot be viewed as a failure. The change is going to come when we decide that that's how it's going to be. That's a tremendously freeing feeling because I am no longer subject to external forces that I have no control over.
01:41:17 Speaker_05
I don't have to wait for the right person to get elected.
01:41:19 Speaker_05
The world's shittiest human can get elected, and I can still do everything I can, and I can still impact the world for good, and I can still change the course of history despite my external circumstances.
01:41:32 Speaker_05
And this book is full of people who prove exactly that. Most of the big and important things that have happened in this country, the lasting change that has been created, has come about
01:41:44 Speaker_05
from ordinary people, the pregnant teenagers of history, the people whose parents were enslaved, the wrongfully accused, who just kept doing the next needed thing, the people who just kept trying things nobody else had ever done before, the people who were willing to let other people watch them fail.
01:42:06 Speaker_05
We're afraid to let people watch us fail, but the great Americans of history
01:42:11 Speaker_05
have failed over and over, and have set aside the fear of judgment of others, and have just decided, I can work with my enemies because my enemies might have a change of heart at any moment.
01:42:23 Speaker_05
And how will our enemies ever have a change of heart if we are not there to show them the light?
01:42:27 Speaker_05
How will our enemies ever change if we are not a force for good in their lives, if we have blocked, deleted, canceled, and unfriended the people who ideologically oppose us?
01:42:39 Speaker_05
So that orientation of your spirit does not come from a place of everything is going great, comes from the knowledge that things will improve when I choose to hope that they can.
01:42:54 Speaker_08
I love it. Yeah. I know the compromise is set up as this binary compromises failure versus the reality of it, which is compromises. You get some of the stuff you wanted,
01:43:02 Speaker_05
Yes. And then you can build on that from there.
01:43:05 Speaker_08
True binary is, or you get none of it. Or you get nothing. Or you get some of it for four years and then it goes away in the next administration. It's really the choice between nothing and something.
01:43:15 Speaker_05
That's exactly right. And then you can build on something. That is how all long term change happens. Anybody who is advocating for like a revolution, revolutions have happened infrequently. They are always bloody. They're always highly destructive.
01:43:29 Speaker_08
The party that comes out on the other side of it generally fucks it up even worse for the next 15, 20 years.
01:43:36 Speaker_05
Complete unknown of what is gonna happen afterwards. We view the American revolution as like the standard of which to judge all revolutions.
01:43:44 Speaker_08
Yeah, your enemy's 3,000 miles away by boat.
01:43:46 Speaker_05
Precisely, that's exactly right. And the British were like, you know what, fine. They were willing to let it go.
01:43:53 Speaker_08
Truly. We really rally around it. And I'm grateful for it. But I mean, at any point, they could have gone all in. I mean, we barely got through.
01:43:59 Speaker_05
Right. Well, and they tried to come back in the war of 1812. And then they tried to, like, let the White House on fire and let the Capitol on fire. And eventually they were like, fine, you what? Never mind. We're better off as friends.
01:44:09 Speaker_05
Let's both hate France.
01:44:10 Speaker_09
You know what I mean?
01:44:12 Speaker_05
They let it go. But the idea of a revolution within the confines of your own border is an entirely separate matter. Change in a pluralistic society should not be advocated for in a revolutionary sense. Change is incremental.
01:44:24 Speaker_05
You have these two forces of like this very progressive force that wants to have a trajectory of change at a rate that the conservative breaks are not willing to tolerate. And ultimately, the conservative breaks are an important component in this
01:44:40 Speaker_05
relationship because it's too easy to go quickly too far afield if you have nobody being like, slow down. Yeah.
01:44:46 Speaker_08
Well, the only thing the left and right agrees on is social media is terrible and that's something that had no brakes.
01:44:52 Speaker_02
Yeah, that's true.
01:44:53 Speaker_08
It's just like, go, let's see. And now we're going to do it again with AI. We'll see. OK, go.
01:44:57 Speaker_02
Yeah, no breaks.
01:44:59 Speaker_08
Oh, my Lord. Well, Sharon, you got to come back. I didn't get into so much. I didn't get into the electoral college. I didn't get in the function and structure.
01:45:06 Speaker_05
I will come back any old time. You just give me a jingle.
01:45:09 Speaker_08
OK, everyone, check out the small and mighty 12 unsung Americans who changed the course of history. Also, listen to your great podcast. Here's where it gets interesting. You're over 400, 400 episodes.
01:45:20 Speaker_06
Yeah. Yeah. You know what it's like.
01:45:23 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Sharon, this has been so fun. And The Small and Mighty, I hope everyone checks it out. Thank you. And I hope everyone opens the door to 10% more hopefulness.
01:45:32 Speaker_05
Yeah. Myself included. Thank you.
01:45:35 Speaker_08
You're radical. I see why you have a huge following.
01:45:37 Speaker_05
Yeah. Thanks for inviting me. I loved it.
01:45:40 Speaker_08
Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert, if you dare. We are supported by Macy's. Macy's is your one-stop shop for all things gifting this holiday season. If you have trouble knowing what to give or ask for, Macy's gift guide is here to help.
01:46:00 Speaker_08
I love a gift guide, Monica. I need them so much. I'm so bad at this.
01:46:04 Speaker_02
Gift guides are important. I mean, Macy's is classic.
01:46:07 Speaker_08
Trusted brand.
01:46:08 Speaker_02
Yes. I was on their online store the other day buying something for a family member. I won't say, cause I don't want to give it away.
01:46:16 Speaker_08
Right. Smart.
01:46:17 Speaker_02
It was a gift and you know, it is, it's just like classic and homey and everything's great.
01:46:22 Speaker_08
Yeah. You can shop a curated list and editors picks for under $25 under $50 and even Lux gift ideas. The Macy's Gift Guide is also a great way to figure out what you want for the holidays. This is my problem. I can never think of what I want.
01:46:35 Speaker_08
But they've got gifts for her, gifts for him, gifts for home. Spend a little time looking through their hand-picked selection, and you're sure to find something that catches your eye. Let Macy's be your guide to gifting this holiday season.
01:46:47 Speaker_08
Check out the Macy's Gift Guide at Macy's.com for all the gifts you'd like to give and get, curated for stress-free shopping. Shop now at Macy's.com and at a Macy's store near you.
01:47:03 Speaker_10
Stay tuned for the fact check. It's where the party's at.
01:47:10 Speaker_02
I said, I already had to start walking to work. And can you please make sure that doesn't happen again? It's happened a few times where there's been a car right there. And she said, I have workers in the building.
01:47:19 Speaker_02
They will potentially be here tomorrow, too. Like, that's not the appropriate answer.
01:47:24 Speaker_08
They can't park there.
01:47:24 Speaker_02
Yeah, I know.
01:47:25 Speaker_08
Say, well, the workers definitely can't park behind our cars.
01:47:29 Speaker_02
What is wrong with everybody?
01:47:32 Speaker_08
I'm totally in a spiral right now myself.
01:47:34 Speaker_02
What the fuck is going on with the world?
01:47:37 Speaker_08
Something's going on. Do you want to hear this recent one?
01:47:40 Speaker_02
Yeah.
01:47:40 Speaker_08
I'm like, I'm having an oversized reaction for sure. I know it. It's weirdly related to us talking about the claustrophobia last episode. So, you know, I did another commercial and then as they do, they send out like a release for tattoos.
01:47:56 Speaker_02
Oh, yes, yes, yes, yes.
01:47:58 Speaker_08
And so I send it to her. She's, you know, last time she signed it. And when I got them, I specifically said, you know, I would never want to work with a tattoo artist that tries to get paid from their tattoos when you act.
01:48:11 Speaker_08
Like, I don't want to get tattoos that I can't I can't act anymore. Yeah. So I send her a thing saying like, hey, would you sign this or do you want me to sign it? She even said last time, just sign those. Cool. This is the vibe I'm looking for.
01:48:25 Speaker_02
Yeah.
01:48:26 Speaker_08
So she sends me back a text that's like, yeah, literally a bunch of language that sounds so weird and legal. And I'm like, what is going on? First of all, you have a little sweat here and you'll regret it when you watch it.
01:48:38 Speaker_08
The wording is so weird and immediately I'm like, what is going on? So then I call her and I go, hey, what does this text mean? And she's like, well, I am sick of people using my art and you were in a Super Bowl commercial.
01:48:54 Speaker_08
And I go, I was not in a Super Bowl commercial. And she goes, yes, you were. And I go, I don't want to say her name. Yeah, I was not in a Super Bowl. I know I'm not in a Super Bowl commercial. And she's like, this business should pay.
01:49:11 Speaker_08
And I'm like, listen, what you're doing right now is setting up that every time I ever work, because they always ask, are you going to be able to get those signed off on? And I say, yes, because we have that arrangement.
01:49:24 Speaker_08
And now I'm going to say, no, you'll have to negotiate with her. And they're going to say, you have to be in a long sleeve. So I just want, you know, like what you're telling me is that sincerely I can never do my job again in a t-shirt.
01:49:38 Speaker_08
That's like the fallout of what you're saying.
01:49:41 Speaker_02
But she had already agreed.
01:49:42 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah, yeah. The last go-around of the commercials it signed.
01:49:45 Speaker_02
Oh my God.
01:49:46 Speaker_08
And in my mind, I'm like, okay, I'm trying to make a good argument for her. I'm like, how has she decided people are profiting from her work and she's not getting a kickback?
01:49:56 Speaker_02
Yeah, it's like one thing if you were doing a tattoo commercial.
01:49:59 Speaker_08
Yeah, it'd be another thing about selling like an action figure of myself and you could argue this is part of, you know, but like I'm just either, so I'm having this very oversized reaction of like, I feel like I have to get my whole fucking arm lasered off because I can't be held hostage.
01:50:17 Speaker_02
Yeah. Well, you won't have to do that. I'm sure it'll get worked out, but like.
01:50:22 Speaker_08
I'm so, I'm just hurt by it.
01:50:25 Speaker_02
I know, I know.
01:50:26 Speaker_08
I finally texted her, I'm like, I'm just really hurt by this. Every time she ever gave me the bill, I promise you, I'm bragging, this is just relevant. I always gave her twice what she ever asked for. Like I was, I went out of my way to try to be.
01:50:41 Speaker_02
I am sorry. That's so annoying.
01:50:43 Speaker_08
It's so annoying. And now I feel like I have this like I'm overreacting, but I'm like, I'm going to get them all lasered up and then I'm going to have a different, you know, whatever.
01:50:51 Speaker_08
It's just a crazy, literally for the rest of my career, I have to wear it.
01:50:54 Speaker_02
But you don't.
01:50:55 Speaker_08
Or go through two hours of makeup and get it all covered.
01:50:58 Speaker_02
I mean, can't, oh God, I guess like, it wasn't in writing from the beginning that you could.
01:51:04 Speaker_08
Yeah, I wish I would've known like, if I ever got a tattoo, I gotta be like, hey, I want a tattoo, but I need you to give me the rights, at least in my arm. I'm not asking for the rights to reproduce the image and sell stills of it or sell,
01:51:17 Speaker_08
Anything, just if it's on my body, I gotta be able to walk around and do things. Like how dare you? Like, I feel like I got branded now.
01:51:24 Speaker_02
Yeah, it's like, it feels violating. It does. Yeah. I'm sorry.
01:51:28 Speaker_08
Yeah, it's a real, again, I know I'm, it just happened, so I'm really like hot about it. I feel so powerless. Like, okay, well, that's a wrap on that.
01:51:37 Speaker_02
Oh my God. I hate people. I do. Today. Today only. Well, I don't know how many more days, but I don't know what's going on.
01:51:52 Speaker_08
Okay. Well, I'm glad I vented.
01:51:54 Speaker_02
Yeah. That's very frustrating. People are, are we leaving that in?
01:52:01 Speaker_08
Yeah.
01:52:01 Speaker_02
Okay.
01:52:01 Speaker_08
I mean, that's what happened.
01:52:03 Speaker_02
Yeah, both of us are in the middle of some bureaucratic crises. I don't like the way I'm being spoken to.
01:52:13 Speaker_08
Oh my God.
01:52:14 Speaker_02
At all.
01:52:15 Speaker_08
You're being talked to by a lawyer. I've read some of this stuff. And I'm actually, I'm going to applaud your restraint.
01:52:22 Speaker_02
Thank you.
01:52:23 Speaker_08
Because I have wanted to come unglued the way this lawyer is talking to you.
01:52:27 Speaker_02
It's so disrespectful and condescending.
01:52:30 Speaker_08
Condescending. Apex condescending.
01:52:33 Speaker_02
It's just dripping.
01:52:33 Speaker_08
Yes, yes.
01:52:35 Speaker_02
I will say this to anyone who's listening. This is a PSA. If you are being represented by someone, you really need to know how they're representing you.
01:52:48 Speaker_02
Because during this process, a lot of what I've thought is, holy shit, I need to make sure no one on my behalf is ever speaking to anyone like this ever. Even if I might not know, and this happens in this job too, with publicists and agents.
01:53:07 Speaker_02
And one time it happened, it was so rough, the representative was so rough, that we were like, well, we're not gonna do it. And I know this person. And I was like, I need to tell this person because they don't- Did you? Yeah.
01:53:23 Speaker_08
Oh, and what was their response?
01:53:25 Speaker_02
They were like, I had no idea and I'm so sorry that that happened. And like, I wonder how many other times this has happened.
01:53:34 Speaker_08
Right. Well, just to make one counterpoint, because I was privy to three and a half years ago, a ton of correspondence between lawyers, some that were representing me and some that were representing another entity.
01:53:47 Speaker_08
And I will, I can admit, I was so much more agitated by the way the lawyers were talking than the lawyers were.
01:53:55 Speaker_02
Yeah.
01:53:55 Speaker_08
I do think they have a really like weird baseline aggressive condescending, like if anything, it just made me really happy. That's not my day-to-day drafting letters like that and stuff.
01:54:07 Speaker_08
That seems, I just don't think I'd go down my lunch break and feel great.
01:54:12 Speaker_02
Yeah.
01:54:13 Speaker_08
Just being engaged in this like really sharp back and forth.
01:54:17 Speaker_02
Yeah, maybe you're right. I just think there's different levels of it. Like I know a lawyer well who I know doesn't.
01:54:24 Speaker_08
Max?
01:54:24 Speaker_02
Yeah.
01:54:25 Speaker_08
Yeah. Me too, Tom Hanson.
01:54:27 Speaker_02
I mean, I know, I know multiple lawyers and I think there's a scale of how they speak to people.
01:54:32 Speaker_08
Yeah.
01:54:33 Speaker_02
And I think a very good lawyer does not speak.
01:54:36 Speaker_08
Yeah.
01:54:36 Speaker_02
Condescendingly, they speak very directly. Sure.
01:54:40 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah. I think the ones that long term, I think you can get like little Pyrrhic victories along the way and be misled, but long term, this is kind of similar. This is tangential, but related.
01:54:51 Speaker_08
Actors, there's a ton of them, get away with horrendous behavior while their movies are working and while their shows are working. And I have been given a lot of second chances in show business, for sure. So grateful for that.
01:55:06 Speaker_08
I had peers that all hit at the same time as I did. Some of them were really, really hard to deal with, and when they had downturns, there was no second chance for them. You know? Kristen.
01:55:19 Speaker_10
Yeah.
01:55:19 Speaker_08
She had like lows in movies after, what's her name? Sarah Marshall. A couple that just were okay financially.
01:55:27 Speaker_02
Yeah.
01:55:27 Speaker_08
But people stand in line to work with her.
01:55:30 Speaker_02
Yeah. If you're kind of nice and easy to work with and good at your job, ultimately you- Long term. Yeah. It works out for you.
01:55:40 Speaker_02
But that's all to say I think you really have to keep an eye on who's speaking for you because that can change the public opinion of you or the personal opinion of you. It's dicey.
01:55:54 Speaker_08
Anywho.
01:55:55 Speaker_02
I guess it's a ding ding ding because this is for America's government teacher. Yes.
01:56:01 Speaker_08
Who we love. That was so fun and we only got to like two or three things on my whole list.
01:56:06 Speaker_02
I know we could have talked to her forever.
01:56:08 Speaker_08
I feel bad about being cranky on a fact check but I guess it's okay.
01:56:12 Speaker_02
At least we're saying it.
01:56:14 Speaker_08
I was I didn't I just knew I couldn't get I knew that I was so upset it when we sat down. Yeah, that I feel like me hiding it would have I'm not even sure I would've been able to hide it.
01:56:24 Speaker_02
It's not even I on my walk. Wait, when do we start recording? Did we talk? Did we get on air that? My car was blocked.
01:56:33 Speaker_08
No, no. You walked here.
01:56:34 Speaker_02
I walked here unexpectedly because I went to my car and it was blocked.
01:56:40 Speaker_08
Yeah. Someone's parked behind you.
01:56:41 Speaker_02
Yes.
01:56:41 Speaker_08
In your parking spot.
01:56:43 Speaker_02
Yes. And I couldn't back out. And I just got my car fixed. And I was like, I'm not like going to attempt to try to.
01:56:49 Speaker_08
Oh, I guess I'm now I have a grievance because I really wanted to see the door.
01:56:53 Speaker_02
You should be mad about it. Yeah. Yeah. Anyway. And so I texted my landlord and I was like, somebody's parked here. Can you ask them to leave? Yeah. And then I'm not hearing back. So I'm like, I got to walk.
01:57:05 Speaker_02
So I started walking and then I got a text back that I did not like that didn't feel it's like, it's just easy to say, Oh, I'm sorry that happened. Yeah, we'll handle it. Or yes. You know, I'm not there all the time, but we'll figure it out. Yeah.
01:57:20 Speaker_02
It's easy. I don't understand what happens to people's brains when they, I guess they feel attacked, even though this has not, it wasn't like I was like, you did this.
01:57:29 Speaker_08
You son of a bitch.
01:57:30 Speaker_02
Yeah. Anyway. So I had to walk here.
01:57:33 Speaker_08
I'm going to be 20 minutes late to work because of you.
01:57:34 Speaker_02
I walked here. I was itchy. Yeah.
01:57:37 Speaker_08
It's hot.
01:57:38 Speaker_02
It's hot. I put makeup on and I was like, my face is going to break out because I'm wearing makeup and I'm walking.
01:57:44 Speaker_08
You wore a, An outfit for a car ride.
01:57:47 Speaker_02
I did. Yeah.
01:57:48 Speaker_08
And you didn't have time to go in and change, put on shorts and a tank.
01:57:51 Speaker_02
No, I didn't. So I on my walk, I planned on saying I'm in a really bad mood.
01:57:57 Speaker_08
Oh, that's what you were going to do.
01:57:59 Speaker_02
Yeah, I was going to tell people I was in a bad mood. And then you told me you were in a bad mood.
01:58:02 Speaker_08
Yeah, well, that's kind of nice. I like that word.
01:58:05 Speaker_02
Too bad to make it good?
01:58:06 Speaker_08
Yeah, I'm already happier.
01:58:08 Speaker_02
Me too. Yeah.
01:58:09 Speaker_08
This is a good venting session. I don't feel as alone in the thoughts.
01:58:13 Speaker_02
That's why we have support systems.
01:58:14 Speaker_08
I started ruminating in the, you know, the examples are getting more and more dramatic in my head.
01:58:20 Speaker_02
It's going to be okay. But I know, but it is rude. I'm going to cut my arm off. We almost lost a finger this week and an arm.
01:58:28 Speaker_08
And a toes on the way out.
01:58:29 Speaker_02
Oh yeah, how's the toe?
01:58:31 Speaker_08
A lot of people are really mad at me and I understand why. They're like, get to the fucking Dr. Shepard. Yeah, and that's fair. That's really fair.
01:58:39 Speaker_02
They care about you.
01:58:40 Speaker_08
Yeah, it's really sweet.
01:58:41 Speaker_02
Speaking of outfits since I walked here in this outfit. I want to shout out this sweatshirt.
01:58:46 Speaker_08
Okay, great.
01:58:46 Speaker_02
It's from It's my Marston show. No member came. You want to tell people what happened to Kmart?
01:58:52 Speaker_08
I almost can't especially with this other upset I read an article that they closed the last Kmart. I hated that It's really sad also in the article. It said there was years where they were making 36 billion a year Wow
01:59:06 Speaker_08
How, like if you're sitting on top of a, yeah, I think so. But can you, you're sitting on a company that's making 36 billion a year. I don't know how you imagine like, well, we're going to be completely bankrupt in a few years. Yeah.
01:59:19 Speaker_02
How long, longer than a few years, right?
01:59:22 Speaker_08
Probably. I'm sure it was a gradual.
01:59:24 Speaker_02
Yeah. Oof. Well, R.I.P. K-Mart.
01:59:27 Speaker_08
I know. I loved going to K-Mart with Papa Bob, get those hot wheels, wake him up, put some washcloths on his face, get punched across the room and then go get the mongoose.
01:59:37 Speaker_02
And on to K-Mart. Yeah, no.
01:59:39 Speaker_01
Rob, there's apparently a couple of them in Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands if you want to go.
01:59:43 Speaker_08
Remember I said that to you? I don't know if globally they're done.
01:59:47 Speaker_01
That was the last American one closed.
01:59:49 Speaker_08
Last American one.
01:59:50 Speaker_02
We should go to Guam. All right.
01:59:52 Speaker_08
I've never been to Guam.
01:59:53 Speaker_02
Me either. I would like to go. Okay, no, but this sweatshirt is not from Kmart. It is from Hey Gang. Okay. And it is from Kristen's show.
02:00:02 Speaker_10
Oh.
02:00:03 Speaker_02
Her show, Nobody Wants This. Kristen, in one of the episodes, wears this sweatshirt. She says, oh, it's my favorite sweatshirt, and I'm going to ruin it for you, this dog.
02:00:13 Speaker_08
Oh, yeah, yeah.
02:00:14 Speaker_02
And I obviously asked her where the sweatshirt was from.
02:00:16 Speaker_08
And that's the dog that looked weirdly like a two and a half times size whiskey.
02:00:20 Speaker_02
It did.
02:00:21 Speaker_08
It was exactly like whiskey, but two and a half times.
02:00:23 Speaker_02
Yeah, I was triggered a little bit.
02:00:25 Speaker_08
Yeah, PTSD.
02:00:27 Speaker_02
So I asked her and she was like, yes. Get it, get it now, get two.
02:00:32 Speaker_08
Oh, that's what she said.
02:00:33 Speaker_02
She told me to get two.
02:00:34 Speaker_08
And you did?
02:00:35 Speaker_02
Yeah, obviously I did.
02:00:36 Speaker_08
Okay, smart.
02:00:37 Speaker_02
So in case one goes, gets, you know.
02:00:40 Speaker_08
In case you find a dog. Life and art. Life and art.
02:00:44 Speaker_02
So anyway, it's a great sweatshirt, highly recommend it. Get two.
02:00:47 Speaker_08
OK, now I want to say something that I know it's going to make you really nervous, but I feel I'll tell you why I really feel compelled, because I can relate. So first of all, lots of people have been having fun with two minutes in the archive.
02:00:59 Speaker_08
So it's going well for the most part. It really is. But a lot of people are really, really confused. And for those people, because I'm a bit this way. This is a bad characteristic of mine.
02:01:09 Speaker_08
It's not bad in them, but in me, it's bad is, um, if I feel like I'm being manipulated or tricked or I don't like that.
02:01:18 Speaker_10
Yeah.
02:01:19 Speaker_08
So when I, I heard, I heard enough of those words, like, you know, for the means in the audience, I feel like I just want to be honest.
02:01:25 Speaker_02
And this is also why I said we shouldn't be doing that bit.
02:01:28 Speaker_08
I know. But I've really thought this through and I think it's okay.
02:01:31 Speaker_08
So for those people, the long and the short of it, I can't get into why we're in this situation, but I do want to say that it's incredibly helpful to us if people check out the archive.
02:01:41 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:01:41 Speaker_08
That's it.
02:01:42 Speaker_02
And no pressure. No pressure.
02:01:45 Speaker_08
No pressure.
02:01:46 Speaker_02
But we do have some good episodes in there.
02:01:48 Speaker_08
Yeah, yeah. And also you can go to YouTube.
02:01:50 Speaker_02
Also watch us on YouTube. Watch the fact check on YouTube because it is fun.
02:01:54 Speaker_08
It's fun.
02:01:55 Speaker_02
Yeah. I enjoy it. Okay.
02:02:00 Speaker_08
I took a hike this morning.
02:02:01 Speaker_02
Uh-huh.
02:02:02 Speaker_08
I had been feeling really rough for a week and really tired and sleeping every chance I could.
02:02:06 Speaker_02
And you had Hannes.
02:02:07 Speaker_08
And I had a, yeah, I had a, I had a Hannes.
02:02:10 Speaker_02
You had the bug I had, I think.
02:02:12 Speaker_08
I had the bug you had. But anyways, today I was like, I think I got it in me. And I did go for a hike. And something happened about two-thirds of the way through the hike on the way down. It kind of broke.
02:02:24 Speaker_08
I found myself dancing as I was coming down the hill.
02:02:27 Speaker_09
Oh, wow.
02:02:27 Speaker_08
Yeah. I was skipping and I was listening to a great song and I was really just dancing. I was feeling really good. Before you got the... Before the tattoo thing happened, yeah. So I was feeling really good.
02:02:40 Speaker_08
And then I got home and I was like, oh, I got to get the trailer ready for the hayride because I'm going out of town tomorrow morning.
02:02:46 Speaker_09
Yeah.
02:02:46 Speaker_08
And when I land, it's virtually Halloween. So I got to be on it, which meant I got to take the razor out of the trailer. Of course, the battery in the Razor's dead, as you would expect. That's a whole thing.
02:02:59 Speaker_08
And then this was the most non-linear little string of chores I've ever done. So I go to charge the battery. That's not working. Then I realized I got to jump the battery.
02:03:11 Speaker_08
Also, they've stacked so much stuff from the remodel of this garage for this studio on the So there's just trash everywhere. So I'm dealing with trash. And then I go in to get my leaf blower because I want to blow out all the crap of the thing.
02:03:24 Speaker_08
And I see my chainsaw and I'm like, oh, I've been meaning to cut.
02:03:27 Speaker_02
Oh, my God.
02:03:28 Speaker_08
This is so crazy. I'm like, oh, fuck. I've been meaning to cut that branch off of that ficus that's by the sauna. And so I grabbed, now I have my chainsaw and my leaf blower. And then, I mean, I'm doing way too many things at once.
02:03:43 Speaker_08
And I'm like, I got to fill the tires with, and then I parked the RZR, I get it going, I jump it, I got to park the RZR on the side of the yard where I realize there's too much junk in that side of the yard. I'm going to start packing.
02:03:52 Speaker_08
piling it up behind the garage. So I'm doing that and I keep moving the chainsaw. Then I go and I cut the, the, the tree limb down and then I got to take it to the driveway and cut it in a bunch of small pieces to put in the thing.
02:04:03 Speaker_08
And all, when I came in, cause I, I went right from my hike to starting this thing and I was in a little white tank top and my little blue hiking shorts.
02:04:11 Speaker_08
And by the time I came in, Carly was inside and it looked like I had laid down in a pile of leaves and rolled around for like 20 minutes because I was so sweaty before I started all this stuff. Yeah, you look crazy.
02:04:22 Speaker_08
And my face was dripping with sweat.
02:04:24 Speaker_10
Oh my.
02:04:25 Speaker_08
It was about an hour and 30 minutes of like me hustling and then looking at that, deciding to do that. Again, very scattered approach to all these tasks. So when I walked in, Carly looked at me and she just goes, what happened to you?
02:04:41 Speaker_02
Yeah, that's a fair question. I guess it's time for me to remind you that last episode, you were very concerned about me using a very tiny tool to try to get my ring off. And here you are juggling chainsaws and leaf blowers and chopping and chopping.
02:05:00 Speaker_08
But I put the leaf blower down when I operated the chainsaw.
02:05:03 Speaker_02
I mean, I'm just going to say it feels a little lopsided.
02:05:07 Speaker_08
Okay. Okay. But if you saw me using the chainsaw and I was cutting the tree limb and I had my leg below the tree, like in the path of the chainsaw, you would go, that's a bad game plan. And I just think a sharp knife trying to cut metal.
02:05:23 Speaker_02
I was cutting away from my finger, FYI.
02:05:26 Speaker_08
But a sharp knife in a, You'd have to go under the ring.
02:05:31 Speaker_02
I was under, yeah.
02:05:32 Speaker_08
And then the finger is a water weenie. It's a big balloon.
02:05:36 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:05:37 Speaker_08
And so you're either going that way towards the balloon or you're coming this way towards your artery.
02:05:43 Speaker_02
Oh, God. Both of those are really... Okay, I don't like that.
02:05:46 Speaker_08
They're bad, bad game plans, I think.
02:05:49 Speaker_02
You're right.
02:05:50 Speaker_08
Okay. Now, I probably did do some things along the way that you would have not liked. I certainly didn't put my safety goggles on when I used the chainsaw. That's a no-no.
02:05:58 Speaker_02
That's not good. Yeah.
02:06:00 Speaker_08
Don't do that.
02:06:01 Speaker_02
Don't do that. Wear your safety goggles, folks.
02:06:03 Speaker_08
They're very good for you.
02:06:06 Speaker_02
OK, there really are not that many facts because she's a teacher.
02:06:10 Speaker_08
She has the facts.
02:06:11 Speaker_02
We talked about the different kinds of democracies and there are so many. You know, there's a direct democracy, a popular democracy, a representative democracy, a parliamentary democracy, Westminster democracy, Jacksonian democracy.
02:06:31 Speaker_02
I'm sorry, parliamentary Westminster Jacksonian are all types of representative democracies.
02:06:37 Speaker_08
Okay. What about dictatorship democracies?
02:06:40 Speaker_02
You don't see those? There's organic or authoritarian democracy.
02:06:45 Speaker_08
Ooh, how does that work?
02:06:46 Speaker_02
Democracy where the ruler holds a considerable amount of power, but their rule benefits the people. The term was first used by supporters of Bonaparte.
02:06:56 Speaker_08
Ah, Napoleon Bonaparte.
02:06:58 Speaker_02
There's also a demarchy. It's a form of government where people are randomly selected from the citizenry through sortition to either act as general governmental representatives or to make decisions in specific areas of governance. That feels dicey.
02:07:13 Speaker_02
There's religious democracies. There's types based on location, types based on ethnic influence. There's autocratic democracy, anticipatory democracy. There's so many.
02:07:23 Speaker_08
There's so many.
02:07:24 Speaker_02
Oh, there is democratic dictatorship.
02:07:26 Speaker_08
How does that work? You elect a dictator.
02:07:29 Speaker_02
People's Democratic Dictatorship is a phrase incorporated into the constitution of the People's Republic of China and the constitution of the Chinese Communist Party.
02:07:40 Speaker_02
The premise of the People's Democratic Dictatorship is that the CCP and state represent and act on behalf of the people, but in the preservation of the dictatorship of the proletariat possesses and may use powers against reactionary forces.
02:07:54 Speaker_08
What feels undemocratic about a dictatorship is I'm not aware of any dictatorship that had term limits. So like what you vote one time and then the person serves until they die.
02:08:05 Speaker_08
That seems to be how these dictatorships go or they hand it off to their son and then they die a couple weeks later. It seems kind of antithetical to democracy.
02:08:13 Speaker_02
I don't think it's real.
02:08:14 Speaker_08
Yeah. And if you're a dictator, you could just end democracy the day you get elected.
02:08:18 Speaker_02
Well, exactly. Or you just don't leave. OK, the number, this was in 2023, but 87 percent of voters surveyed said they support requiring criminal background checks for all gun buyers.
02:08:29 Speaker_08
Yeah, that's huge.
02:08:29 Speaker_02
That's overwhelming.
02:08:31 Speaker_08
Yeah.
02:08:32 Speaker_02
I'm looking at a Gallup poll also on abortion and the amount of people who think it's over 50 percent the amount of people who think it should be considered in certain circumstances.
02:08:41 Speaker_08
Just over 50.
02:08:42 Speaker_02
Well, I keep hearing like 70, but it says legal under any circumstances. The percentage is 35, which that's high or I think sort of legal only under certain is 50.
02:08:54 Speaker_08
Okay.
02:08:55 Speaker_02
Illegal in all 12, no opinion three.
02:08:59 Speaker_08
So actually legal is missing quite a bit of to make a hundred here.
02:09:04 Speaker_02
No, that is 35, 50, 12, three.
02:09:08 Speaker_08
35, 50, 85, 12, 97, three, 100. What was 12?
02:09:14 Speaker_02
Illegal in all. So really, if it's legal only under certain, that's 50, and legal under any being 35, that is really high.
02:09:24 Speaker_08
Oh, okay, that makes sense. Yeah, yeah, yeah, okay. So they're saying like 85% think that it should be legal under some situation or circumstance.
02:09:33 Speaker_02
Which is similar to the guns. What's your graph?
02:09:38 Speaker_08
Oh, I just thought this was interesting. I read it this morning. This was also in Malcolm's book, Revenge of the Tipping Point. There's very few social issues that change really rapidly.
02:09:50 Speaker_08
And one was gay marriage, as outlined in that wonderful episode I always encourage people to listen to when Will met Grace or something, Revisionist History. That changed in like 10 years, like radically changed.
02:10:02 Speaker_08
So US adults that supported legal marijuana use in 1970 was, from this graph it looks like about 5%. In 2000, it was 31%.
02:10:13 Speaker_10
And now it's 70%.
02:10:14 Speaker_08
Wow, that's nuts. Yeah, it's like more than 2x since 2000. Very few things do 70% of Americans support.
02:10:27 Speaker_02
I know. Yeah, that's pretty crazy.
02:10:30 Speaker_08
I'm all for it. I'll call you strops generally in all the States that legalize it.
02:10:35 Speaker_02
Yeah, I'm definitely for it.
02:10:37 Speaker_08
Yeah. I don't know if I love that everywhere you walk in New York smells like weed. I mean, I can deal with it. I'm not like it's, but yeah, it's just interesting. The whole city smells like weed now.
02:10:49 Speaker_08
Yeah, our city on the road smells like weed as I always say when I'm riding my motorcycle.
02:10:54 Speaker_02
I'm just in a constant cloud I never smell it.
02:10:57 Speaker_08
Well, you're in your car driving next to one. I'm like blowing by a ton Yeah at lights with their windows down smoking or whatever. It's not for me, but it's great for have you done much pot smoking? How many times have you smoked pot?
02:11:10 Speaker_02
Not very many at all. Every time I've done it, I don't like it.
02:11:13 Speaker_08
How many do you think? Did you smoke weed?
02:11:15 Speaker_02
I did it in college a couple times.
02:11:17 Speaker_08
Smoked or ate something?
02:11:18 Speaker_02
No, bong.
02:11:20 Speaker_08
Yeah, that's smoking.
02:11:21 Speaker_02
I never smoked a joint. I guess that's different, right?
02:11:25 Speaker_08
So you smoked a bong. Yeah, a couple times.
02:11:27 Speaker_02
And you coughed.
02:11:28 Speaker_08
If you weren't choking, you ain't smoking?
02:11:30 Speaker_02
Has that happened? I guess I coughed. I don't, I don't know if I did it right. I'm not very good at inhaling. Yeah.
02:11:35 Speaker_08
Maybe you didn't inhale.
02:11:36 Speaker_02
I don't know if I did that.
02:11:37 Speaker_08
Okay. And then have you ever had a gummy or anything?
02:11:40 Speaker_02
I've never had an edible.
02:11:41 Speaker_08
I don't think. Right. Um, never had a pot brownie. That's what you did before they were legal.
02:11:47 Speaker_02
Yeah. No, I don't, I don't like, I don't like it.
02:11:52 Speaker_08
It's not for you. The vape.
02:11:57 Speaker_02
The marijuana vape.
02:11:58 Speaker_08
Yeah.
02:11:59 Speaker_02
I have used that. It's not for me.
02:12:01 Speaker_08
You don't like it. I never liked it either.
02:12:03 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:12:04 Speaker_08
Especially when I was drinking. It was a disaster. Every time I smoked weed when I was drinking, I ended up throwing up and I would convince myself like once every year to try it. Like, ah, just that's not going to happen this time. It always happened.
02:12:20 Speaker_02
I just don't think I felt like I got anything from it positively.
02:12:24 Speaker_08
Yeah. Well, what I always said is it made me inarticulate, which is the only thing I love about myself.
02:12:29 Speaker_02
I know, but I think booze can do that.
02:12:32 Speaker_08
With enough of it. Yeah. Yeah. But I can, I think I was, I was pretty good at staying at the, um, like maybe I lost 8% of my verbal dexterity.
02:12:44 Speaker_02
I think it makes me smarter.
02:12:46 Speaker_08
Yes. I, a thousand percent when I would like two drinks in, I'm like, I'm on fire. Yeah.
02:12:52 Speaker_02
I'm like, these thoughts are just coming.
02:12:54 Speaker_08
The brain is firing.
02:12:55 Speaker_02
But I wonder if I was with sober people, if they would be like, no, you sound dumb.
02:13:00 Speaker_08
Well, this is very anecdotal, but I think people liked me more. Now, look, there was a zone where people didn't like me as much.
02:13:07 Speaker_08
I don't think I'm completely unobjective about this, but I do think me and one, one through three drinks, people liked me more because I just friendlier.
02:13:14 Speaker_02
No, you're friendly sober.
02:13:16 Speaker_08
Friendly enough.
02:13:17 Speaker_02
I doubt it. I doubt it.
02:13:21 Speaker_08
You smell a rat. If there was a pill that absolutely ensured that I would only have two drinks anytime I drank.
02:13:29 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:13:30 Speaker_08
That's a curious thought.
02:13:32 Speaker_02
Yeah, would you do it? I don't think you would do it.
02:13:34 Speaker_08
I mean, I want to say no, because my life's great. Other than my tattoo issue, which will pass shortly. I'll be completely over it. And I'll regret even bringing it up on this, but in fact, I think I already regret it.
02:13:43 Speaker_02
Oh, do you? Okay.
02:13:44 Speaker_08
But, um, my life is so good. Why, why would, why do I need anything more? Everything's fine.
02:13:53 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:13:53 Speaker_08
I have a great fucking life.
02:13:54 Speaker_02
And you don't miss it.
02:13:56 Speaker_08
Exactly. I'm not, um, I'm not a wallflower. I don't need it as a social lubricant. Um, you know, married, I'm out, I'm not out hitting on girls, learning a little courage.
02:14:06 Speaker_02
Exactly.
02:14:06 Speaker_08
Yeah.
02:14:07 Speaker_02
I don't see why you would. Yeah.
02:14:11 Speaker_08
Even as someone who likes it, I don't see why you would is certainly linked to what we know about me, which is just like, it's too dangerous to ever play with, but that's what you have to really believe. This procedure makes me only try.
02:14:22 Speaker_02
No, I am. I'm really thinking like, I don't see why you would, because for one, you're like, you're also like, you have a really strict diet. You like, it doesn't really make sense for you to incorporate it back in. Even if it was only two. Oh, hi.
02:14:36 Speaker_08
Who do we got there?
02:14:37 Speaker_02
That's okay.
02:14:38 Speaker_00
Hi.
02:14:40 Speaker_08
I've got the trailer, as you see, ready for you and I to bail.
02:14:43 Speaker_10
I ran home.
02:14:44 Speaker_08
You did.
02:14:45 Speaker_10
I'm worried about its condition though. I just stood on it and.
02:14:48 Speaker_08
You worried about the condition of the trailer? You did a little integrity test and you think it's below.
02:14:53 Speaker_10
I think it, I, I really hope this Halloween we don't have a broken light.
02:15:00 Speaker_08
Okay, well I'll walk around on it and we might have to put some, uh, some additional plywood or something down. Oh yes, I would love that.
02:15:07 Speaker_02
Oh, are you guys going to go get hay and stuff?
02:15:10 Speaker_08
Funny you'd say that.
02:15:11 Speaker_02
Yeah, very funny. We're going to hire very nice lawyers to deal with whoever sues us.
02:15:18 Speaker_08
All right, we'll get out of here so I can finish and then we can go. All right, I love you. Welcome home.
02:15:24 Speaker_02
Bye, buddy.
02:15:25 Speaker_08
And then that happens and I go, I don't care about my tattoo thing.
02:15:34 Speaker_02
So you're going to erase them?
02:15:38 Speaker_08
I caught my arm off.
02:15:39 Speaker_02
No.
02:15:39 Speaker_08
Just to prove to you I can.
02:15:40 Speaker_02
No. With your chainsaw?
02:15:43 Speaker_08
No, you know what I would do? Do you know how they castrate bulls?
02:15:46 Speaker_02
What? No, of course I don't know that.
02:15:47 Speaker_08
Okay. They just put a rubber band around their balls and then they just fall off at some point. That's how they do it.
02:15:55 Speaker_02
It's literally what I was doing with my finger.
02:15:57 Speaker_08
Exactly. That's exactly the point I was trying to make. So my idea would just be, I'll just tie a shoestring around my arm and cut off the circulation until one day it just falls on the ground.
02:16:08 Speaker_02
Oh my God. Listen, um, you're not going to need to do that. I'll just say, I don't think you would drink again.
02:16:24 Speaker_08
Yeah.
02:16:25 Speaker_02
I don't know that you'd like it anymore.
02:16:27 Speaker_08
One thing I would like it. That first two drinks, I love that. Windows down in Northern Michigan, Bob Seger playing Camel White, a couple beers. I mean, fuck, that was good.
02:16:38 Speaker_02
You liked the feeling of it?
02:16:40 Speaker_08
Loved. And it's the first two is we already now learned. It's dopamine. The rest is shitty. I don't miss any of, I don't miss drinks four through 12.
02:16:51 Speaker_02
I just wonder now though, if like, you're going to wake up and you're going to have a little bit of a headache. Like it's going to, it's, it's, your body's also different and it, and you're probably going to be like, Oh boy, doesn't feel good.
02:17:04 Speaker_02
I don't want to work out today. Yeah.
02:17:07 Speaker_08
My thing is more an ethical thing or it's kind of like your ring where you consider your, all your luck is gone.
02:17:12 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:17:13 Speaker_08
Mine is like, that would feel greedy. Like I have such a good life. I have so many good friends and I have a great family and it feels a little greedy to want more.
02:17:24 Speaker_08
And I feel like if I had the pill, if I took the pill so I could do that and get more, I would pay the price somehow. I just have this weird Cosmos-y feeling about that. Does that make any sense?
02:17:35 Speaker_02
It makes sense.
02:17:35 Speaker_08
Like the gods would go, your life is good enough. You don't need more. Just focus on what you have. It's so great. And by wanting more, I would somehow ruin something.
02:17:46 Speaker_02
but it's not wanting more if there is a pill that just is available. It's not like you're like, I'm spending, I'm devoting some of my life.
02:17:59 Speaker_08
Muscuato?
02:18:00 Speaker_02
I think it was a, yeah.
02:18:01 Speaker_08
Muscuato's are hot right now. My zapper's going off like crazy.
02:18:06 Speaker_02
Geez. I hated that. Cause I'm already so itchy. Yeah. I'm very itchy.
02:18:16 Speaker_08
I know you gotta, that walk was rough on you. I should have come and pick you up. I didn't see that text for a minute.
02:18:23 Speaker_02
Oh, that's fine. It's not like you're saying, I'm going to devote two hours every day to figuring out a pill that is costing you, that's taking away from your good life. But if it's just available, why wouldn't you?
02:18:36 Speaker_08
It's gene editing or something.
02:18:38 Speaker_02
And if we knew for sure it wasn't going to hurt you. But if you're saying we don't know for sure if it's going to hurt you, then you shouldn't do it.
02:18:46 Speaker_08
Well this is, we know. Yeah, then I don't see how. It's been on the market for 20 years and everyone who's taken it has never ever had a third drink, fourth, let's keep it at three.
02:18:54 Speaker_02
Okay. Then I don't see why there would ever be a problem.
02:18:58 Speaker_08
Well, right, it's just this weird feeling, it would feel like a lack of gratitude.
02:19:06 Speaker_02
No.
02:19:06 Speaker_08
For this great life I have.
02:19:07 Speaker_02
That's really warped, I think.
02:19:09 Speaker_08
Is it?
02:19:10 Speaker_02
It's not either or. You can be happy with your life and then also have a few drinks. Then there's this other cool thing that I can have with no cost.
02:19:19 Speaker_08
Yeah, it just feels greedy.
02:19:20 Speaker_02
That's like saying like, I shouldn't go to any parties because my life is so good. I shouldn't enjoy myself anymore. A really good time. Yeah.
02:19:33 Speaker_08
Yeah, I don't know why I feel that way, but I, it's linked to that kind of, it's probably good.
02:19:37 Speaker_02
You feel that way.
02:19:38 Speaker_08
Maybe that's because of AA, like maybe you're just, maybe it's ingrained and I think, you know, permanently, you know, even if they invented a pill, it's, I don't want to call brainwashing, but it is brainwashing in a very productive way. way.
02:19:51 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:19:53 Speaker_08
You really format your brain to think in a certain way. And I hear this from people all the time that like go back out, even if they do it successfully, people certainly do.
02:20:03 Speaker_08
I'm not one to say that like no one returns to it successfully, but even the ones that return to it successfully and when I've talked to them and they're honest, they're like, you know, it's still in there.
02:20:13 Speaker_08
They're like, even though it's fine, the like guilt and shame or I'm doing something I shouldn't do, like,
02:20:18 Speaker_00
Yeah.
02:20:18 Speaker_08
That's kind of a wrap on that, I think. I don't think you ever get your head back into it not being a very loaded thing, even if you succeed at doing it moderately or something.
02:20:28 Speaker_02
Sure. That makes sense. Yeah.
02:20:30 Speaker_08
My thought, I do believe people do it. I don't think they're lying to me when they say it's going fine. I can only imagine myself doing it, which would be
02:20:40 Speaker_08
I could do it, but it would require so much agony to control it that I don't think it would be a net win.
02:20:51 Speaker_08
When I did drink for a week without a paddle before the wheels came off, like when we were talking with Matt and Seth, I drank a glass and a half of wine every night or two glasses of wine for a week.
02:21:03 Speaker_08
And I can do that, but it's like I'm laying in bed after two glasses, white knuckling and going, you can have a third, don't have a third. If you have a third, you've broken your rule. No, you can have a third. Who cares? Third's nothing.
02:21:14 Speaker_08
No, you got to keep it at two. That was the rule. Like just take the madness of it. is it's so not worth the two glasses I was able to have.
02:21:24 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:21:25 Speaker_08
And also wine. That was part of the strategy. I'm like, I don't like wine. I'll get wine. I should, I should be able to resist having a third glass of wine.
02:21:34 Speaker_02
Wine's so good though.
02:21:36 Speaker_08
Well, it wasn't for me. You know, people have booze that they'll claim makes them mean. You know a lot of people have this. I don't drink wild turkey. Last time I did, I slapped my mother-in-law. It's like, okay. I don't drink tequila. It makes me angry.
02:21:53 Speaker_02
Or whiskey. Yeah, a lot of people can't drink brown liquor. That seems to be a thing.
02:21:57 Speaker_08
Which is racist. I know. All alcohols are. But let me just say that my most embarrassing, regrettable nights of drinking, 90% were when I drank too much wine. Hell yeah. I mean, I have one in particular that is so humiliating.
02:22:16 Speaker_08
And I think about it probably once a month.
02:22:18 Speaker_02
You do? What happened? What kind of wine was it? Oh, fuck.
02:22:22 Speaker_08
A red. I always drank a red. Sure.
02:22:25 Speaker_02
Like a cab?
02:22:26 Speaker_08
Erin and I, I mean, I can't even believe I'm gonna, this is so embarrassing. By the way, I just want to add to Aaron is perfect at, it's not like he doesn't correct my bad behavior.
02:22:38 Speaker_08
No, we both have a huge tolerance for bad behavior with each other, but there is, we're also semi responsible. So there's, we have gentle ways of going like, yeah, you were a little out of control. Yeah.
02:22:49 Speaker_08
So I was doing a car show in Carmel at the, that famous golf course. had something to do with the Course d'Elegance. There was like a Buick car show.
02:22:58 Speaker_10
Okay.
02:22:59 Speaker_08
Pebble Beach. And we're at this hotel and my brother had just started drinking. He hadn't drank for like 15 years and he started drinking again. Proved to not be a great idea, but he was sweetly kind of excited to drink with his brother.
02:23:13 Speaker_08
Cause I had been drinking that whole time. So he's like, oh great. We're going to drink. And you know, I lost control. I drank, you know, I drank a few bottles of red wine. By yourself. No, no. With Aaron and my brother.
02:23:26 Speaker_02
Oh, a few bottles split.
02:23:28 Speaker_08
No, no. I had a few bottles of wine.
02:23:29 Speaker_02
That was my ask. Okay. Yeah.
02:23:32 Speaker_08
And I think because we were close to wine country and we woke up in the morning, I was so hungover and it was a total blackout. Like I was missing a couple hours of the night.
02:23:45 Speaker_08
And Erin gently said, do you know how many times you asked your brother if he knew what the starting point is?
02:23:53 Speaker_02
Oh, my God. I can't even say it out loud. You have told me this before. I have? Yeah, you have. I commend you that you talk about it.
02:24:02 Speaker_08
Oh, fuck. Yeah, that's when the monster in me would come out, when I was really, really hammered.
02:24:07 Speaker_02
Can you say it again? Because I'm not sure.
02:24:08 Speaker_08
I know, I don't want to say it again. Can you say it? I mean, it really still sears my soul. He said, do you know how many times you asked your brother if he knew the starting grade point average at UCLA? Yeah. Oh my God.
02:24:22 Speaker_02
What's funny is that you're so embarrassed by that.
02:24:25 Speaker_08
Because I know what I was doing. I'm trying to self-aggrandize myself. I'm like in that bad zone of drunk I would get sometimes where it was like, I couldn't slake my ego's lust.
02:24:38 Speaker_10
Oh, interesting.
02:24:39 Speaker_08
I needed to like bra, like I needed to be important. I needed to be, yeah. And I just, and I'm like, no, how many times he goes, dude, I mean, oh my God, maybe 30. I was like, oh my God, what was it like? DeLene was slurring me, oh fuck.
02:24:59 Speaker_02
But did Aaron, was he blackout too? Like I assume everyone's blackout.
02:25:03 Speaker_08
No, Aaron was drunk, but he didn't blackout.
02:25:06 Speaker_02
Oh, and your brother also wasn't?
02:25:07 Speaker_08
There's wine, I don't like, I could drink a fifth of Jack, no problem, and not blackout, but this wine got me, as it often did. Wow. And then another time, I just took Nate to task one time on a balcony.
02:25:19 Speaker_02
What do you, what'd you ask him?
02:25:19 Speaker_08
In the most regrettable way imaginable. And I just, I woke up the next day and I was like, oh my God. I was saying things I don't even believe.
02:25:26 Speaker_02
Right.
02:25:30 Speaker_08
You know what it really was? I was hurt I didn't have a bigger role in the movie he produced. That's what was really going on.
02:25:36 Speaker_02
Oh, because you were Vomiteer.
02:25:37 Speaker_08
That's right. I was Vomiteer at the party. And I think I wanted a character name. And I was hammered on his ex-girlfriend's balcony with him on wine.
02:25:49 Speaker_02
Oh wow.
02:25:50 Speaker_08
And I just really started being horrendous.
02:25:54 Speaker_02
Oh no.
02:25:54 Speaker_08
Fuck, but I remembered that. I guess it wasn't a blackout, because the next morning I was like. And you apologized? I mean, what were you saying to Nate? Did you apologize? The sweetest, yes.
02:26:03 Speaker_02
That's nice of you.
02:26:04 Speaker_08
I always apologize.
02:26:05 Speaker_02
That's like a lot of people, I've done it, where I am like, I don't think that was my best showing. But also, but if everyone else is drunk, I do a bad job of not appalling.
02:26:21 Speaker_02
I'm just kind of like, let's just, no one needs to talk about anything anyone did, because everyone did embarrassing shit.
02:26:28 Speaker_08
And that's a covenant. Like my friends in Detroit, who we all drank so hard. I mean, that's what we did. We all were I'm not gonna call them anything, but we were all fucking- Drinking to excess. Till six in the morning and, you know, getting ugly.
02:26:43 Speaker_02
Yeah.
02:26:44 Speaker_08
And we had a pact. Yeah, you didn't really have to ever say sorry. Right. But there were definitely incidents where I don't think there was any other option. Like I woke up in the morning, I was like, well, that was damaging to our friendship.
02:26:55 Speaker_10
Yeah.
02:26:56 Speaker_08
Like that was, if I just never say anything to Nate, that would have been, I think, very damaging to our friendship. Because it was a very ugly side of myself that I,
02:27:04 Speaker_08
I don't, I mean, you could argue, well, it is a side yourself because it came up, but I can't even really relate. Sober, I don't even have those thoughts I was having. I don't think any of those things.
02:27:14 Speaker_02
That is what's interesting for me. I think in these, when there's like scuffles or fights or emotional stuff that happened, sometimes I do apologize. now. But it's tricky because often whatever is being said and what's coming out, I do believe.
02:27:34 Speaker_08
Right.
02:27:35 Speaker_02
I want those things out there. Right. And it's sometimes it's not good that it takes the alcohol to say it.
02:27:43 Speaker_08
But you don't regret that it's known.
02:27:45 Speaker_02
Exactly. So then it gets like, it's a little bit tricky. I mean, of course it's apologizing for the way it happened, but then you're sober and then you have to revisit it.
02:27:55 Speaker_08
And like, I mean, my God, there is nothing like laying in your bed with a fucking pounding headache and, and just replaying all the events. I mean, it's, it's, it's so morbid. Oh, I miss it so much. This was a processing fact check.
02:28:13 Speaker_02
It was, it was. Which is ding, ding, ding to the government.
02:28:19 Speaker_08
That's right, they process a lot of stuff.
02:28:20 Speaker_02
They process stuff. All right, love you. All right, I love you.
02:28:38 Speaker_08
Follow Armchair Expert on the Wondery app, Amazon Music, or wherever you get your podcasts. You can listen to every episode of Armchair Expert early and ad-free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple Podcasts.
02:28:52 Speaker_08
Before you go, tell us about yourself by completing a short survey at wondery.com slash survey.
02:28:58 Speaker_00
Your business deploys AI pilots everywhere. But are they going anywhere? Or are they stuck in silos, exhausting resources, unable to scale? Maybe you don't need hundreds of AI pilots. You need a holistic strategy.
02:29:12 Speaker_00
IBM has 65,000 consultants with Gen AI expertise who can help you design, integrate, and optimize AI solutions. So you're not just deploying AI, you're scaling it across your business. Learn more at ibm.com slash consulting. IBM, let's create.